Are Israel and South Afri
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-03-10Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
Socialist Organiser no.349 10 March 1988, Page 10 The uprising in the Israelioccupied West Bank and Gaza readily calls to mind township upheavals in South Africa. It has been spearheaded by the youth. The refugee camps, overcrowded slums that are an affront to civilised values" according even to David Mellor, resemble South African black townships.
The bare-faced brutality of the Israeli Army (like the South African, called a Defence Force') is not so different from the activities of the South African soldiers with their sjamboks whom we used to be able to see in television news reports.
The Palestine Liberation Organisation and the African National Congress openly identify with each other, and the Israeli and South African governments are on such good terms that they have developed nuclear weapons together.
The similarities and links are there for all to see. But they are not a sufficient foundation for a socialist policy. In making solidarity with the Palestinian struggle, socialists need a firm analysis, a clear, materialist understanding of what is going on. And despite the undoubted similarities, Israel is a very different society to South Africa.
It is important to look at these differences, because for many socialists a failure to do so has led to confused and confusing political positions. If you think that Israel is essentially identical to South Africa, then the slogan for "secular democratic state' in Palestine seems the same as that of a unitary, non-racial South Africa', , with one person, one vote. Proposals for an independent Palestinian state seem like the 'bantustan' policy of the South African government.
Socialist Organiser does argue for a 'two states' policy in the Middle East. Our opponents often argue that logically, if we favour the right of the Israeli Jews to self-determination, we should equally support the South African whites' right to a separate state. But this argument — the direct parallel between Israel and South Africa - is utterly superticial and lacking in historical analysis.
The Israeli Jews are a nation; the South African whites are a ruling caste. This is a material fact, which affects the dynamics of conflict in FRAT the two cases and the expressions of this conflict ideologically. It determines the political attitude of socialists: in general we accept the right of nations to self-determination but call for the destruction of caste-systems. Moreover, it affects the attitudes of participants in the two conflicts.
Distinct
That the Israeli Jews are a distinct nation is now commonplace among Palestinian nationalists and Israeli radicals. Not everyone accepts it as a fact: but those who do, that no fully formed nations or nationalities have yet emerged in South Africa. The situation is still tlud. But that it is radically ditterent from Israel/Palestine is obvious. Would anyone argue that the development of capitalism had created one nation in Israel/Palestine? It would be absurd to do so.
One of the peculiarities of Israeli capitalist development has been the attempt to exclude non-Jewish labour. Today, Arab labour is important in the Israeli economy -but Arabs are a marginalised, super-exploited minority layer of the working class - a *subproletariat' . In South Africa the exploitation of black labour has been the essential basis for capitalist development, and black workers constitute the vast majority of the working class.
This distinction is important. Consider a parallel. The PLO has been prepared for many years to accept an independent Palestinian state next to Israel; the secular democratic state they see only as a long-term objective.
Certain forces do support on the Palestinian side as well as on the Israeli, are by no means a small minority. The South African whites - ОГ even the Afrikaners -are a fully-fledged, distict ration is not coherently argued by anybody on the South African left.
Indeed, since the 1950s (when the Congress Alliance was organised on separate white-African-ColouredIndian lines) the general trend within progressive forces in South Africa has been towards a more consistent 'non-racialism'. As COSATU's founding conference expressed it, "the development of capitalism in South Africa has created one nation."
Now maybe it could be argued 'independent African 'states' " (i.e. the homelands) in South Africa -but not the ANC or any serious force in the liberation movement. If the parallels are direct, Yasser Arafat must be worse than Chief Gatsha Buthelezi. Yet the real equivalents of Buthelezi, or other tame black leaders, are proJordanian or Israeli-sponsored "quislings' in the occupied territories, who far from wanting an independent Palestine are prepared to accept Israeli (or Jordanian) rule.
In real terms there is no 'compromise that the South African equivalents of the PLO could accept that is comparable to a West Bank-Gaza state. They might accept compromise on the question of one person, one vote in a unitary South Africa; but they would not be territorial compromises - they would not result in an independent "black' state alongside awhite In certain respects, various political forces in South African history have advocated "black independence' • But the concept of *non-racialism' is a profoundly progressive departure from such limited black or African tionalism. The 'non-racialists in South Africa are the least nationalist, the most prepared to involve whites.
But within the PLO, the seculardemocratic state is a hard-line nationalist demand. The advocates of 'two states' are, on the whole, the least narrowly nationalistic, the most prepared to involve and accommodate the Jews. The secular democratic state is more nationalist because it in reality encompasses a demand for the restoration of all of Palestine - including where the Jews live — and demands the right to determine what will happen in all of Palestine.
Israel and the Palestinians *Two states', from the narrow nationalist point of view, is a sellout position - not because it compromises on the issue of equal rights for all, but because it compromises on the nationalist claim on every inch of Palestine.
So the political content and significance of the slogans for the 'unitary, non-racial' South Africa and 'secular democratic' Palestine are completely ditterent. Why?
Because the historical and material realities of the two cases are different, and the dynamics of class and popular struggle are different.
Struggle.
Fundamentally, in South Africa there is a struggle for equality within a single state that already exists (or rather, within a historically economically and socially constituted unit that already exists).
This struggle is often described as a national liberation struggle, but in a strict sense it is not. 'Selfdetermination for South African blacks' is not a rational slogan. The struggle is against white caste rule.?
The Palestinian struggle is tundamentally for national liberation, while it includes elements of a struggle for equality (i.e. of Arabs and Jews in Isarel). But it is not a struggle against 'Jewish caste rule' in a unit that already exists.
The distinction lies primarily in the existence of a fully-fledged and distinct Israeli Jewish nation. Its existence structures and shapes the conflict, class struggle and popular consciousness, in ways that have no parallel in South Africa. To draw an equals sign between the two is in.
fact to blot out reality - and to make incomprehensible the forms and ideological expressions of popular struggle.
None of this implies that the Palestinian case is less just' than that of the black people of South Africa. But no aid is given to the Palestinian struggle by mystifying Palestine: two nations, two states! The new issue of "Workers' Liberty', out now, discusses the conflict in the West Bank and Gaza, and carries, for the first time in English, two articies by Trotsky on the socialist approach to disputes batwaan nations.
Also in this issue: a feature on the Crash, Kowalewski on Poland, and debate on Ireland, Scottish nationaliam, South Africa and the movies. 90p plus 30p pastage from SO, PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA.
----- pull-quotes -----
WORKERS, LIBERTY