Shame as feminism?
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-02-25Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
Eye' piece on pornography con- Lynn Ferguson
hink thev all miss the crux of replies to the A scene from Derek Jarman's 'The Last of England', which shows explicit and apparently homosexual
The replies to my Women's The replies to my 'Women's
Eye' piece on pornography conthink they all miss the crux of what I was trying to say.
Male and female relationships, sexuality, and desire are shaped by, and take place in the context of male dominance, and the oppression of women. However, to argue that heterosexual sexuality, and its manifestations, specifically pornography, are simply about male dominance strikes me as rather 'reductionist'.
Helen McHale in her letter argues "The fact that women are sexually aroused by pornography is totally irrelevant. It is undoubtedly the case that some women fantasise about rape. So what?"
Well, I don't think it is irrelevant. Nor do I consider it irrelevant that women produce and read, for instance, Jackie Collins novels, which the sex depicted is little different from the fantasies on the letters page of 'Playboy' Helen argues that such responses by women occur because women are dominated by male ideas of sexuality.
But society has traditionally defined women, primarily, as passive and receptive sexually. It certainly does not see women as active consumers of sexually-explicit material - indeed, if anything, women are conditioned not to respond to, or be interested in, material about sex, If women do relate to pornography not in a purely negative way, it does imply that there's something to Marion Bower's argument in her Feminist Review article whch I referred to in SO 344: *Whilst I do not discount the influence of social pressures on women's view of themselves, this does not seem to be a satisfactory account of why pornography should be sexually arousing to "Sexual responses are notoriously resistant to social pressures. For example, homosexuality existed, and still does, in societies where the penalty for its expression is death."
After all, many feminists, who presumably to some extent have broken from dominant male ideas Lettersl Lynn Ferguson replies to the discussion in our letters column about pornography about women, have written about sexual fantasies in which they assume a passive role. Moreover, women are conditioned from birth to be wives, mothers and nurturers, but many break out of this, or at least kick against it. I don't see that sexuality should be more resistant to this unless there are other factors involved.
Ellen Willis, in her article *Feminism, Moralism and Pornography' (published in the collection 'Desire' by Virago Press), argues that feminist opposition to pornography can be oppressive to "If feminists define pornography, per se, as the enemy, the result will be to make a lot of women ashamed of their sexual feelings, and afraid to be honest about them. And the last thing women need is more sexual shame, guilt and hypocrisy - this time served up as feminism."
Another argument is that pornography leads to violence against women. Jo Springthorpe argues that "In research studies, pornographic literature has been suggested as a cause of rape." The key word here is "suggested".
It is indeed the case that people have embarked upon research studies intending to prove a causal link between porn and rape. But no-one has succeeded in doing so. In fact, research studies from places like Denmark and Sweden, where a wide range of pornograhic material is freely available, show a comparatively low rate of sexual attacks — while rape is and has been horrifyingly widespread in illiterate, underdeveloped societies where mass pornography is unknown.
I'm certainly not arguing that the free availability of porn actually causes a drop in the incidence of rape and sexual assault (or better job opportunities, or more legal sex. Is it pornography?
equality, or any of the other gains women have won in some of the more developed capitalist coun tries). But given this is the only conclusive research that exists, it indicates that porn does not directly cause rape or the subordination of Jo also mentions child pornography - "How many eightyear old girls willingly consent to pornographic modelling?"
It is incontestable that a vast quantity of porn involves coercion, rape and even murder in its production. This is vile and must be stopped - indeed it is already illegal, to the extent that child sex abuse, rape and murder are illegal.
But the vast bulk of freely available porn is not produced in such a way. The argument is completely irrelevant to written pornography. And it has little to do with the reasons that people like pornography. within feminism...the contemporary feminist attack on pornography and sexual 'perversion" shades at the edges into a right-wing and anti-feminist version of social purity, the moral majority and pro-family movements of the new right."
I think, as thinking people, we have a responsibility to be aware that there are lots of different approaches to pornography within feminism. Not everyone agrees with Andrea Dworkin.
As I mentioned in my original article, Marion Bower and Jessica Benjamin have investigated the constitution of sexuality in early childhood, and have related fantasies of dominance and submission to small children's ambivalent feelings about their powerlessness in relation to their mother.
I'm not an expert on psychoanalysis by any means, but it seems to be an angle worth looking at. Socialists should never assume we know everything about a subject. We should always be questioning our assumptions, and looking to deepen and extend our understanding of issues. Pornography and sexuality should be no exception.
Ellen Willis argues:
"At present...the sexual impulses that pornography appeals to are part of virtually everyone's psychology. For obvious political and cultural reasons nearly all porn is sexist in that it is the product of a male imagination and aimed at a male market...
*But anyone who thinks women are simply indifferent to pornography has never watched a around a trashy novel, firls pass bunch of adolescent Pornography is a very complicated and emotive subject. I think we should be aware of the debates which have taken place about it, and we ought to be prepared to think seriously about the difficulties with the "mainstream' analysis.
The feminist movement so. Why shouldn't we?
----- pull-quotes -----
tain many valid points, but I ain many valid points, but I