[American war — for example in the huge…]
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-02-25Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 6
American war — for example in the huge demonstrations at Grosvenor Square that led for the first time to shocking clashes with police.
Two groups on the 'far left' in particular grew after '68: the International Marxist Group (IMG) and - much more so - what was then called the International Socialists (IS) and later became the Socialist Workers' Party (SWP).
The IMG were vital in organising the mass-based Vietnam Solidarity Campaign, but tended to be invisible within it as a poltical tendency - although individual members, such as Tariq Ali, had a very high public profile. Furthermore, the IMG went along with the ultraleftism of a lot of the students. developing weird political strategies calling for 'red bases' in the universities ("sociologically inaccessible to the repressive forces of the ruling class"). The IMG's paper after the French general strike was underway headlined: "The power of student action!"
IS were more serious. Making a turn to 'Leninism' as a model of organisation (i.e. tightening up their, previously very loose structures), IS also turned their student recruits out to the growing workers' struggles. By the early '70s they had managed to acquire a relatively significant working-class base.
The other — at the time, biggest far left group was the Socialist Labour League (SLL) which later became the Workers' Revolutionary Party. They took a bitterly sectarian stand towards the student movement (denouncing VSC as a - but often stifled action from below that was independent of the national leadership.
From the mid-'seventies a major issue was the government's raising of fees for overseas students. Massive fee increases, besides being unfair, were a way to divide students from eachother. A big campaign to defend the rights of overseas students peaked in late 1979 with a wave of occupations.
The campaign was defeated. Overseas students' fees went up — reducing drastically the numbers of overseas students from less than extremely affluent backgrounds (which in turn had an effect in reducing student militancy, as overseas students had often been in the forefront).
In the wake of that defeat, the government introduced new measures for student union financing - very similar in aim to the defeated 1972 Thatcher proposals. The new rules were designed to tie student unions hand and foot to their college administration. The campaign to defend union autonomy was defeated.
But in 1981-2 there was a concerted student fightback - a big wave of occupations against educaby the National Organisatin ot Labour Students (NOLS). NOLS took a majority on NUS Executive in 1982, including the presidency: Neil Stewart became the first Labour NUS President.
Until the late '70s, NOLS had been invisible as a force for itself in NUS — keepng firmly in tow to the Communist Party-led Broad Left. The Broad Left transformed itself into the Left Alliance (LA) in 1979, and NOLS split - although not immediately - leaving the LA as a straightforward pact between the CP and the Liberals, Left From the mid-'70s, the far left in NUS consisted largely of the SWP and the Socialist Students' Alliance (SSA), which included the IMG. Within NOLS, the chief opposition had been Militant until the early 1980s. But by 1983 there was a serious left alternative in NOLS to its 'Clause 4' leadership (later broadened out to be the 'Democratic Left'). Socialist Student was formed, bringing together a number of tendencies and individuals and joining up with the fragments of what had been the SSA. Within Socialist Student the dominant force was Socialist Organiser.
Socialist Student rapidly grew to be the main left opposition within NUS. On a whole series of issues, Socialist Student led successful struggles against the 'Democratic Left' leadership — only to find that policy passed by conferences would be ignored by the leadership if they didn't like it.
It is because of this concerted challenge by Socialist Student that the 'Democratic Left' has resorted to old-fashioned witch-hunting tactics. For the first time the non-sectarian socialist left is in a position seriously to challenge the rightwing Labour leadership, and might defeat it.
Rise
Yet there are peculiarities in this situation. The rise of Socialist Student has not been accompanied by a wave of radicalisation comparable to the late '60s or early 70s. It is not that students are uniformly apathetic. Far from it: big struggles have continued to take place over cuts and other issues. But the general background today is the inability of the NUS leadership to cope with the "Thatcher years' Socialist Student's strength has been that it has provided immediate answers and shown the way forward - on basic questions such as the necessary strategy to fight the cuts, on the defence of student unionism, and on grants, benefits and housing.
Focused
Groups like the SSA in the '70s were unable to provide such immediate answers, and focused rather more on traditional revolutionary' issues - such as Ireland. Such issues are still discussed today; but the fundamental question has been how to reverse the retreats students haye endured for so long. dera tio •CVC Vol SLL bes Mo par SLU labe the
Scan page 7
NION CAMPAIGNS BS NUỆ WOR FORTY FUTUR ertain lessons can be drawn 1 the past two decades of stustruggles.
Broad ith sufficiently broad mobilisastudents can win campaigns 1 on their own, given the right ditions. For sure, nothing can won without grass-roots vilisation and rank-and-file inement. The 1972 campaign for ent union autonomy was the example of such a victory. e recently, government proIs to replace grants with loans had to be shelved at least in because of student opposition. it many of the attacks on nts have formed part of a -der Tory policy to beat down sition and impose cuts. To t such attacks, unity with the † movement is essential.
68 generation often saw -elves as the advanced guard' of social revolution. They saw how students in France had sparked a huge wave of working class militancy, and imagined that all they had to do to create such a movement in Britain was to appear on television getting their heads cracked open by the cops.
Many Many Marxists, who should have known better, completely capitulated to this impatient mood. The worst offenders were the IMG — which no longer exists, although its general ideological tradition is represented today by 'Socialist Action' ("Campaign Student').
Robin Blackburn, a prominent 'New Left Review' intellectual and member of the IMG in the late '60s and early '70s, argued in 1968 that *those who reject the strategy of the Red Bases... will be in serious danger of becoming the objective allies of social imperialism and social fascism"
Now many of the red-hot revolutionaries of '68 are right-wingers of various shades.
Sober
A more sober - though not a conservative - approach is needed. Students are a volatile social group, able to flip suddenly from militancy to apathy. That lasting links are made between the student and labour movements is essential for students to win, and thus prevent bouts of apathy.
Many students threw themselves into the miners' strike. The task now is for students — not just individuals, but student organisations - to join up with the growing industrial struggle against the Tories. The 'Democratic Left' who run NUS failed to build serious links with workers in struggle in the past. That's one reason why they need to be replaced. THE LEADERS of the National Union of Students, the 'Democratic Left' (DL) faction, want SSiN expelled from the For standing up against their incompetence, their passivity, and their inability to organise students in NUS, the DL want SSiN expelled.
For expoosing the corruption in the National Organisation of Labour Students (NOLS), the DL want SSiN expelled.
For beating the DL on most domestic policy issues in NUS for the last four years, they want SSiN expelled.
Hiding behind a dubious Labour Party constitutionality, the DL have run to the Labour Party, asking the NEC to rescue them by getting rid of us.
The DL want SSiN to be taken to the National Constitutional Committee, which means that they want us expelled. But the DL have a problem. The thing they want to get us on is standing against NOLS candidates in NUS elections.
But NOLS candidates are not Labour Party candidates. The Labour Party NEC may NOLS slate its blessing or it may not - it doesn't make any ditference. NOLS National Committee decides the candidates, and NOLS is not the Labour Party. It is an affiliate - just like the Fabian Society or the Socialist Educational Association.
Constitutionally, there is nothing the Labour Party NEC can do about it if it doesn't like the candidates NOLS National Committee chooses. Constitutionally, it is none of their business. NOLS is not accountable to the NEC. And. therefore, wanting to expel SSiN members for standing against NOLS in NUS is like wanting to exTeachers" Alliance for standing int members Socialist an election in the National Union of Teachers against the Socialist Educational Alliance, which is an affiliate of the Labour Party just like NOLS.
The DL has another problem, much deeper than any lawyer or Star Chamber can resolve. That is: how can the DL explain their failings to any fair-minded jury?
The DL are accused of:
• Systematically rigging NOLS conferences for at least the last five years. We published evidence of this in the pamphlet 'A Stitch in Time', and they have never dared to reply.
• Refusing to allow elected Auditors to see the books, because they are covering up for the financial favours they have done for Labour Clubs which support them.
• Refusing to allow part-time Further Education students to join NOLS while allowing part-time postgraduates to join.
• Changing the rules at the last minute to defend their majority.
• Failing to maintain the organisation. In 1984 it had 7,000 members. Now NOLS has 5,000.
In NUS the DL are accused of:
• Failing to organise student support for Labour at the General Election, and bringing the Party into disrepute among students.
• Breaking NUS conference mandates we suspect, sabotaging them out of petty factional spite. Sabotaging the production of the Welfare Manual to discredit Simon. Pottinger - delaying its arrival in colleges by three months.
• Failing to do a job for the labour movement by running a recruitment drive among the thousands of YTS trainees in Further Education colleges. Failing to fill the gap in contact between youth and the labour movement that the end of the apprenticeship system and youth unemployment have created.
• Alienating Jewish students and the Union of Jewish Students to the extent that the UJS, the only genuinely representative body of any minority in the student population, is discussing withdrawing from NUS. Most glaringly, the DL tried to sell NOLS support tor Sunderland Poly's banned Jewish Society to UJS in return for UJS support for a NOLS candidate in an NUS election.
• Creating such a bad name for the Party that out of 17 Labour Party members on NUS executive, only 10 chose to stand on the NOLS slate. The previous year there were 14 Labour Party members on the Executive, of whom nine were elected on the NOLS slate.
• Portraying Labour as Stalinist party, with Stalinist ideology and Stalinist methods.
Within their own terms of reference the DL have an even bigger problem. The majority of Party leaders believe the Left to be an electoral liability. That is the basic reason for the recent expulsions of left-wingers from the Party.
-But in NUS it is plainly untrue that the Left loses elections for Labour. Last year Simon Pottinger of SSiN beat Jo Gibbons, the official NOLS candidate, for Vice-President Welfare. A candidate supported by SSiN for Finance Committee (not normally a base for the 'loony left'!) beat the NOLS candidate by a margin of almost three and a half to one.
It is not true that the Left are unelectable. It is not true in General Elections, and it is not true in NUS. The electorate, and in this case NUS conference, will respond to candidates who tell the truth, who conduct themselves honestly and politically, and who say what they think rather than what they think the audience will like.
Unfortunately for the DL, they are going to have to explain just how come a small group of people with little money came to give them — who have the Party label to cling to, and lots of money — a thrashing both politically and organisationally.
xcuse The excuse the DL gives in NUS to explain SSiN's successes is that SSiN have done deals with the Union of Jewish Students. It is not true. SSiN and UJS certainly have worked together. There has never been a quid-pro-quo deal with UJS or anyone else in NUS.
The climate on the left is tainted with anti-semitism - unintentional, unclear, but unmistakable. The DL have tapped into thinking which says: Zionists are racists; the UJS are Zionists; SSiN works with UJS; ergo, SSiN are racists, or the next worst thing.
The DL have also tapped into a reservoir of anti-semitism in the belief that Jews plot and conspire. If SSiN works with UJS, then that is Trotskyists and Jews, the twin devils, conspiring together.
The DL are more than happy to invoke the appalling idea that all Jews in Britain — unless they are explicitly and vehemently antiIsraeli — are personally responsible for Israeli government policy. Diaspora Jewry has a collective responsibility for Israel and everything it does. Therefore, "by association, SSIN are supposedly apologists for Israel, responsible for the deaths of Palestinian Arabs!
The DL play on the equally prejudiced myth that if someone is in UJS then they must be right-wing. Conspiracy-spotting is a good cover for the DL. It deflects blame for NOLS's appalling record in NUS by trying to focus everyone's attention on a common enemy — "Zionists' And by "Zionists' ', they mean Jewish Zionists.
The DL are trying to save their careers at the expense of Jewish students. They are playing with fire by kindling left-wing anti-semitism.
That is just one more good reason why the DL have to be called to order.
----- pull-quotes -----
STUDENT UNION CAMPA •E DEMAND JOBS NOI CONTACT NUS FOR THE EUTURE