[The outcome so far of the Cleveland child…]
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-02-25Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
The outcome so far of the Cleveland child sex abuse inquiry has set back the whole Doctors Higgs and Wyatt have been removed from their posts. Most of the children have been returned to their parents. The traditional view has been publicly vindicated — the problem of child sex abuse is over-estimated by overzealous doctors and heavy-handed social workers.
Prior to Cleveland it looked like, at long last, the question of child sex abuse was being seriously discussed. TV programmes, newspaper and magazine articles, were focusing on the issue, exposing its real extent, and beginning to look at different ways of dealing with it. Now, it is business as usual. But the problem still remains. Children still get sexually abused by their fathers, brothers, family friends.
So what is the truth of the matter? Well, the anal dilation test used by Dr. Higgs is clearly not a reliable test for sex abuse. The test was initially developed after research on a very small sample of "high risk" children - children already suspected of having been sexually abused.
Once the test is transferred to the general population you do get a high proportion of 'false positives - children who are positive for other reasons, like chronic constipation or lax muscles. Higgs' insistence on the complete reliability of her methods, her unwillingness to accept other medical views, is simply not good medical practice.
It is true that the vast proportion of what seem likely to have been "false positives' in Cleveland caused a terrible amount of unnecessary pain. Apart from the ethics of performing distressing anal examinations on children who are not already suspected of having been sexually abused, the heartache caused to the families must have been tremendous.
But all the newspapers focused on this angle. Not surprisingly so — the family is an almost sacred institution in this society, and any By Katherine O'Leary suggestion that it is not the heaven it is supposed to be is seen as an attack on one of the lynchpins of capitalist society. Capitalism needs the family, and will leap to its defence when it is under attack.
But the truth is, that whatever techniques are used to detect child sex abuse, however careful and sensitive doctors and social workers are, there will be some parents who are wrongly accused of abusing their children.
Mistakes will still be made. This is sad, but inevitable. Our priority should be to protect children, and any suspicion that a child has been abused should be investigated.
The Cleveland Inquiry did raise some important issues - sadly the most important were those not given prominence in the press.
Most experts in the field of child abuse say that the key thing is to isten to and believe the child. If this nad been done in Cleveland many of the problems would have been avoided. Children do need to be given the confidence to tell other adults about what has been done to hem. What they don't need is strange adults insisting, on the basis of extremely dubious medical evidence, that daddy has done iomething terrible to them. Think of the emotional damage that in tself can do to a child.
As socialists we do have to insist. hat child abuse is a real problem. It joes on in the home which, far rom being a safe haven, is often a ery dangerous place for children. The relations of power which exist n society are mirrored in the home. There, at least, the man who might lave a low-paid, degrading job, can se 'king of the castle'. Children are lis property. To be good is to do as rou're told — it's not surprising hat this should sometimes extend nto sexual abuse.
In the long run, we will only get id of child sex abuse by getting rid if the sick society that warps luman relationships. But in the lere and now, we need to give hildren more confidence, and to irovide adequate social work serDr Marietta Higgs vices that can deal sensitively with abuse, rather than be forced into crisis management.
Phone-lines for children, refuges, perhaps on the model of those for battered women, are part of the answer. Social work services must be changed - often mothers who suspect their child is being abused keep quiet for fear of their child being immediately taken into care. Social work must become a service for families, rather than a state 'soft cop'.l socialist bureaucracies.
We stand:
For full equality for women, and social provision to free women from the burden of housework. For a mass working class based women's movement.
Against racism, and against deportations and all im.nigration controls.
For equality for lesbians and gays.
For a united and free Ireland, with some federal system to protect the rights of the Protestant minority.
For left unity in action; clarity in debate and discussion.
Tuesday 23 February.
Oxford SO meeting, 'Where We Stand'. Speaker: Lynn Ferguson. 8pm, East Oxford Community Centre.
Wednesday 24 February.
Merseyside SO meeting, 'Th Housing Crisis. Speaker:
Helen McHale. 7.45, Wallasey Unemployed Centre.
Wednesday 24 February.
Canterbury SO meeting, "Workers in the Eastern Bloc'. Speaker: Tim Anderson. 1pm. at the University.
Thursday 25 February.
Sheffield SO meeting: debat with Workers' Power on the Middle East. Speaker: Tom Rigby. 7.30pm.
Thursday 25 February._ Support the BTR Strikers new video and speakers, 6.30 at Lambeth Town Hall Organised by South London Support Group, 01-274 4000 x 372 Thursday 25 February York SO meeting, 'How unite Arab and Jewish workers'. Speaker: Clive Bradley!
Saturday 27 February. North London SO jumble sale. 2pm at the 'Red Rose, 129 Seven Sisters Rd, NZ. Saturday 27 February, Demonstration called by the National Union of Students against the Education Reforn Bill. Assemble 12 noon, Embankment.
Tuesday 1 March.
North London SO meeting, "Support the Health Workers'. Speakers: Mark Nevill, Nik Barstow, Pete Gilman. 7.30, 'Red Rose'. Wednesday 2 March. Edinburgh SO meeting, 'Socialists and Ireland'. 7.30, Windsor Buffet, Leith Walk.
Tuesday 8 March, Newcastle SO meeting. 'Palestine: two nations, two states'. 8pm, Tyne Rooms, 10 Pilgrim St.
For further details of SO meetings, contact 01-639 7965.
AFTER ALTON: A conference on Women's Liberation and Socialism into the 1990s.
Saturday 23 April, at Caxton House, 129 St Johns Way, London N19 Contact: Lynn Ferguso c/o 12A Canonbury Street, London N1 2TD.
----- pull-quotes -----
Women-and ALTON IS LANS whe-stnaggle: BILL OR TOr SOCHI672