Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Glasnost and gree

Socialist Organiser no. 346, 18 February 1988 · scan p. 10 · about 483 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

Last week I looked at glasnost and pollution in the USSR. New anti-pollution measures are being introduced in the USSR, but they highlight how bad things were before.

Yuri Izrael, chair of the USSR State Committee on Hydrometereology and Control of the Natural Environment, is quoted by an official magazine.

Izrael estimates total air pollution in the USSR at 105 million tonnes per year (65Mt from industry and 40Mt from vehicles). This compares. favourably with the USA's 150Mt until you take into account the USA's greater industrial base and its vastly greater number of vehicles, Most illuminating is the way Useinova (and Izrael?) tries to explain the causes of the ecological *The negative processes that manifested themselves Soviet society in the 70s and early '80s were among the main underiying reasons. They included extensivetype development, the spend principle in the economc mechanism and insufficient openness and democracy in discussing and tackling problems. Consequently, departmentalism and commandist and technocratic approaches triumphed, hampering in the past decades the full use of the advantages of the socialist system and planned economy, especially in solving the problems of ecology."

"Departmentalism" is explained as *fulfilling narrow economic tasks such as growth of production", ignoring ecological and social problems. Russian laws for environmental protection have been unable to modify this situation.

The case of Lake Baikal is most blatant. Useinova describes how, for 20 years, "scientists, authors, workers and people of most diverse trades" had proved that Baikal was no place for a pulp and paper mill. They argued that the world's most beautiful lake and largest body ofpure fresh water must be safeguarded against industrial pollution.

The ministry responsible partly resisted, partly acceded to these arguments, uprating pollution controls from time to time.

Overall they spent as much as it they had just built a new mill away from Baikal. They finally agreed to environmentalist demands but, emphasises Useinova, only after 20 years. In contrast, the public succeeded changing the Lake Ladoga mill's output in less than 2 years. "Restructuring, openness and democratisation are bearing fruit."

She lists several other projects now subject to public discussion and then describes the new law on State Enterprise which has a special article on "The Use of Nature and Environmental Protection". This obliged enterprises to use natural reserves in a renewable way and to use non-waste technologies to keep the environment intact. Failure to do this will render an enterprise financially liable for any damage and may result in its shutdown.

No doubt, environmental protection is being used as a stick by one part of the bureaucracy to beat the back of the other part, but the opening of questions of control of industry to public discussion can only benefit the work of true socialists. How different from Czechoslovakia, where the authors of a critical report on the environment (see SO, November 7) have been rounded up by the police!

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 346

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →