[public were defined. Anxious to intain the friendship…]
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-03-24Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 5
public were defined. Anxious to intain the friendship of the rkish Government (created by a rent revolution, and under essure from Britain and France) : Soviet government made conisions, a number of which were at e expense of the Armenians. The regions of Kars and Ardakan re ceded to Turkey. Nakhichevan a pocket of Azerbaijani populain on the far side of Armenia — is attached as an administrative it to the Azerbaijan Soviet public, whilst Karabakh was left an Armenian enclave within viet Azerbaijan.
The three republics of Armenia, terbaljan and Georgia were soon irged into a single Transcaucasian deration, though not without bitdisputes within the Communist rty. In the debates on the namal question in the run-up to the 3 conference of the Soviet Comnist Party, the proposal to form h a federation was singled out as example of Greater Russian auvinism masquerading as pcialist" opposition to naalist deviations.
the early 1920s Bolsheviks h as Narimanov had argued for creation of autonomous ¡bles in the Caucasus, tederated the rest of the Soviet Union.
position was shared by Lenin a majority of the Bolshevik tral Committee. Most eran" Bolsheviks in the esus, however, opposed such osals as a repugnant gical deviation in the direcnationalism.
As the Stalinist elite emerged as the new rulers of the Soviet Union, the Transcaucasian Federation became the framework within which the local party leadership was purged by the usual methods of the firing squad and Siberian exile. Only after the Stalin constitution of 1936 did Armenia, Georgia and Azerbaijan again emerge as separate states.
Stalin made Armenia a showcase for the success of "socialist planning" and "enlightened" policies on the national question. The Armenians, unlike the other minority nations, were almost junior partners with the Great Russians in running From 1945 onwards Armenians living abroad were encouraged to return "home" , and substantial immigration from Persia, Turkey and the Lebanon did indeed occur, with the Republic's population increasing from 1,320,000 in 1940 to 3,317,000 in 1985. The success of local economic policies (at least as compared with the rest of the Soviet Union) is reflected in the fact that the proportion of families in Armenia owning a motor car and a television is the highest in the Soviet Union.
The memory of the holocaust of 1915 and the continued oppression of Armenians in Turkey has ensured that hostility towards Turkey remains dominant in Armenian nationalism. On the 50th anniversary of the 1915 measures, mass demonstrations in Yerevan, the capital of Armenia, escaped the control of the bureaucracy, with disturbances continuing into the night. The First Secretary of the local Communist Party was scapegoated and deposed.
The demand for the incorporation of Nakhichevan into Armenia has also remained a source of discontent. Hundreds of Armenians were massacred there in the period 1919-20 by local Azerbaijanis, acting under the orders of Turkish army officers. But today the Armenian population of Nakhichevan is well below 50%.
The more immediate source of contention is Karabakh, where (according to the "Minority Rights Group" report on the Armenians) Armenians are 80% of the population. (Walker, author of "Armenia — the survival of a nation" puts the figure at 85%).
As the Minority Rights Group report points out: "In (Karabakh) Armeno-Azeri inter-communal clashes and riots are not uncommon. The Armenian majority complain bitterly and quite openly about discrimination against them exercised by the Azerbaijan Tatar government in Baku."
The government's principaland thoroughly inadequate — argument against transfer of Karabakh is that its mountains are used by Azeri shepherds as summer pastures for their flocks.
The more likely reason for refusal to transfer Karabakh from Azerbaijan to Armenia is the fear that this would unleash a series of similar, and more far-reaching, demands throughout the rest of the Soviet Union, possibly leading to its complete break-up.
That the Soviet Union might suffer such a fate as its oppressed nationalities struggle for their rights is of no concern to socialsts. What is of concern to socialists is that the struggle for national rights should not result in the creation of new oppressed national minorities.
The Armenians are a people who saw one in three of their number wiped off the face of the earth in the course of a quarter of a century. Despite the relatively better conditions enjoyed by sections of the Armenian community in the nationality.
At the same time, the existence of Armenian-Azeri communal strife and antagonisms must be recognised, a produet of the events of the last hundred years. The Armenians have been victim of communal persecution but have also paid back their opponents "in their own coin"
A regulation of such intercommunal antagonisms cannot be achieved "from above" . The creation ot the Transcaucasian Federation by a Communist Party which had not yet undergone a Stalinist degeneration is evidence of this. And in any case, what is today "above" the oppressed nationalities of the Soviet Union is the Stalinist bureaucracy, which is inherently incapable of resolving the national question on a democratic basis.
Socialists should therefore support transfer of Karabakh (but not Nakhichevan) to the Armenian Republic, whilst at the same time striving to ensure that this does not lead to any oppression of the minority Azeri population of Karabakh.
To win full dmeocratic rights for all the oppressed peoples of the Soviet Union, and the replacement of communal antagonisms by peaceful mutual self-respect, the workers will have to overthrow the Stalinist rule which perpetuates such communal and national divisions and antagonisms.
----- pull-quotes -----
Caucasus, under both Tsarism and Stalinism, they remain an oppressed