Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

A prison house today

Socialist Organiser no. 349, 10 March 1988 · scan pp. 7–8 · about 1,310 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 7

themselves to the problems of -Russia as a whole, in the ministries and streets of Petrograd." (Liebman p.272-3)

Trotsky Years later in 1939, Trotsky spelled out his attitude to Ukrainian in-dependence, replying to critics who said self-determination was less important than 'defence of the USSR'. . Trotsky argued:

"What does a revolutionist say to the woman? You will decide draw together more closely and honestly, it is sometimes necessary first to separate. Lenin often used to cite the fact that the relations between the Norwegian and Swedish workers improved and became closer after the disruption of the compulsory unification of Sweden and Norway...

The slogan of an independent Ukraine does not signify that the Ukraine will remain forever isolated, but only this, that she will again determine for herself and of her own free will the question of her interrelations with other sections of the Soviet Union and her western Today's Russia is a far cry crom the democratic traditions on the national question of Lenin's day. Huge numbers of people are oppressed within the USSR itself by Great-Russian chauvinism. The Ukraine, with 60 million people, is the largest oppressed nation in the world.

Russian troops intervened in Hungary_ in 1956 to crush a workers" uprising, in Czechoslovakia in 1968 to stop the *Prague Spring' And in Afghanistan since 1979-80, the USSR has been waging a colonialtype war.

Socialists today need to revive Lenin's policy. Gorbachev, for all his 'refoims' , is unlikely to do so. Yet the Russian people would do well to remember Lenin's comment — following Marx — "Can a nation be free if it oppresses other nations? It cannot. through this episode that Lenin, who, though already incapacitated by illness, hurled his last reserves of energy into the battle, became aware of the extent to which the policy of Russification had developed. It was then that he launched his last anathemas against *that really Russian man, the Great-Russian chauvinist, in substance a rascal and a lover of violence" and wrote that disillu-: sioned sentence: "If matters had come to such a pass...we can imagine what a mire we have got ourselves into."* (Liebman, p.275-6)

Scan page 8

Police riot unit outside UDF offices in Jel: meshirg. Photo: Morris Zwi, Reflex.

Behind the Mark Swilling looks at what lies bahind the latest clampdown in South Africa. Examining Botha's overall stratagy, he raises the question of whathar or not the left should reassess its attitude of boycotting the state's ethnicallybased local government system.

This week's banning of th United Democratic Front an 16 other organisations is clearl designed to prepare the way fo the local authority elections i October..

The state's repressive reforn strategy is premised on the assump tion that local government can b legitimised without the UDF's par ticipation and that the effects of the election boycott can be outflanked State strategists in the Nationa Security Management System don' want the UDF to participate because they know this will protec the UDF from direct full-fronta blows like those delivered this week.

One top official said to me: "What the security guys fear most is that the UDF will participate."

The boycott tactic being debated In opposition circles because the state has recovered from the delegitimising consequences of previous boycott campaigns. It has recovered because i believes it can effectively counter the boycott by using two tactics.

Firstly, has initiated repressive reform strategy that does ceed. Secondly the this strategy is not depend on legitimation to sucpremised the premeditated assumption that the extraparliamentary organisations will choose once again to use a boycott tactic. In other words, included in the state's strategic planning is not how to break the boycott but how to outflank it.

The state's game plan is the "bottom-up" approach to reform This involves the creation of "multi-racial" ethnically based local government structures with each "group" having its own "primary local authority" which then sends representatives to the Regional Services Council.

Using the secretive Joint Management Centres to pilot this process, the state intends using simultaneous local authority elections for each "group" to consolidate this first stage of the "bottom-up" reform process.

The point is the legitimising mechanism in these elections is not intended to be mass participation and high polls, but rather the elec toral process itself will be heralded as a necessary and sufficient condi. tion to ensure legitimacy no matter how low the polls.

The outflanking of the effects of the boycott involves: Firstly, the continuation of prolonged detentions and maintenance of the State of Emergency. Secondly, using a disciplined fiscal policy to prevent the economy from overheating again, Finance Minister Barend du Plessis hopes to diminish unemployment, thus pacifying the vouth. Thirdly, the upgrading of townships will continue apace so that basic grievances about daily living conditions cannot be exploited by "agitators". Fourthly, clampdowns on the press will continue to remove the 'alternative" voice. Finally, when the local government structures are in place, to sell these tional reform". If it succeeds at the local level then the National Council can proceed on the same basis. The question is, can it be countered?

Much depends on the extent to which the terrain of struggle has been transformed. If it has been fundamentally altered by new material conditions of struggle, then the boycott tactic as applied to local government may need to be reassessed. This tactic is the lynchpin: given the state's capacity to insulate itself from the effects of an election boycott, what are the alternatives?

At least four positions have been articulated in response to this question. The first argues that even though the balance of power has changed from what it was in 1984-6, given the state's refusal to countenance any real dissent and given the general repressive condinons, participation would serve to legitimise rather than undermine state structures. Under present conditions the state stands to gain more than it will lose if the boycott is called off.

The second position argues that as in the past, there are times when the best form of offense is to use participation in state structures as a cover for the continuation of mass organisation and mobilisation. There are a few local organisations within the UDF fold that have unilaterally decided that the only way their struggle can be taken forward is to take over the local authority. These are organisations engaged in bitter housing struggles against corrupt patronage networks that can only operate by virtue of the fact that the patrons control the local authorities.

The third position can best be called conditional participation. It would amount to democratic organisations saying they want to particate in the local elections - on condition all detainees are released. If they are not released then the moral high ground is won and the election is declared unfair and unfree. If they are released then the lead-up to the election is used to strengthen organisation. Upon being elected, the candidate then refuses to take his or her sat. (This gs strategy has been used by the Palestine Liberation Organisation on the West Bank and by the Irish Republican Army):

At this stage the first option appears most likely and probably the most feasible given the recent. clampdown. Even if the UDF decided tomorrow it wanted to participate, the bannings effectively prevent this. This position will be justified with the argument that the repressive reform strategy will not fundamentally alter the terrain of struggle. At this moment not many will disagree with this largely sound conclusion. However, as in previous phases of resistance, there is no reason why the boycott strategy will not be reassessed if this conclusion proves untenable in the the boycott strategy is a tactic, not a future. This will be possible because principle.] •Mark Swilling is a Research Of ficer at the Centre for Policy Studies, University of the Witwatersrand. From the Weekly Mail

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 349

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →