Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The Tories' double standards

Socialist Organiser no. 348, 3 March 1988 · scan p. 11 · about 2,319 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 11

The Peruvian 20,000 tonne Presidente Jose Pardo is pany's affairs by the Peruvian president, Alan Garcia. stranded in Liverpool by the bankruptcy of its parent In the meantime the 17 crewmen are stuck in Liverpool company, CPV, and a national strike of CPV crew. A in poor conditions with little money, and no support fourfold pay increase would bring them in line with in- from the 12 ship's officers, who are in a different union. ternational standards from their present £60 a month, They would welcome support and financial help. Conand the union is also asking for intervention in the com- tact Alex Doswell, 051-709 4398. For a long time we have been accusing the state and the authorities of using doublestandards. Last week they prov ed it once again when the information came out that a British soldier, convicted of murder, had been released after just over two years and was now back at his job.

Since the strike we have been pressing that miners who, in the main, are guilty of no offence whatsoever - and those miners who are guilty of some offencehave still paid their penalty to society -be given their jobs back.

But there are still some 260 miners victimised by British Coal.

The information that came out on Tuesday shows clearly what the state thinks. If you are part of the establishment then it is quite alright for you to serve two years for murder and then be given your job back. But if you are guilty of no offence but are part of the trade union movement, then you have to sutfer for the rest of your life, as does your wife and your kids. It's a blatant indication of the way things are.

The NUM, sponsored MPS and in tact everybody should now be arguing that if it's alright in the case of the army, then every single one of the cases of the 260 victimised miners should now be looked at again. I do not think there is any argument why they should not all be given their jobs back.

It's another incident that gives me a chance to urge once again that the Civil servants -Mike McGrath, the candidate Lof_the_Broad_ Left_ in NUCPS (Pational Union of Civil and Public Servants) for the presidency of that union, spoke to Socialist Organiser. NUCPS is the union recently formed by the merger of two civil service unions, the SCPS and the CSU.

Mike was for many years a well-known activist in the CPSA. He is editor of "Open Left", the NUCPS Broad Left journal.

The existing leadership is controlled by a small group of Stalinists. These people think that everything started going wrong in the Soviet Union after Joe Stalin died. The uprisings in Hungary 1956, Czechoslovakia 1968, and more recently in Poland are all viewed as CIA-sponsored.

But the Broad Left doesn't exist simp1y as a political opposition: we are, after all, in a trade union, not a political parту. We are critical of the leadership's secrecy and elitism.

For example, you have to be invited to join their secret "left' caucus.

They were opposed to the introduc Haringey WHETTON'S labour and trade union movement should not forget those miners who are still victimised, and are still showing tremendous resilience in the face of real hardship. Other workers should remember that they could be in the same position tomorrow unless we keep fighting on this issue.

5 March L am looking forward to going on Saturday's TUC demonstration in support of the health workers. Will be going with one of my sons, who is a nurse. In some respects, I suppose, we should be grateful that the TUC has actually done something, although it is only a demonstration.

But demonstrations, petitions, etc., are not going to save the health service, and the 'new realists' who try and convince others that it will are living in cloud-cuckoo-land. The only way you will save anything from the Tories is to stand up and fight.

Since the end of the miners' strike I have been pretty disillusioned to see jobs and industries go down like ninepins in the face of the Tories' onslaught. Recently, though, I have begun to get a little bit of optimism. Arthur Scargill's re-election, the Ford strike, the healthworkers and so on. People have tried the new realists way and time after tion of election addresses (where candidates for union positions can tell the membership their background and policies); they oppose the election of full-time officers. On many industrial issues, they simply do not believe that members are prepared to fight seriously — ever. time it has been shown not to work. Stirring examples of nurses and Ford workers being prepared to stand up and fight are at least giving us a pointer to the way forward.

Incidentally, this is one of the dilemmas facing NACODS at the present time. They took their wage claim to the national reference tribunal, who ruled they should call off their action, but also that British Coal should stop victimising the deputies and trying to impose a new 7-day roster.

Not surprisingly, NACODS obeyed but British Coal has not, at least in Notts and Yorkshire. NACODS think they can talk their way out of a very difficult situation, but they can't. The only way they will win is by stepping up their fight, not by trying to call it off.

am sure that on Saturday's demonstration there will be plenty of demands for the TUC to call at least a one-day general strike in suport of the health workers. I am very much in favour of it, as I have been on a number of occasions in the past on other issues. But it is so clear for the health workers. It is an issue that affects every working class man, woman and child. Their health is at stake. It's their health service. The only possible answer is for every man, woman and child to participate in the fight.

People in the past have argued that the miners' fight was not their fight, that they were not the same as Ford workers and so on. But that argument is so obviously invalid with the health workers. The very least that the working class can do, as a whole, is to throw their tools on the floor in defence of the health service What is the leadership's response to the existence of the open Broad Left?

Very hostile. A secret paper of theirs came into our hands, which rejected out of hand any cooperation with us. No doubt they would like to get rid of us in one way or another, but in fact they can't. Nor, I suspect, do they have the confidence to try.

Why are you standing President?

I'm not standing in order to further my own career in the union. In fact, I'm a somewhat reluctant candidate, but was felt to be the best choice by comrades within the Broad Left.| We are standing for two principal reasons. Firstly, in the new union, the presidency is the only position for which all members can vote. All other posts are reserved for members of each of the two old unions, CSU and SCPS.

Secondly, the current leadership has reacted passively to the threats that we face.

The pay agreement this year is full of the worst sort of class collaborationist rubbish. For pennies, we have sold defences on the introduction of new technology, on the direct recruitment of staff to grades to which our members expect promotion, and many other conditions of service.

As someone at work said to me the other day, "What our leadership doesn't seem to realise is that the government plans ceaselessly to find ways to screw us." The conflict is total and unconditional — the trouble is, onLy one side recognises the fact!

Last week the Tories came out with their plans for the privatisation of the electricity industry. It's the latest round in their selling-off of assets to finance their political strategy. The industries in which I like everybody else, used to have some form of stake, have been sold off into private hands - all without a ballot! Of course, that private control will rapidly become concentrated into fewer and fewer private hands.

The sale of the electricity industry will be a massive give-away. It threatens jobs in mining, rail, seatarers and within the power stations themselves. And in the run-up to privatisation the consumer will have to pay hand over fist for the bosses' rich pickings, with the prices being driven up. Nuclear power, of course, is enshrined in the plans, and could even itself end up in private hands.

Many pits would go, virtually overnight. It does not take a genius to work out that if you are buying coal on the market as a private investor, would you be payng the f40 odd per tonne from British Coal or would you be paying sometimes as low as half that figure by getting coal from South Africa, or Columbia, where coal is mined by kids, slaves and workers in slave conditions. Not even Nottinghamshire would be safe.

They are already expanding the facilities to import the cheap coal, and the rail is particularly threatened. Something like 80% of all freight traffic on the railways is coal. They would be decimated overnight, and even those lines that remained would then themselves become prime candidates for privatisation.

What difficulties do you a Broad Left in what management union?

Well, since the merger with CSU, we have become a union which also organises the lowest paid in the civil service - cleaners, messengers, photoprinters, etc. However, it's true that the majority of the union membership are management grades, and this does present both opportunities and difficulties.

Many members still retain an illusion that they have a career in the civil service, and this can create a conflict between loyalty to the management and loyalty to effective union action. As managers, NUCPS members are called upon to report on, and to direct the work of junior staff - and that can put militants in a spot.

However, the attacks on our members are now so severe that the illusions are disappearing. Witness, for example, the vote to establish a political fund.

I am confident that we will see a surge of militancy in the civil service in the coming period. We must do what we can to ensure that it comes sooner rather than later, and be of a scale sufficient to roll back the government's attacks.

I don't think that the civil service workers alone can win: we need to join with other public sector workers. This is a difficult task, opposed as it is by the trade union leaders because of its political implications.

*Readers in NUCPS who are interested in finding out more about the Broad Left should contact the National Secretary, 54 Withy House, Globe Road, London EL, - Les of What caused the disastrous floods and mudslides in Rio de Janeiro recently? At least 300 died and some 20,000 shanty town dwellers are homeless. The city is still under threat of more landslides.

What caused flooding in Rio Branco, capital of the eastern Amazon province of Acre, 3000 kilometres away? This left some 40,000 homeless and Rio Branco was still flooded ten days after.

Everyone agrees that the torrential rains had something to do with it but Brazilian scientists agree that these by themselves were not enough to explain the devastation. To understand the full picture, we must examine the situation in Rio de Janeiro and Rio Branco.

Cultivate

Due to lack of land for the poor to cultivate, hundreds of thousands of landless people have gone to Rio de Janeiro and other cities, searching for work. More than one million of them live in favelas or shanty towns on the hillsides surrounding Rio. These hills are actually quite high, over 1000 metres in places, and were extensively wooded. Over the years, however, the trees have been cut down to make space for hovels, for building materials or for fuel.!

When heavy rain falls on a tropical forest, water is caught by the leaves and slowed down in its fall. Once the canopy has gone, though, the water hits the soil with full force, sweeping it away down the hillsides in muddy streams. If the process has been going on for some time, a particularly heavy storm can cause a catastrophic landslide and a river of mud carries all before it. In Rio, such mudslides destroyed the shanties on their way to the richer areas nearer sea-level.

In Rio Branco, the flood was caused by the bursting of the banks of tributaries of the Amazon but the underlying cause was again deforestation. Normally, the rain is delayed on its way into the rivers by the trees and soil. But once these have gone, the water pours straight in and the river in full spate tears down its banks.

In the Amazon forests, the reasons for cutting down the trees are different. People have flocked here in search of land not already occupied by ranch owners or multinational companies. They cut down and burn the trees (causing on at least one occasion last year massive air pollution and disruption of the weather), farm for a few years until the soil is exi austed and then move on. Multi-national ranching, timber and mining companies also cut down the forests, with the same result.

If that is the cause of the floods, then the solution is simple -replant the trees. But the soil has gone and is not easily replaced. The people, too, need land and work. This human tragedy in Brazil has economic, political and environmental causes. Preventing more such tragedies means tackling all these causes. 10.348

----- pull-quotes -----

*MONT CAPTENT

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 348

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →