Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Loans threat in Baker Bill SAVE Cabbage Education patch kids I-BUSTEDA GERBILIS

Socialist Organiser no. 349, 10 March 1988 · scan p. 5 · about 1,485 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 5

The government's plans centre quate level since 1979 may make involve the membership in either whatever immediate action can be

last week the government has in around a £1,000 non-means tested €1,000 seem an attractive proposi- the activity or the political ideas of achieved.

now. •Culminate the week of action *Call emergency executive, coun with a mass rally in London. *Organise pickets of Tory MPs, for our campaign. All out on the occupations, shut-downs, or picket lines on 14 March.

rule OK

In a story leaked to the Times

effect announced that student loans and "voluntary membership" of the NUS are to be included in the Education Bill.

This move is the biggest threat the student movement has faced and it would put in question the viability of NUS as a student organisation able to represent and campaign for students' rights. Last weekend's NOLS conference proved once more that the Labour student organisation (NOLS) is in serious decline. But the conference did nothing to stop it. Very much the opposite in fact. Under the control of the "Democratic Left" (DL), this conference was a symptom of the NOLS disease, not the beginning of a cure.

True, conference did vote to adjourn itself so that delegates could go on the health workers' demonstration. That was good. It happened when the "Democratic Left" , who had previously opposed such a move, caved in to pressure and made a u-turn. The bad side of it was that the DL refused to reconvene the conference for a compensating evening session.

This meant that much business was lost and there were only three policy debates. No emergency debates were allowed.

The DL liked it this way: it gave them an easier ride.

The nature of the disease NOLS suffers from was exposed to delegates when the DL chair opened conference with a speech lamenting the still dwindling number of NOLS members but then sagely commented, in the spirit and manner of a fatalistic and demoralised old man, that you can't expect anything else in a third Thatcher term! So you won't be so sinful as to blame the dispirited would-be careerists who run NOLS for the organisation's decline, will you comrade?

This irresponsible and feebleminded refusal to take any responsibility for the decline of NOLS sums up the Democratic Left' in NOLS right now.

They feel that their continued rule in NOLS will only be possible if they can sustain a blindly obstinate rejection of any criticism of their stewardship, however valid. This means that they are utterly unable to learn the lessons of the decline or to work out policies for rebuilding and expanding NOLS.

Their attitude resembles nothing so much as the dimwitted factional pigheadedness of Militant (over the Liverpool fiasco, for example. But then the 'Democratic Left' and Militant have always been the terrible Siamese twins of the youth and student movement.

The ineptitude and irresponsibility of the 'Democratic Left' → the Socialist Organizar no.349 loan available to all higher education students in exchange for a renouncement of all rights to benefits and loss of £100 off the grant. Few students would actually get access to more money over a three year course of study, and all would be left with a l£1,000 debt on graduating. _The fact that the grant has been allowed to tall to such an inadeconference self-proclaimed left-wing leade! rship of the student movement! - was evident again when they refuse ed to take_an emergency discussior organising immediate action ag ainst government plans to bring in student loans.

The sad truth is — and even : some of the DL supporters must kni ow it — that after six years of grueso mely ineffective NOLS leadership the Tories are confident that they can safely introduce loans and later on a "voluntary membership" rule designed to destroy the NUS.

The "Democratic left" ref fused even to discuss the issue at conThe three policy debates at conference were:

On the NHS (but there were few students on Saturday's NHS demonstration because neither of the two organisations run by the Cabbage Patch Faction have done any work to organise students to defend the NHS.)

On Poll Tax, where a compromise position was passed against the NC. At least the compromise mentioned the possibility of the labour movement organising a refusal-to-pay campaign rather than sitting back and expecting working class people to stand on their own against the government and individually to refuse payment. On the Alton Bill, where the NOLS NC opposed mandating Labour MPs to vote according to Labour conference policy over abortion. The DL-controlled NC was defeated.

ference, thus throwing away an opportunity to organise a swift and decisive response by Labour activists. How pathetic and irresponsible can you get!

As usual the DL had ruled out enough opposition delegates to ensure themselves a safe majority in electing the NOLS NC and to rule out any serious challenges to their factional rail-roading of Conference procedure.

So while changes to NOLS constitution which the NC don't like such as allowing part-time FE students to join have to pass through a priority ballot procedure to be debated, other constitutional amendments simply "come up" March 1988 Page 5

quate level since |1979 may make

£1,000 seem an attractive proposition to some students but we have to be clear in our opposition to the plan.

Any top-up loan is only the first step to a full loans system, and education as a privilege for those who can afford to nav for it Unless we can organise students to defend themselves againt loans there's no way students are going to be organised to defend the NUS. Six vears of decline and failure to The Photo: lan Swindale without being passed by a single Labour Club or even being tabled on the order paper. This at least has the advantage that we can be sure we know what they consider important!

Building and rebuilding NOLS isn't, that's for sure. Look at their attitude to Further Education students, for example.

The 'Democratic Left's contempt for FE students in general was evident in a written answer to a question submitted to the Vice Chair, Adrian McMerriman. With breathtaking arrogance he excused NOLS' appalling record in the FE sector as being not due to the rule barring part-time students from NOLS membership but to "the anti-politics atmosphere" in FE colleges and to "the fact that many of these students do not see themselves as part of the student movement"!

According to Adrian it is a *misunderstanding of the FE sector" which leads to "organisational remedies for what is a political problem". So, let me put it to you once

involve the membership in either

the activity or the political ideas of the union mean that NUS is out of touch with the membership and can't assume that the support is automatically there.

We need urgent and decisive action to see off the threat of loans. The NITS muct ctart nlannino action MAD MMMAYA cil, Labour Club meetings now. more comrade: you wouldn't be so trotish and ssinful as to blame the DL leaders of NOLS for anything, would you?

These people think that building a youth organisation is the same thing as growing cabbages: it all depends on the soil and the sun and the rain, and, really, it's all in the hands of God. For sure it's not in the hands of the Cabbage Patch Kids of the DL. Unfortunately these Cabbage Patch politicians are running NOLS. Into the ground!

Proper

A proper NOLS conference, for which delegates were freely and democratically elected and seated would have taken a long hard look at the state of the organisation and, maybe, called the outgoing leaders to account.

But not this conference. Exclusion of FE students, artifical - factional - restrictions on the organising of Labour Clubs and the bureaucratic exclusion of properly *Call on NUS for the following programme of action:

•Immediate week of action appropriate local actions.

• Week possibly 24 hour *Build labour movement support elected delegates all combined to make this a rump conference controlled by the Cabbage Patch Kids of the DL.

No assessment was made of NOLS' failures or of NOLS leaders. Packed pretendconferences don't come up with answers to difficult questions, because by definition a packed conference is designed to protect those in charge from difficult and embarrassing questions.

And those who don't dare to raise the necessary questions will never arrive at answers to the difficult question NOLS must answer.

The Cabbage Patch Kids can rig NOLS conferences, but NOLS can't rig the outside world. The student movement is going to want answers to legitimate questions about NOLS' failure to tackle issues like student loans and voluntary membership.

The labour movement should also be seriously asking how Labour's "official" student section has got itself into such a mess.

----- pull-quotes -----

Sandra Cartlic Ige

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 349

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →