Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Not all Jews are chauvinist

Socialist Organiser no. 347, 25 February 1988 · scan p. 10 · about 407 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

The Socialist Workers' Party have now gone in for "leftwing" stereotyping of whole nations. Two articles under the heading "Inside Israel" from Socialist Worker of 30 January give reasonable factual accounts of the drift to the right inside Israel, but conclude that this is an inescapable process of history.

The recent Peace Now demonstration against oppression in the occupied territories saw a massive turn-out of 40,000 Jews -an equivalent demonstration in Britain would be well over a million: But the SWP do not see this as evidence of real opposition to the Israeli government. Instead they quibble about the size of the demonstration compared with the 200,000-plus Jews who demonstrated against Israel's role in Lebanon in 1982. And they conclude:

*The more the Palestinians resist, the more most Israelis feel threatened and the more reactionary they become."

It is impossible for Jews to go any other way. Be honest, Socialist Worker, why don't you just say *these Jews are all the same - you can't change them."?

And this is exactly the logic of the second article "Do Israeli workers hold the key?" They don't, Socialist Worker. Why?

First, "the Israeli working class has never taken action over discrimination against Arab workers" - so obviously they never will (like nurses will never go on strike). Secondly the leaders of the Jewish trade unions are chauvinists — so obviously all their members are too. It's funny how Socialist Worker never seem to equate British trade unionists with the political consciousness man Willis.

These "left wing", stereotypes of Jewish people demonstrate how far Socialist Worker has come from an independent working-class analysis of the national question. They have forgotten Trotsky's and Lenin's repeated warnings against falling for the chauvinist propaganda of bourgeois nationalists.

LIAM CONWAY, Nottingham Penny Newell gives a graphic account of how men can use pornography to harass and intimidate women. I think Penny was quite right in the action that she took. I also agree with Sarah Cotterill that women in a workplace where porn is all over the walls, and makes their working environment unpleasant, have a right to remove it, and to get union backing for doing so.

But in the case that Penny described, I can't help thinking that if this man was so intent on getting at. women, then he would do so, porn or no porn. The pornography was the method he chose, not necessarily the cause - and not

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 347

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →