Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Jews Jewish?

Socialist Organiser no. 348, 3 March 1988 · scan p. 9 · about 571 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

I do not feel that anti-Zionism per se is anti-semitism, despite the fact that for many antisemites today, anti-Zionism is a convenient guise for straightforward anti-semitic feelings. Nonetheless, one should realise the fact that one can be anti-Zionist without being antisemitic.

Yet the problem is much deeper. In its most fundamental sense, antisemitism has always been not a mere hatred of Jews, or of all things Jewish. What anti-semitism in all its historical manifestations objected to and aimed at-_were always the sources of the legitimacy of Jewish: existence.

Therefore, when in the Middle Ages religion was the mainstay of Jewish identity, Christian persecution of the Jews aimed at delegitimising Jewish religion, by depicting Jews as deicides; with secularisation and the rise of modern nationalism, nineteenth century racial anti-semitism emerged as an ideology delegitimising theJews as an ethnically or 'racially' inferior and pernicious entity.!

Israel - the historical product of Zionism - is today the broadest makes common denominator for Jewish self-consciousness all over the world. Certainly Jewish religion cannot be viewed anymore as the common bond uniting all people who call themselves Jewish.

Many Jews consider themselves as having been secularised, and certainly the vast majority lead a highly secularised life-style.

Secondly, Jewish religion today is no longer a uniform structure of codes and modalities as it was in pre-Emancipation days.

The differences between Reform Judaism and the Orthodox traditions are certainy not a unifying factor in Jewish life — the opposite is the case.

It is in this context of a largely secularised world that Israel has emerged as a normative centre for Jewish self-consciousness and Jewish self-definition in our age. The fate of Israel, its triumphs and tribulations, its problems and achievements, all these play a more central role in the selfunderstanding of more Jewish people all over the world than any other facet of Jewish life:

Secular and Orthodox Jews, left wing and right wing Jews, American and Soviet Jews - for all of these, Israel is more central to their self-definition of being Jewish than any other factor common.

To strike at the legitimacy of Israel today, through anti-Zionism as an ideology of delegitimising Israel, as the SWP does, means striking at the very centre of the normative self-definition of the Jewish people as Jews understand it. It is a fact that most Jews define themselves today, in some way or other and in various degrees of intensity, in relation to Israel.

Should Israel disappear or a major catastrophe betall it, practically all Jewish people would conceive it as a major tragedy for their own existence as Jews. Thercfore, a delegitimisation of Israel is tantamount to the delegitimisation of Jewish existence as understood by most Jews.

Many non-Jews may deplore this Jewish identification with Israel; but then many non-Jews deplored the obstinate refusal of Jews in the Middle Ages to convert to Christianity, and it is out of this unwillingness to accept the Jews as what they consider themselves to be that anti-semitism has historically arisen!

It is in this deeper sense — not in the facile semantic equation of anti-Zionism | with anti-semitism, that anti-Zionism is identical in its fundamental attitudes to former modes of traditional anti-semitism. Just like Christian theology in the Middie Ages and modern racist antisemitism, current anti-Zionism of Reviewi the form where the legitimacy of the state of Israel is denied, aims at exirpating levitin existen basic legitimacy of MARK EDWARDS,

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 348

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →