Place of safety
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-03-24Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 6
doing good. But the people they helped were different. They praised God for the sisters' good works, but they praised God too for sending Babette with her magical gifts.
For Babette, her joy is in giving happiness to those who helped her, and giving it the best way she knows - through her art. Babette's own life may be ever blighted by the loss of her loved ones, but she believes in life, and in the importance of happiness.
What she shows is that there is nothing to be gained from repressing the senses; rather that there is everything to be gained by not repressing them, by being open to life and life's gifts. Babette experiences poignant happiness in practising her art again. In sniffing her Clos de Vougeot, she is taking in all the fragrance of the life she left behind.
The art of a chef in a luxury restaurant is not very democratic. Karen Blixen did not address this question; but then she was an aristocratic rebel against capitalist society, not a socialist. It's a satisfactory film, full of small, telling details that build up a rich picture. It's nice to see a film that says that happiness is our birthright.
In fighting with the Communards, Babette was fighting for a fair life for all, for the right of people to happiness. Though she was beaten, she didn't lose her faith, and she tried to pass it on. Place of Safety' (ITV, Monday 14 March) was - almost openly - about the Cleveland child sexual abuse case.
According to the TV critic of the Guardian, it ended, maybe, with a faint hint of a possibility that the father might have assaulted his own two children. But that wasn't how it struck me at all.
The only time in the play when it seemed to me that you might be intended to think him guilty was when he seemed completely uninterested in finding out whether or not his second child had also been assaulted.
For the rest it was a powerful and straightforward story of a family whose children are taken into carr after doctors decide that they hav been assaulted, "probably" by their father.
The father at the end leaves home after a third child is born, telling his wife to tell the social services whatever they want to hear, so that they'll allow the mother and the children to be together again.
This was a polemic from Stuart Bell camp in the Cleveland case. Shuan Prendergast gave a very good and moving performance as the father who is wrongly accused. To be so accused must be horrible beyond belief.
The play underlined the need for better procedures than those which allow far-reaching decisions to be taken by social services workers on the presumption of a parent's "probable" guilt and with no right of appeal.
But it laid it on with a trowel. For example, the children are taken away in the middle of the night. Everything was presented in terms of a hostile and perhaps malevolent "them" picking on innocent people, almost as if there wasn't a massive problem of undetected child sexual abuse.
There is. And the Cleveland case called forth a storm of hostility against those who - too zealously and recklessly it seems - tried to do something about it.
That episode has probably set back by years the battle to end what is perhaps the greatest single outrage in British society -something going on all about us right now. This effective and moving play is unfortunately part of the backlash. take on the nuclear industry, passing on the bill for the costly mistake of nuclear power to us?
Hotrocks on Good news now about safe nuclear power. I refer to the experimental geothermal ('hot rocks') scheme in Cornwall. The principle of the scheme is this. There is a considerable amount of heat inside the Earth, generated by the decay of radioactive elements naturally present. This heat keeps the Earth's core molten and makes the rocks nearer the surface quite hot.
The Cornwall scheme is a way of tappng that heat.. Holes are drilled 1-2 km deep and explosives detonated to crack the rocks. Water is pumped down one hole, heated as it percolates through the cracks, and then emerges through another hole.
At present, water at 60°C is being produced. This could be used for heating homes. Planned deeper holes could provide water at 200°C, enough to generate electricity.
The Cornish hot rocks are nearer the surface than average, so the heat is more easily obtained. But it should be possible to extract geothermal energy elsewhere in Britain, giving a virtually endless supply of energy.
The good news? The government has reversed a previous decision and will continue to fund the scheme, after all