Feminists are not moralists
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-02-18Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
OPEN 24 HRS been telling women for decades that ting 'a nice screw", , one thing is certhat's what they want and that's tain, such ideas should not be linkwhat they need. What is a nice ed in an article about pornography screw? I always thought the term or in arguments about por"screw' suggested women as nography.l the truth or merits of women wan- pornography are opposites, not Socialist Organiser no.346 18 February 1988 Page 10 It was good to see a reply (Penny Newell, SO 345) to Lynn Ferguson's article, '"My Erotica, Your Porn" (SO 344), but the reply was still far too soft and missed the essential point.
I always thought the idea of your erotica, my porn' meant that what is for men's sexual gratification is based on and perpetuated women's oppression.
1 agree that Page 3 should not be banned for the one reason, and one reason alone, that we should not give the state that power, power they will inevitably abuse. We would be in favour of workers refusing to produce this material.
The fact that women's bodies are portrayed in a degrading way every day in newspapers which millions of people see is a serious issue. These mages must shape, if not define, men's and women's view of women. It is something to be angry about, not to dismiss.
Is pornography . the symptom, women's oppression the cause, socialism the answer? This is not a Marxist approach or one we would usually adopt. After all, golliwogs are surely a symptom of racism, but firstly we do not defend the right to distribute golliwogs and secondly we recognise that such things perpetuate and reinforce racism. To state glibly that something is only a symptom is posture politics and more familiar in the pages of Militant.
The article claims to be the beginning of a debate. The starting point for a debate about pornography is not 'what is erotica?' and 'what is porn?' but what exactly is the nature of pornography.
Where does it come from? What are its effects? Whose interests does it serve? How do we fight it?
The fact that women are sexually aroused by pornography is totally passive, men as active. Whatever Clare Short's bill proposing Women's sexual liberation and part of the same. Just like we say rape is about violence and not sex, so porn is not about women's erotica.
HELEN MCHALE, Manchester