A nasty, spiteful lot
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-02-18Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
cover-up «White Mischief' is rather an inadequate title for a movie the decadent British in 1940s Kenya. These settler aristocrats not only drink and drug and get off with each other's spouses, but they aren't above a spot of murder too. Rather more than just mischief, one might think.
Why make this film at all? That is probably a greater mystery than the so-called mystery at the centre of the film. These unsavoury people aren't set against any background, so the film isn't really looking at the role of the British colonists in Kenya. The native population barely get a supporting role, except to do the classic walk-on parts of bringing in the drinks or the afternoon tea.
The film makers seem to have dispensed with a real story since the film is based on actual events - the murder of Lord Erroll, a notorious philanderer, even by Happy Valley standards, in the 1940s.
We see the young bride, Diana Broughton, with her ageing husband, Jock, and we know she'll get off with Erroll, and that Erroll will be shot. All that has come out in the press releases.
The film goes nowhere after that. Jock Broughton was tried and acquitted of the murder, but the film seems to say he was guilty anyway. Tha naaa ia far fram en anan_and tue case is tal mom so open anushut. There were other people around with motives, but the film isn't interested in them. All it seems interested in is a fashion show.
Greta Scacchi's Diana is photogenic, and she does get to wear nice clothes, and live in a nice house. But so what? Who cares about these people and their sordid affairs? Not me.
You can't work up an ounce of sympathy for anyone in it. Everyone is either a nutter or just plain unpleasant. Jock probably was pathetic, but he's portrayed as such a crawly masochist that Diana seems to be doing him a favour by Derek the lad Clive Bradley looks at Derek Hatton's book 'Inside Left' (Bloomsbury. £3.95) Derek Hatton, as you might expect, is utterly contemptuous of the London 'loony left' 'On one occasion", he recalls in his autobiography, "they spent hours discussing who should be on the platform for a national rally. Just when we had sorted it out, up they popped to demand equal numbers of men and "I lost my rag, turned to John Hamilton and said: 'Hey, John, if you put a skirt on, that should solve the problem!' You can imagine the sort of reaction that aroused"
Hatton's frustration with "the London loony left, more concerned about black mayors and gay rights than about The real Kenya: racism and oppression treating him badly. Sarah Miles's Alice goes even further over the top than we're used to. All I can reveal is that she isn't bothered by normal standards of respect for the dead.
-Everyone is either vicious or too stupid to be vicious. After Jock's . Considering how chummy she'd been to him before, this is a bit thick, but then they're a nasty, spiteful lot.!
Most of the crowd jeer at Gilbert Colvile, who became Diana's second husband. They think he has gone 'native' by being friendly with building new houses" is expressed with all the self-important arrogance that we have come to expect from this 'great workers' leader'. It's not really a political criticism of the radical pressure-group politics of many Labour councils. It's Degsy proving himself to be one of the lads.
Judging by the extracts published (to great financial gain for Hatton, presumably) in the Sunday Times, the whole book's like that - less analysis than an exercise in megalomania.
Hatton's precise relationship to Militant these days is difficult to work out. But it's hard to see how the Militant editorial board could be very happy with Hatton's book. Even though it describes Militant's editor Peter Taaffe as "the greatest political thinker I have ever met" ', the book will be a delight to Labour Party witch-hunters. the Masai and driving round with them. But the Masai tend Gilbert's cattle for free, because they love cattle. And Gilbert is laughing all the way to the bank. He's the richest-man in the colony_ so what harm is there in going a little native?
Exposé
If the film is meant as an expose of the sordid British settlers, living it up in Kenya while the gallant Brits at home fought a world war, then it needs a little more contrast. But was there much contrast? Weren't the ruling classes at home Martin Thomas reviews "Liverpool, A City That Dared to Fight', by Peter Taffe and Tony Mulhearn. (Fortress Books, £6.95).
Anyone can suffer defeats. the best socialists make mistakes. In hectic times, and under fire, even good Marxists often look at their own mistakes with a less coolly critical eye than they would wish.
But after the defeats, after the mistakes, after the emergency cover-ups for those mistakes, there has to come a time for learning lessons. People who cannot think critically even then are no Marxists at all.
In 1983 the avowed Marxists of Militant gained a dominant position on Liverpool Labour council. They promised to use it as a platform for mobilising workers to defeat the Tories, and up to May 1984 they made a reasonable start on that.
Since then they have been defeated. The council has made cuts. It is now under more-or-less business-as-usual Labour management. 47 councillors have been surcharged. Numerous Militant supporters have been expelled from the trying first to chum up with Hitler, then fighting him when it seemed he wanted what they considered their rightful share of the world cake?
Wasn't the war partly about defending those very Happy Valley settlers and their way of life?
Bang goes the contrast! It's a relief to know that Kenya finally became independent from the British. But independence came twenty years after these events! Twenty more years of bringing in drinks to people like these before the Kenyans stopped playing supporting roles, and took the leads.
Maybe it still needs to be said that Defeat was possible with the best policies, but in fact mistakes by Militant contributed heavily to the defeat.
*After May 1984, with the miners' strike in full swing, they ran down their mass campaign and turned instead to gettinz a crisispostponing deal with the Government.
*In early 1985, when a number of Labour councils talked of defying the government, Liverpool sat back, keeping (so it thought) well within the law.
*In June 1985 they stumbled into an unbalanced, illegal budget. And then for three months silence followed. There was only the most general, bland campaigning. Council workers could only guess when the council was going to run out of money and what the council leaders would do then.
*In September the council leaders suddenly announced that they would run out of money in two weeks, and issued 30,000 redundancy notices..."purely as a legal device," they explained.
*They withdrew the redundancy notices under union pressure. Á ballot for all-out strike was lost -undoubtedly because of the redunSocialist Organiser colonialism was a brutal system, forcing the native population into servile roles and destroying their livelihoods. But this film doesn't really do that job.
Watching the film, I kept wishing for a few Mau Mau to come stealing up the garden path to teach this crowd a lesson. But it's twelve years too early for them in this movie.
You'll have to see "The Kitchen Toto' if you want the Mau Mau, though that film doesn't really do them justice.
"White Mischief" may do the Kenyan settlers justice, but does anyone really care? dancy notices. Then the council sent out the redundancy notices again!
*It continued to bluster about the struggle going ever onwards and upwards while it tried ever more desperate tactics — like planning to lay off the entire council workforce for a month! - before making a deal with the banks. It made cuts.
Despite the great and ponderous bulk of their book - over 500 pages - Taaffe and Mulhearn scarcely mention most of these turning points. They do concede that the redundancy notices were "a major tactical error", but all they say in explanation is that "perhaps if Liverpool City Council had been entirely made up of Militant supporters" the error would not have been made. That hardly explains why the redundancy notices were not only issued by the council, but also hotly defended by Militant, In 500 pages of unremitting selfcongratulation, Taaffe and Mulhearn hardly ever seem to recognise that there have been defeats. They even warmly defend Derek Hatton, whose antics since: the council's fiasco have discredited him throughout the labour movement and among many Militant supporters. no.346 18 February
Scan page 10
ers
----- pull-quotes -----
reviews 'White Mischief*.
trial, Gwladys Delamere mutters, 'I alan: hongering was frummal