Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Lenin and Georgia

Socialist Organiser no. 349, 10 March 1988 · scan p. 7 · about 780 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 7

Komsomolsk o

Blagovi Isan INA The 15 Republics of the U.S.S.R.

Russia (R.S.F.S.R./ -see map 1000 Km termina 1918, 'in a sense, had come into being on German initiative and accepted the protection, successively, German and of British imperialism, and since this tutelage from outside linked these nonGreat-Russian nationalities with states that were intervening in Russia on behalf of the counterrevolution, it was inevitable that the entire 'nationalities policy' of the Soviet Government should be profoundly affected. It must be added that in a number of cases the demand for independence was more a reaction against Bolshevism than an expression of genuine nationalism. The Georgian Mensheviks, for example, had been opposed before the October revolution to the idea of independence for Georgia, and between February and October had ignored the affairs of their own little country, preferring to devote Khabarovsk itchensk Vladivostok NOR Yellow Friendship of the peop el tion and yourself whether you want a child; I will defend your right to abortion against the Kremlin police'. To the Ukrainian people he says: 'Of importance to me is your attitude toward your national destiny and not the 'socialistic' sophistries of the Kremlin police; I will support your struggle for independence with all my might!"

The sectarian, as so often happens, finds himself siding with the police, covering up the status quo, that is police violence, by sterile speculation on the superiority of the socialist unification of nations as against their remanining divided. Assuredly the separation of the Ukraine is a liability as compared with a voluntary and equalitarian socialist federation: but it will be an unquestionable asset as compared with the bureaucratic strangulation of the Ukrainian people. In order to heighbours. Let us take an ideal variant most favourable for our critic. The revolution occurs simultaneously in all parts of the Soviet Union. The bureaucratic octopus is strangled and swept aside. The constituent congress of the Soviets is on the order of the day.

The Ukraine expresses a desire to determine anew her relations with the USSR. Even our critic, let us hope, will be ready to extend her this right. But in order freely to determine her relations with other Soviet republics, in order to possess the right of saying yes or no, the Ukraine must return to herself complete freedom of action, at least for the duration of this constituent period. There is no other name for this than state independence.

Now let us futher suppose the revolution simultaneously embraces also Poland, Rumania, and Hungary. All sections of the Ukrainian people become free and enter into negotations to join the Soviet Ukraine. At the same time they all express the desire to have their say on the question of the interrelations between a unified Ukraine and the Soviet Union, with Soviet Poland, etc. It is self evident that to decide all these questions it will be necessary to convene the constituent congress of the unified Ukraine. But a 'constituent' congress signifies nothing else but the congress of an independent state which prepares anew to determine its own domestic regime as well as its international position." ("Independence of the Ukraine and Sectarian Muddleheads"). Marcel Liebman, *Leninism Under Lenin', explained Bolshevik policy towards Georgia Lenin showed a similar attitude in connection with the problem of relations between Soviet Russia and independent Georgia. Despite well-founded grievances against the Mencherik regime in that country, the Soviet government recognised Georgian independence in May 1920. In February 1921, however, the Red Army occupied the country and put an end to this independence.

The invasion of Georgia was decided on behind the backs of Lenin, Trotsky and the Political Bureau. Shortly before the invasion began Lenin had expressed his opposition to any such move. It was Stalin who overruled him.

Once the occupation of Georgia was a fait accompli, Lenin sought to mitigate the consequences of a policy that he regarded as harmful.

Writing to Ordzhonikidze, who was in enarge or Dover ceorgia, erase in he said: "it is of tremendous importance to devise an acceptable compromise for a bloc with Jordania [the former president of the Georgian Republic, M.L.J or similar Georgian Mensheviks, who before the uprising had not been absolutely opposed to the idea of Soviet power in Georgia on certain terms."

In a telegram to the Soviet army of occupation he called on them to *observe particular respect for the sovereign bodies of Georgia" and "display particular attention and caution in regard to the Georgian population."

Later, when the brutal and chauvinist attitude of Stalin and Ordzhonikidze brought about a crisis between the Russian and Georgian Communists, Lenin intervened with desperate insistence on behalf of the latter. It was

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 349

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →