Ford and the AEU
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-03-24Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 5
Socialist Organiser no.350 24 March 1988 Page 9 On Monday evening the TUC narrowly voted to support the AEU's attempt to get a single-union deal at the proposed new Ford plant in Dundee. This deal would break up the national union negotiating structure in Ford's UK plants, but the TUC was desperate to persuade Ford bosses in Detroit to reverse their decision to pull out.
The TUC decision came after days of public pressure from Tory ministers and from trade union and Labour leaders for the TGWU and MSF (TASSASTMS) to back down on their opposition to the deal.
Alex Glasgow explains the issues behind the row. The recent decision by Ford Motor Company to drop plans to set up a plant in Dundee, allegedly due to inter-union wrangling involving the Transport and General Workers Union (TGWU) and the Amalgamated Engineering Union (AEU) has led to many bitter accusations mostly about the behaviour of the TGWU.
The plant would have created 450 jobs directly and another 500 jobs through a knock-on effect on the local economy. Trade unions are now under attack for supposedly being responsible for the loss of these jobs.
Scottish Secretary of State Malcolm Rifkind has talked of "extraordinary trade union neanderthal attitudes while Scottish Industry minister lan Laing has referred to trade union leaders as "bone-headed prehistoric monsters". Such insults are pretty cheap coming from Tories who have supported and implemented policies which have cost workers both in Scotland and elswhere tens of thousands of jobs.
Attempts to scapegoat the TGWU for Ford's decision to pull-out of Dundee do not tally with the facts.
The TGWU was in dispute with the AEU both at the latter's attempt to stitch-up a single union no-strike deal with Ford in breach of the Blue Book national agreement (a multi-union agreement that governs pay and working conditions at Ford's 22 plants in Britain).
Ford and the AEU claimed that the Blue Book should not apply in Dundee as the plant was to be part of the Ford electrical and electronics division (EED) rather than part of Ford of Britain. But three of the existing Ford plants in Britain are in the EED and covered by the Blue Book. Why should Dundee be any different?
The reason is that if the Dundee plant was covered by the Blue Book, then it would have to have wages in line with the car industry rather than those prevalent in the electronics industry. The former are up to 50% higher than the latter.
Workers' Liberty will take place in 2-3 July Special courses • The national tion •Party and class •Workers in Eastern Europe There will also be an Introducing Marxism series for those new to socialism.
More details from Mark Osborn, PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA.
Ford's announcement to pull-out of Dundee came only a week after the TUC General Secretary Norman Willis had met the Ford EED management in the USA and been told that there was no deadline for reaching an agreement with the unions and that no decisions would be taken without further consultations with the unions involved.
At the same time the TGWU had announced that it was prepared to make a number of concessions and the TUC had postponed proceedings with union complaints against the AEU. The Scottish TUC had also arranged a meeting to work out a "compromise solution.
So why did Ford pull out just when the trade unions were on the verge of reaching agreement? The timing of the announcement strengthens the argument that Ford's real concern in the affair was to destabilise union agreements elsewhere in Britain through establishing single-union low-pay bridgehead in Dundee.
A further fact behind the Ford decision was the recent strike by Ford workers in Britain. Although it could have won far more than it did the concessions forced out of Ford led the top Ford management to fear that the Dundee plant's workforce might not be as docile as had been hoped (courtesy of the AEU).
Even AEU officials accept this as a fact behind the Ford decision. Do those who now condemn the TGWU also condemn Ford workers for going on strike in defence of their living standards and working conditions?
The TGWU were trying to defend trade union rights, rates of pay and working conditions. As bureaucrats they inevitably attempted to do so in negotiations behind closed doors rather than through campaigning in public to clarify the issues involved. And as bureaucrats, they were prepared to make major concessions to fix up a deal.
The role of AEU leaders such as Gavin Laird in the affair is very different. Laird in a personal capacity is a member of the Scottish Development Agency (SDA) which won Ford over to setting up its plant in Dundee. Aware of Ford's plans through his membership of SDA, Laird struck his single-union no strike agreement with Ford before the project had even been publicly announced.
This is the trade union equivalent of "insider-dealing' in the Stock Market. In reaching agreement with Ford Laird was prepared to trample basic trade union principles underfoot - poaching on other unions' territory, selling out the right to strike and undercutting rates of pay elsewhere in Ford's UK operations. Hardly surprisingly Laird is now the Tories' hero and the hero of every other enemy of the trade union movement. and rightly so.
At the end of the day, the basic question is whether trade unions should accept jobs at any price. The answer must be no. If Ford (with the assistance of the AEU leaders) had got its way, rates of pay in the combine would have been dragged down and trade union organisation weakened — and the ability of Ford management to axe jobs through work speed-ups would consequently have been strengthened.
The TGWU officials are certainly not beyond criticism. They too operated behind closed doors rather than explaining and winning support for their stand in public. They also seem to have been prepared to make far reaching concessions to management. Even so, in contrast to Laird, they still managed to retain a commitment to some basic trade union principles.
----- pull-quotes -----
Workers' 88 Liberty summer school