T&G - symbolic victory for left sym
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-03-10Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
ca twins! The result of the TGWU executive election represents significant victory for the left in the union, but not the dramatic *hard left takeover" that sections of the capitalist press have been ranting about.
Candidates associated with the broad left: (which, in reality, means anyone fractionally to the left of Neil Kinnock) won a 23-16 majority of the 39-strong General Executive Council, overturning
the previous 22-17 right-wing majority,
The left versus right battle within the TGWU has been raging for the last two years, but the political differences between the two sides are vague and have often seemed less important than various personality clashes. Both sides, for instance, proclaim their loyalty to Neil Kinnock, and the new lett majority on the executive is unlikely to back any direct challenge to the Labour leadership.
Composition
The composition of the new executive could even turn out to the advantage of Neil Kinnock. The old right wing majority was bitterly hostile to general
secretary Ron Todd and his deputy Bill
Morris. As the Financial Times noted, "Mr Todd has a close relationship with Mr Kinnock. If Mr Todd can stabilise the executive and exert his influence over it, the swing could bring benefits for the Labour leadership."
Symbolically, at least, the most important result of the election was the defeat of the union's former chair, Brian Nicholson as Region One (London and the South East) territorial representative, by Ford shop steward Steve Riley. Nicholson was the leader of the "hard right" on the TGWU executive and made no secret of his hostility to the union's long-standing policy of unilateral nuclear disarmament, as well as his lack of enthusiasm for the "Link-Up" campaign, aimed at recruiting part-time workers, women and workers on government schemes.
Nicholson has hinted that he might challenge the election results because of alleged "irregularities" (i.e. ballot-rigging), but this is unlikely to come to anything. Whereas in the past ballot-rigging has been widely practiced by both left and right within the TGWU, these elections have been conducted quite scrupulously, and Ron Todd says that no complaints. had been received from TGWU members.
The change in the political complexion of the TGWU may not be as drastic as some reports have suggested, but it does offer the serious left within the union considerable opportunities. In particular, the new executive should prove more receptive to rank and file pressure to give the "Link-Up" campaign real teeth in the regions. It should also increase pressure upon Todd to reverse his backing for the govenment's new adult training scheme. Within the Labour Party the TGWU's considerable influence (its 1.25 million block vote represents one-fifth of the total voting power at annual conference) could be decisive in making or breaking Kinnock's efforts to shift party policy to the right.
But the serious left in the TGWU must organise at rank and file level -otherwise the new executive could yet prove to be a blessing in disguise for the Labour leadership.