What makes the bureaucrats tick?
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-03-03Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
SUBSCRIBE!
Please send me 6/12 months sub. / enclose E||/To: Socialist Organiser, PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA.
Get your copy! Wednesday 2 March, Edinburgh SO meeting, 'Socialists and Ireland'. 7.30, Windsor Buffet, Leith Walk.
Wednesday 2 March. Canterbury SO meeting, 'Socialists and the Labo Party', Speaker: Lynn Ferguson. 1pm, Keynes College JCR3.-Thursday 3 March. Merseyside SO meeting South Africa. Speaker: Tom Rigby, 1pm.
Thursday 3 March. Northampton SO meeti 'Socialists and the Labe Party'. Speaker: Tim Anderson.
Sunday 6 March. Lambeth Against Alton benefit at the Ritzy Cinema, Brixton. From 1.25 p.m. Women only:
Tuesday 8 March, South London Women's Centre Open Day on the Alton Bill. Noon to 6pm at Acre Lane, London SW2.
Tuesday 8 March. Newcastle SO meeting, •Palestine: two nations, two states'. 8pm, Tyne Rooms, 10 Pilgrim St.
Saturday 12 March. Lambeth Against Altonbenefit, at the Old White Horse pub, Brixton Road. All welcome.
Saturday 19 March. Fight Alton's Bill. Nationai demonstration. Assemble 11.30, Embankment. Saturday-Sunday 16-1 April. North London Socialist Conference, at North London Polytechnic, Holloway Road, London N7. For further details of SO meetings, contact 01-639 7965.
How the workers made a revolution A Socialist Organiser special 60 pence Available from SO, PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA. 60p plus 20p p&p. Socialist Organiser no.348 I visitor from Mars, witnessing he desperate efforts of union eaders like Mick Murphy to revent (and then sell out) the 'ord strike, or observing the reent grovelling before the High ourt of seafares' leader Sam Ic Cluskie, might be forgiven or assuming that these people re simply bought and paid for gents of the bosses.
They are not. But union 'leaders" like these have their own riorities and interests, which are uite distinct from those of the corkers they are supposed to repreent.
They are a layer of people within le working class who occupy a osition between the employers on ne side and the workers on the ther.
They must be seen to extract conessions from the employers from me to time, in order to justify their wn existence. But they are more errified of uncontrolled militancy uncontrolled by them, that is) from ne rank and file than they are of ny employer.
Rank and file militancy upsets osy arrangements with employers, ndermines the authority of the raders in the eyes of employers -nd can give workers the dangerous lea that sometimes direct action an achieve more than skillful egotiation by full-time union ofcials.
For all these reasons, union raders and officials don't like miliint action, other than that which ley have called, and can turn on nd off like water from a tap, in rder to strengthen their hand in egotiations.
Trade unions emerged in Britain ith the rise of capitalism. itself. he thousands of workers driven ito the grim factories of the inustrial revolution soon realised the eed to combine into unions. And the first lesson they learned as the need for solidarity amongst I the workers in each factory -nd between workers in different ictories and industries. In the early Эth century the most advanced lilitants, the Chartists, saw the eed for solidarity throughout the workers' liberty, East and West. We aim to help organise the left wing in the Labour Party and trade unions to fight to replace capitalism with working class socialism.
SOCIALIST SOCIALIST AMISER cops did Ulster shoot to killi The Tories new homeless This enti mai achi end : is the gang who betrayed health re working class (and what rened of the peasant class) to ieve political power. ha sarl atmanlac hittan ne cany suuggies were viler not always successful. Bad nmunications, frequent mployment and grinding povernade it very difficult to maintain ile, continuous union organisaut as capitalism itself expanded, table employment for the skilled ions of workers gave rise to perlent, financially viable organisaIs much more like trade unions e know them today. Politically, the new "craft" (i.e. skilled) ons were much more like today's C "new realists" heir leaders accepted the talist system as natural and inable. Their role was to-act as a sure group maimaicing the imliate. sectional interests of their mbers. More far-sighted iloyers began to realise the adtages of establishing a good relaship with "responsible" union icials. Lord Elcho, the owner, used to invite Alexander Donald, the miners' leader, to npagne breaktasts.
We want public ownership the major enterprises and a anned economy under orkers' control. We want mocracy much fuller than e present Westminster system a workers' democracy, with ected representatives callable at any time, and an id to bureaucrats' and anagers' privileges.
Socialism can never Name Address workers last time to be accepted if the union leaders had already been persuaded to agree. They became, in the words of ine American revolutionary Daniel De Leon, the "Labour Lieutenants of Capitalism,"
Movement When, later, a movement arose to organise unskilled labourers, it came about not because of the craft union leaders, but because of the spontaneous actions of workers like the dockers and the agitation of socialists like Eleanor Marx and Tom Mann.
The traditions of conservative craft unionism has marked the British labour movement throughout this century.
The Labour Party was formed by the union leaders to negotiate in Parliament in the same way they did at the workplace - and on the same political basis.
Of course not all union leaders are exactly the same. Some are personally honest, others corrupt. Some stand on the left, others are openly right wing. They are susceptible to different pressures from their members, from the employers, in one country alone. The workers in every country have more in common with workers in other countries than with their own capitalist or Stalinist rulers. We support national liberation struggles and workers' struggles world-wide, including the struggle of workers and oppressed nationalities in the Stalinist states against their own antier delivered to your door by six months, £16 for a year, from the government - and how they respond to those pressures will vary depending upon circumstances. someumes us can skin result in surprising twists. It was intersting to note that during the Ford strike, the only TWU leader to call for solidarity action in defiance of the law was Brian Nicholson - a leading right-winger. He had his reasons...
But ultimately, all union leaders - left or right — are concerned to protect their own positions and their relatively privileged life-styles. - And that means accepting capitalism, and policing the members should they get out of hand.
Demands That's why socialists may place demands on the leaders, and even support them when they say or do the right things — but we always warn against placing any reliance upon them, and encourage the rank and file to organise themselves within the unions. It will be a lesson that a whole new generation of trade union militants in the NHS, the motor industry and elsewhere must learn as a matter of urgency.
socialist bureaucracies.
We stand:
For full equality for women, and social provision to free women from the burden of housework. For a mass working class based women's movement.
Against racism, and against deportations and all immigration controls.
For equality for lesbians and gays.
For a united and free Ireland, with some federal system to protect the rights of the Protestant minority.
For left unity in action; clarity in debate and discussion.
For a labour movement accessible to the most oppressed, accountable to its rank and file, and militant against capitalism.
We want Labour Party and trade union members who support our basic ideas to become supporters of the paper — to take a bundle of papers to sell each week and pay a small contribution to help meet the paper's deficit. Our policy is democratically controlled by our supporters through Annual General Meetings and an elected National Editorial Board.
Scan page 9
• Letters The first postwar world Jewish congress What LL
----- pull-quotes -----
STAND Socialist Organiser stands for
Reitains death Isquad exposed!
roposals for wage cuts, or new king practices, were more likely
THE TUC DEMANDS JUSTICE OR NHSC