Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Ireland: what's the answer?

Socialist Organiser no. 350, 24 March 1988 · scan p. 3 · about 1,418 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

OVER THE last few weeks in Northern Ireland, we have had a small-scale demonstration of what Protestant-Catholic civil war would be like.

Catholic people attending a political funeral are attacked by a Protestant with a gun and grenades. Three die. 60 are injured.

That night, a Catholic crowd goes on the rampage, attacking some Protestants.

A week later, at another IRA funeral, two British soldiers are captured, beaten, stripped and lynched.

There have been a number of sectarian attacks, and Protestant paramilitary groups threaten more.

Imagine these events repeated across Northern Ireland where the Catholic and Protestant communities overlap, and you have a situation like Lebanon or Sri Lanka.

The tabloid press reacts to these events with typical irresponsibility. The Sun's front page quotes the understandable feelings the grandmother of one of the soldiers stripped and killed - that the Republicans should be strung up -and makes this its siogan. The Evening Standard produces a racist cartoon by 'Jak'.

Last week they praised the bravery of unarmed Republican youths who tackled and captured the gunman who attacked the first funeral. One of those youths was killed. This week they talk of the "savages' of West Belfast.

It is understandable why people who last week were bombed in Milltown Cemetery, Belfast, might attack and kill two armed men who drive a car, horn blazing, into the funeral cortege. Nevertheless it is undeniable that the killing of the soldiers was peculiarly horrible.

Where does the horror come from? Who is responsible for it? How can full-scale civil war be prevented? What is the solution?

In Ireland people talk about 'the politics of the last atrocity'. This means that public opinion shifts from one side to another after each horror. It shifted against the IRA after Enniskillen last November; it swung towards them after the Protestant attack on the funeral; it is swinging against the Republicans and the Catholics after the lynching of the two soldiers.

The capitalist press has seized on the latest horror to wipe from cialist Organis • Box 823, London SE 4NA 63817965 atest date for reports: Tir ost Monday or by phon dita ypesetting: Upstream Lt Ul 01-358 1344 Published by Socialist Organiser, PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA.

Last Gmphics (TU). Registered as a PostOlice, Signed articles do no necessarily reflect the view of natiOr daniler. public memory: • The cold-blooded killing by the SAS, without charge or trial, of three unarmed Republicans in Gibraltar. • The Stalker affair - the Government's protection of those in the Northern Ireland police force (the RUC) who ran a killer squad which murdered Republicans and a nonpolitical 17 year old, Michael Teague. • The proven collaboration between sections of the RUC and Protestant paramilitary killers like the man who attacked the mourners at Milltown Cemetery.

More than that, the labour movement needs to keep the basic facts of the case in mind. These are:

For centuries the Catholics of Ireland were oppressed by the British ruling class. For a hundred years in the 18th century they lived under a system of legal discrimination very similar to South Africa's discriminatory laws against blacks.

Majority

When the majority of the Irish people finally fought to win their freedom from British control, a minority in Ireland - the Protestants — were used by the British ruling class against the majority.

A democratic solution could have allowed the Irish majority and minority to sort out their affairs on the basis of minority rights for the natural Irish minority. But the British ruling class used the minority first as an argument against the idea that the Irish majority should have the independence it wanted, and then as shock troops with guns in their hands to oppose it.

When it proved impossible any longer to resist the demands of the Irish majority, Ireland was partitioned into two states. The Six Counties of Northern Ireland remained with Britain.

This was no clean partition between Catholic nationalists and Protestant Unionists. One in three of the people of the Six Counties were Catholics and nationalists who wanted an independent Ireland. In border areas - Fermanagh, South Tyrone, etc. — where they were the majority, they were kept in the Six Counties by force.

They were a bigger minority of the Six Counties' population than the Protestant-Unionists of all Ireland would have been in a 32-County state.

The Catholics in the Six County state were treated as second-class citizens. They were discriminated against in jobs, housing,. and politics. The Protestant majority lived in very great fear of this Catholic minority, which owed allegiance to the other Irish state. A sectarian police force was used to keep Catholics down.

Special police powers, including the right of internment without trial, were used against Catholic nationalists.

In 1967-8, after nearly 50 years of this, the Catholics started a civil rights movement modelled on the movement of the US blacks. They One of the two soldiers killed on met police violence and a strong Orange-Unionist movement in opposition to their demands.

In August 1969 serious CatholicProtestant fighting broke out in Belfast and Derry, and the British Army was moved onto the streets to "keep order'. Instead of changing anything fundamental, Britain's then Labour Government tinkered with the system, leaving Catholics still unsatisfied. The IRA military campaign developed from early 1971.

In 1972 Britain abolished local majority rule — it had always been Protestant sectarian rule - in Belfast. Since then Northern Ireland has been ruled from London. Nothing fundamental has changed. The war between Britain and the IRA, and on the ground between the Catholic and Protestant communities, has gone on without interruption ever since.

Catholics feel oppressed, and they are. Protestants tear being an oppressed minority in an all-Ireland Catholic state!

In November 1985 the Dublin and London governments signed the Anglo-Irish Agreement. Dublin would share political responsibility for running Northern Ireland, in an advisory capacity.

In recent months things have increasingly gone wrong for London and Dublin in Northern Ireland. The Stalker affair, London's unresponsiveness to Dublin's demands for change in Northern Ireland's grossly unfair judicial system, and the Gibraltar killings, have generated tensions between the two Governments. Tensions betaturday ween the two communities have grown, and are still growing.

British policy continues to be one of 'holding the ring', and hoping things will one day calm down. But the latest series of killings, 17 years into the British-IRA war, proves once more that no solution is possible within the present Six Counties entity. The Northern Ireland state is artificial and unviable, a beargarden for its two communities.

The solution is to recast the British-Irish state system: • Unite Ireland on a basis of consistent democracy • Create autonomous regional government for the Protestant area (and for Catholic pockets within that Protestant-majority area • Create a closer link between Britain and Ireland, replacing the old forced links by voluntary and free cooperation • On the basis of such a political solution, withdraw British troops.

To simply demand troops out now, even without a political solution - as some sections of the left do - is a recipe for bloody sectarian civil war on the Lebanese scale, out of which could only come two Irish states with a different border.

The greatest obscenity and horror of Northern Ireland under British and Irish capitalist rule is that the Protestant and Catholic workers who live in adjoining slums fight each other and fear each other. They suffer a common oppression at the hands of capitalism, but have been unable to unite as a class to do anything about it.

Socialist The democratic programme of a free united Ireland with regional autonomy within it is not something socialists offer as advice to the ruling class, in Dublin, in Belfast, or in London. It is a programme on the basis of which Catholic and Protestant workers could unite — the Protestants offering the Catholics help to escape their oppression, and the Catholics offering the Protestant workers guarantees that they will not be oppressed as a permanent minority in a Catholic-dominated Ireland.

The British government presents itself as a force for stability and *law and order' in Northern Ireland. It is not. It is a force for propping up the unjust and unviable Partition settlement. British Government policy is maintaining and building up the conditions for sectarian civil war.

FLOTIO! numbers - Pago •The whole IRA should be put on an island and nave a bomb dropped on won't see Derek again"

Hysteria March

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 350

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →