Alexandra Kollontai
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-03-24Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 12
Cathy Nugent
The Russian revolutionary, Alexandra Kollontai, is best known for her organisational work among Russian working class women prior to, and immediately after, the 1917 revolution and also for her writings on sexual morality and the family. She has become better known largely as the result of feminist interest in her life and career.
At the end of her life Kollontai made this comment: "Women and their fate occupied me all of my life and concern for their lot brought me to socialism."
Kollontai did see her "special mission" as fighting for the interests of working class women. However, when she wrote some of her best pieces concerning women's oppression during the 1920s (e.g. "Communism and the Family" *Sexual Relations and Class Struggle") Kollontai had retreated from any political struggle within the Communist Party. She had found herself unable to cope with the terrifying realities of Soviet Russia: economic chaos, poverty, a growing bureaucracy in the party and state. She was writing in a vacuum and this, inevitably, weakens some of her speculations, analysis and political conclusions.
Anonymity
Eventually Kollontai "chose" life of anonymity, exile and loneliness as a Soviet diplomat. She refused to take part in the fight against the bureaucracy which would have meant certain death at the hands of Stalin's thugs...capitulation but at what personal and psychological cost we do not know and Kollontai deserves a better write-up than this.
Alexandra Mikailovna Domontovich was born in 1872 in St. Petersburg. Her father was a Tsarist general, her mother the daughter of a wealthy timber merchant. She married Vladimir Kollontai against her parents wishes and for love in 1893.
As a young woman Kollontai was impressed by the ideas of radical liberals. One of their goals was the emancipation of women. Through combatting prejudice and campaigning for better education for women, the injustice of women's oppression could be destroyed. Of course this was not an option for working class women. Kollontai came towards a socialist understanding through her observation of the conditions of work of St. Petersburg's women textile workers. In 1896 these women came out on strike. Kollontai became involved in the young Russian socialist movement.
In 1898 Kollontai left her husband, turned her back on her family and privileged background and went to Zurich to study political economy. She continued her association with Russian socialists WOMEN'S Labour CONFERENCE'87 FIGHTBACK women: our alternative Abour women: back to asics in exile. She returned Russia. in the following year, full-time political activity!
During this period strong bourgeois women's movements emerged, largely organising around the question of women's suffrage. The international socialist movement was divided on the question. Although most, rightly, opposed votes for women on the basis of property qualification, there was a generalised hostility to the "woman question" in the social democratic parties. Against this background Kollontai began to develop her ideas.
In 1906 Kollontai was involved in trying to establish a Women Workers' Bureau. In 1908 the first Women's Congress of the Russian Social Democratic and Labour Party was held.
At that congress both Menshevik and Bolshevik wings of the Party argued that genuine social emancipation for women was impossible without working class revolution. At that point it was still unclear what the Bolsheviks' attitude to women's work was. Certainly it evolved over a period of time, shaped not only by the efforts of Kollontai and other socialist women, but also through the involvement of working class women in the revolution.
Kollontai herself did not join the Bolsheviks until 1915. She was aloof from early factional battles between the Mensheviks and Bolsheviks. Her own political education was protracted. Kollontai's writings and political positions suffer from certain theoretical weakness. It also seems she was unable to accept herself as an equal in political activity. All this is best explained by her background and the position of women in society.
In 1909 "The Social Basis of the Woman Question" was published. Here Kollontai argues strongly that women must take up the struggle for their own interests within the social democratic parties. It is a polemic against bourgeois feminism (at the time this was synonymous with feminism and against separate women's movement.
Some critics have argued that Kollontai was too soft on social democracy and its ability to represent working class women. But social democracy - and in particular the German party — had not yet betrayed the working class through support for the First World War. To Kollontai things were clearcut:
*The women's world is divided just as is the world of men, into two camps. The interests and aspirations of one group of women bring SUBSCRIBE SUBSCRIBE TO WOMEN'S Get WF delivered to your door each month by post. Rates £1.50 for six months, E2.50 for a year.
Name.
Address Please send me 6/12 months subcription to WF. I enclose E To: WF, Po. Box 823, London SEI5 4NA. Cheques payable to Women's Fightback. it close to the bourgeois class, while the other group of women has close connections with the proletariat and its claims for liberation encompass tion! solution to the woman quesIn 1908 Kollontai escaped arrest by fleeing to Western Europe. She joined the German Social Democratic Party. There she gained valuable experience of the German women's organisation and general methods of work among working class women. When the SPD supported the war effort Kollontai was shocked, although she had first hand knowledge of the party.
To be fair, it must have seemed incredible. Kollontai however, did not have the ability to either express or explain the betrayal of the party in political terms: "During the first days of the war I was oppressed by the awareness that the German party was destroyed. (now) it seems to me things have worked out for the best. Social Democracy has found itself in a cul-de-sac. Its creativity has dried up. It had become set in its ways. There was no spirit, no enthusiasm. Tradition and routine held sway."
In 1917 Kollontai took on a leading role. She was a talented and popular pamphleteer and agitator and she continued her organisational work among women and was centrally involved in the production of Robotnisa (Working Women), the Bolshevik Party paper for After the October revolution she was named as Commissar of Social Welfare and in that position was responsible for the drafting of important legislation: the establishment of civil marriage, easy divorce, equal pay for women and labour protection for women. In November 1918 the first All-Russian Conference of Proletarian and Peasant Women was held. 1000 delegates attended - an indicator of how many women's lives had been changed by the revolution, how far reaching the involvement of women had been. sion of the had the promo *freedo Kolloi Her prit self-orga class. H position the polit This wa were b Workers beaten.
Proba after thi rememb the Part forelock tolerant of works, 1 tionships are not within s not the various 1 phenome post-rev Kollonta cibly ta moreove marginal (indeed here) bur *Thro human h find a ti sex havi place in 19 the Women's Commisthe Bolshevik Party was I by women's departments. 's work could now be much itegrated and influential in k of the party. Kollontai roposed just these arents in 1906. 21 Kollontai joined a faction Bolshevik Party called the s' Opposition. They accused arty and state of ratisation. The soviets had empty shells - what was was a reform programme ting democracy and m of opinion" ntai's motives were sound. nciple of socialism was the anisation of the working owever, the Workers' Opwere too trenchant against rical leadership of the party. is not yet bankrupt. They refore their time. The ¿ Opposition was soundly ibly Kollontai lost faith s and her involvement in the rs' Opposition was ered by those elements in y who were toe-lickers and -touchers who were inof unorthodoxy - the doxy Kollontai displayed in Relations and the Class ¡exual Relations" and other Kollontai argues that relas between men and women unaffected by changes ociety. Of course she was only writer to take up themes about how cultural ena were being reflected in olutionary society. But i was the only writer to forake up this issue and I argue that it was not I. She was being polemical there is much bitterness t to her it is central. ughout the long journey of listory you probably won't ime when the problems of : occupied such a central the life of soçiety."
Her sense of bitterness spills over into her view of human relationships as connections that only reinforce alienation and loneliness:
"People have perhaps never in any age felt spiritual loneliness as seep lymed persistently as at the preHere, she is being specific. In the era of decaying capitalism, human relationships, especially relationships between men and women are like this.
Yet Kollontai is optimistic — too optimistic - because the changes she wanted to see were impossible in the wrecked society of Soviet Russia. For her a "spiritual revolution" was one of the core problems of evolving socialist society. And she is right. But such changes are evolutionary even with the promotion of collective households and so on.
Kollontai made her vacuum.
1923 By 1923 Kollontai had ceased to write. She was pushed into diplomatic career. Kollontai's strengths and weaknesses were shaped by the fact of her sex. Kollontai-had a vision of a better way of living. They called her utopian and we could, too, yet for much of her life she was a determined practical socialist and a fighter for working class women.
Her attempts to uncover the moral straightjackets and material deprivation that are forced on women by society and the personal, individual anguish that accompanies this was, in her time, unique:
*The woman talked. Her eyes seemed to question life. You could catch in her look all the despair, all the horror of being a woman alone and faced with unemployment.
Here was a woman trying to be independent and trying to fight her old way of life...lt demanded an answer...it demanded action...it demanded struggle."
Sisters)
----- pull-quotes -----
FIGHT ALTON