A class alternative
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-02-18Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 7
openly the democratic secular state advocated by the PLO since the late '60s. In part this is because of the material position of the West Bank population - for whom it is easier to settle for a West Bank/Gaza state than it is for the refugeesand in part it is due to the intluential position of the Communist Party, which has a 'two states' position.
Israel has been heavily repressive towards this political movement -deporting mayors, imposing curtews, arresting activists and so on. The invasion of Lebanon in 1982 was partly designed to deal with the political movement in the West Bank. It was, in the words of Israel's Chief of Staff Rafael Eitan, a "war for Eretz Israel" — to consolidate their hold on "Judaea and Samaria' by destroying the PLO and thus beheading the political movement in the occupied territories.
Disaster
The Lebanese war failed to achieve this result. In some respects, indeed, it was a disaster for Israel, opening wide cracks in Israeli Jewish society which are still widening today.
Different political, cultural, youth, women's and trade union organisations have developed in the occupied territories - generally with stronger roots in the West Bank. These have all faced repression. But in the current uprising, although its origins were clearly spontaneous, this Palestinian 'national movement' has been playing a vital role.
Although a substantial proportion of Palestinian Arabs are Christian, not Muslim, the old secular movement has been forced to link up with the rising force of Islamic fundamentalism. The precise strength of the fundamentalists is difficult to gauge, but particularly in Gaza they do seem very strong.
Political fundamentalism goes back to the 1930s in Egypt in the shape of the Muslim Brotherhood. It is this tradition (much older than Khomeinism) that has spawned the new groups in Gaza.
Initially, the fundamentalist organisations were boosted by the Israeli authorities as an alternative to the PLO. Now they must regret it. But the current alliance between PLO factions and the Jihad group must be unstable. Will the Jihad outstrip the PLO? It is too early to nI A9 Tele tan sarluta say. Socialists would hope not.
What ae the prospects in the occupied territories? Even the most intense struggle by the Palestinian Arabs is unlikely simply to drive Israel out. Israel is immensely Palestini an day abourers sraeli teacher and pupils in East Jerusalem strong - and the settlers provide an extra problem. Support for Palestinian independence within Israel — among both Arabs and Jews - will be essential. Such support is growing.
The Israeli Arabs were long considered the most docile of Palestinians; now they too are mobilised against the occupied territories. Amongst Jews there is a shift to the right, but at the same time a growth of the radical left.
Although Israel has created a lot of 'facts' to obstruct Palestinian independence, it is possible. The current uprising has forced the issue to the heart of Israeli politics - the istalus Katatina? of tha anauniad tarnitaniac will be the major issue in this year's election. Solidarity from within Israel and elsewhere can help see that the 'status' will be: a fully independent and sovereign Palestinian state. Nationalism, rather than politics, dominates on all in the Middle East.
The Jewish working class in Israel is tied into a trade union movement, the Histadrut, which is also the biggest employer in the country.
The Israeli Labour Party, despite ite nama drawe ite cunnort mainlu to support many not from workers, on a class basis, but from the better-off middle class of European origin. Working class Jews, usually of Asian or African origin, are more likely to support the right-wing Likud alliance.
Among the Palestinian Arabs, would-be socialist or Marxist groups, and trade unions, function only as a left wing within the Palestine Liheration Organisation. The PLO, an umbrella cross-class movement, is dominated by the Palestinian bourgeoisie — for there are many wealthy Palestinians in the Gulf and elsewhere, and the PLO itself has a big business empire.
Elsewhere in the Arab world, appeals to the cause of the nation -and in particular of the nation's struggle against "Zionism and imperialism' — rarely fail to stifle independent working-class politics.
What is the answer? How can socialists propose a solution to the real national grievances and fears that exist, and begin to unite Arab and Jewish workers?
The Palestinian Arabs have suffered terribly for more than 40 years. The anguish, bitterness and desperation generated among Europe's Jews by the Nazi massmurder of six million Jews and the callous indifference of the Great Powers vented itself on the Palestinian Arabs in 1948. The Jews in Palestine, fired by a fresh determination to trust and to give no quarter to any but their own people, carved out their own state. taking the bulk of the territory which had once been Arab Palestine.
Since 1967 Israel has ruled over 1½ million Arabs in the West Bank and Gaza through an army of occupation.
Many people on the left interpret these facts by assuming that the Zionist enterprise was and is a 'conspiracy', identified totally with ımperialism. General denunciation of "Zionism' and 'Zionists' follows, in terms which imply that the 'Zionists' have no rights in Palesa righes. except possibly inClass considerations therefore give way to national/communal nateanriec The Arah ruline classes have more than once massacred Palestinians, and willingly condemn them to be pawns on the political chessboard; but this outlook puts the Arab states on the 'progessive side. The whole question is seen as a mere item in the struggle between progressive and reactionary, good and bad, camps on a world scale. The problem is thus defined almost as a conflict of good and bad peoples.
But socialists should approach all questions of national and communal antagonisms from the view point of the class struggle, and of the working class programme for solving such conflicts by way of consistent democracy.
The Palestinian Arabs are bitterly oppressed; but a Jewish nation exists. in Palestine. We want democracy not revenge. We do not want to visit the sins of the Zionist fathers and mothers on their sons and daughters, or preach "collective guilt" of the entire Israeli-Jewish people for the deeds of their governments. A Jewish nation exIsts. It has rights. None of those rights mean anything unless they include the nation's right to have its own state on some territory of its own - for the Israeli Jews cannot be stopped from having their own state except by complete conquest and suppression.
Champion
We champion the Palestinian Arabs' fight against oppression and displacement on a programme not of the implicit or explicit denial of Jewish rights, but of compensation, restitution, division of the disputed territory, and conciliation.
We say Israel should get out of the West Bank and Gaza. We advocate the immediate creation of a Palestinian Arab state alongside an Israeli-Jewish state (a modified version of Israel). We advocate an end to all discrimination against the Arabs under Israeli rule. We advocate full and equal citizenship for the Arabs, and the right to secede to the Palestinian-Arab state of the majority-Arab districts in Israel.
Revolutionary militants must aptegrate those two viewpoints. We are against chauvinism and national exclusivism everywhere, whether in Britain, Northern Ireland, or Palestine; and the Palestinian Jews are chauvinistic and exclusive. We support those in Israel and the West Bank/Gaza who fight for JewishArab equality. But the ending of Jewish chauvinism and exclusiveness is not and cannot be, for us, a precondition for accepting that the Jews have rights in Palestine.
Right The Jews have the right to a certain portion of the territory of Palestine by virtue of the fact that they are there, and most of the Jews now there were born there. Their rights there cannot be made conditional on how they conduct themselves in that territory, any more than the openly chauvinist line of the Palestinian Arabs' leaders up to the late 1960s could nullify the Palestinian Arabs' national rights.
We recognise the right to self-determination of the Israeli Jews; we support those in Israel who fight chauvinism and exclusiveness and advocate equal citizenship of Arabs and Jews; we advocate an independent Palestinian-Arab state on the best terms possible which are compatible with Israeli-Jewish national rights. All these elements must be combined into one coherent working-class socialist viewpoint, and a fight for a socialist federation of the Middle East.
Scan page 8
ontest the leade the Id rship!
"The left has been reluctant to support annual contate The electoral college was won in 1981. Ever since then Labour's left has been reluctant to support CLPD's call for annual contests. Only such contest can ensure accountability of the leadership to the party and substantially reduce the elitist gap between Leader and Deputy and the rest of the NEC whose places are contested every year.
To inflate the importance of the two leadership positions is unhealthy in a democratic party: it encourages a cult of personality -undesirable in itself, but just pathetic, given the present incumbents.
There are now very pressing reasons to use the electoral college.
Since 1982 when the Right came to dominate the NEC and Conference, and particularly since the election of the present leader in 1983, the Party has travelled a long way from democratic socialism. If the drift to the right continues Labour's next programme will not differ significantly from that of the merged Liberal and Social Democratic Party. This will reduce Labour's electoral chances.
Should the Tories be so unpopular that a Labour government were returned, despite everything, it would find itself unable to tackle the country's problems and would suffer defeat at the next general The leadership's analysis of the cause of Labour's electoral failures is a mistaken one. Nevertheless, it has been swallowed, albeit sometimes reluctantly, by most Party members. The leadership's fundamental premise is that Labour was rejected because it clung to outdated beliefs about the way society should be changed.
The party must, of course, keep in step with changes in society, and gear its programme to them. It must also develop new ways of getting its programme across. This in no way necessitates, however, a retreat from Labour's basic objectives.
But this is the course on which the party leadership has embarked. Yet, it is impossible to ensure steady economic growth and the return to full employment without using the productive resources at present idle. This, however, inevitably involves government intervention in the economy by taking over the top
Danny Nicol (all
CLPD).
companies in each major industrry, and financial institutions.
The present party policy, however, merely proposes unspecified forms of 'social ownership' based on hypothetical mass participation in economic decision-making. No amount of vague talk is a substitute for a programme of economic reconstruction and in any case genuine democratic management is only realisable in the public sector.
The leadership's policies amount to the acceptance of the capitalist economic framework. So much is also clear from Neil Kinnock's Latest statement on the EEC, that *The prospects of withdrawal, in my view, are nil".
Conflict
Thus any future Labour government which in rebuilding the economy came into conflict with Common Market rules would have to abide by them at the public's expense. Nor can industry be regenerated without a substantial reduction in defence expenditure. Yet the leadership opposes this.
The present reactionary climate does make things difficult for Labour but its roots are complex and run deeper than the attractiveness or unattractiveness of Labour's policies. It will not be overcome by making concessions to The last two Labour governments helped create it. So have the statements of our Front Bench, who in their repeated attacks on the Left reinforced Tory propaganda that Labour is divided and under siege from a lunatic extremist fringe. So far as the general public is concerned, it follows that Thatcher alone can deal with the country's difficulties.
The Left can reverse the Party's disastrous course if it puts forward a comprehensive alternative and do everything to get it adopted. Only contests for Leader and Deputy, however, will ensure that the attention of members is focused on the alternative Left programme. Failing this, the Left's criticisms will receive the same scant attention that they have had until now. It is encouraging that the Campaign Group of Labour MPs is at last coming round to this view.
As important is that any campaign for an alternative leadership is restricted to debate strictly within the party and labour movement press. Conscious effort must be made to reduce media interference to a minimum. When speaking to jouralists or on TV those on the Left slate must limit themselves to attacking the Tories and refrain from making any comment on internal party affairs. Campaigning should be through the extensive distribution of literature within CLPs and union branches. The Right may well make full use of the media, which is always willing to exploit Labour's disagreements or misrepresent its normal democrane processes as civil war. The desire for party unity among rank and file party members and Labour voters must not be underestimated.
A contest should not necessarily be tied to an expectation of victory this year, next year or the year after. It may take some time before the Party realises that he leadership is on a hopeless course. For this reason, as well as to fulfill the college's original aims, this year's election must not be a one-off happening but the start of annual leadership contests as an integral part of the party's routine annual elections, no different from those for Treasurer and the other 26 members of the NEC.
It is up to the Left to establish annual leadership contests as a fully accepted democratic procedure in the party if it is to offer a focus of resistance to the drift from socialism. Wednesday 17 February.
Canterbury SO meeting, 'Women and Socialism'.
7.30pm.
Friday 19 February. Sheffield SO meeting, 'Where We Stand'. Speaker: Lynn Ferguson. 1pm at the Univer sity.
Tuesday 23 February. Oxford SO meeting, Where We Stand'. Speaker: Lynn Ferguson. 8pm, East Oxford Wednesday 24 FebruarY The Community Centre.
Merseyside SO meeting, Housing Crisis'. Speaker: Helen McHale. 7.45, Wallasey Unemployed Centre.
Thursday 25 February. Sheffield SO meeting: deba with Workers' Power on the Middle East. Speaker: Tom Rigby. 7.30pm.
Thursday 25 February. Support the BTR Strikers -new video and speakers, 6.30 at Lambeth Town Hall. Organised by South London Support Group, 01-274 4000 x 372.
Saturday 27 February. North London SO jumble sale. 2pm at the 'Red Rose, 129 Seven Sisters Rd, N7. Saturday 27 February. Demonstration called by the National Union of Students against the Education Reforn Bill. Assemble 12 noon, Embankment.
Tuesday 1 March. North London SO meeting, 'Support the Health Workers' Speakers: Mark Nevill, Nik Barstow, Pete Gilman, 7.30, "Red Rose'.
Tuasday 8 March. Newcas tle SO meeting, 'Palestine: two nations, two states" 8pm, Tyne Rooms, 10 Pilgrim St.
For further details of SO meetings, contact 01-639 7965.
Bristol District Labour Party are organising a conference on the weekend of Friday 26 February and Saturday 27th entitled "Labour Fights Back!
----- pull-quotes -----
proach this question from two view- points simultaneously, and in-
Vladimir Derer, Sarah Mann,