Aimless and valueless
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-02-18Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 3
Truly, the dog days are upon us.
No sooner had the row died down over David Steel's and Robert Mclennan's "Voices and Choices" — a statement of Liberal/SDP aims that no-one in either party semed to agree with, than Neil Kinnock and Roy Hattersley launched their 'Aims and Values' on an unsuspecting Labour Party.
The 3500-word document claims to set out the democratic socialist principles that will steer the Labour Party into power at the next election. But the authors' hopes seem to see no further than Thatcher's Britain - only nicer.
Socialism doesn't really get a look in. The statement offers a lengthy exposition on how socialists are for individual freedom, and goes on to wrestle with how the free market and the capitalist state square with this.
On the free market Kinnock and Hattersley are quite resolute. The free market is not at all nice when applied to things like health, social security and education. However, The operation of demand and supply and the price mechanism is a generally satisfactory means of determining provision and consumption.
All the state has to do, according to messrs. Kinnock and Hattersley, is make sure "that competition is fair and that the necessary regulations exist."
Socialist Organiser Mondon SELIS 4NA 01-639 7965 Latest date for reports: first post Monday or by phone, Editor: Mahony Typesetting: Upstream Ltd (TU). 01-358 1344.
Published by Socialist 23.
London SE15 4NA.
Printed by East West Graphics (TU). Registered as a Signed articles do no necessarily reflect the view of Plan tibrga So what do socialists do when the market mechanism leads capitalism into bone-crunching slumps?
Mr Hattersley should know. He was Minister for Consumer Protection in the Callaghan government in the mid-"70s.
But the price controls and market regulation of that period did nothing to help working class peoKinnock and Hattersley advocate the 'enabling state' , but show a wilful ignorance of how the modern capitalist state works. Get a load of this:
"Socialists had always actively The 1500 seafarers on strike at upheld the view that there was a clear responsibility on government to protect and dead. its sitizens by: maintaining effective axmed torces,. "by civilian policy and by the rule of law."
Who were the RUC protecting and defending when they gunned down five unarmed men under the 'shoot-to-kill' policy? Who were the police protecting and defending when they laid into the miners in 1984-5? Who are the courts protecting and defending when they ban Spycatcher and seize union funds?
Where have Kinnock and Hattersley been for the last eight years?
The document fails to tackle any of the issues facing socialists in the 1980s. It is as if written in another age.
It is weakest on social ownership (its coy gesture towards socialism). = Kimock and Hattower talk airily of produeer and consumer co-ops, ignoring the fact that producer co-ops have provided jobs for only a tiny number of people. The last time they were tried on any scale - in the "70s - the largest of them collapsed when a Labour government pulled the rug from under them.
Many Labour MPs, normally four-square behind Kinnock -Bryan Gould, Robin Cook, even John Cunningham — have criticised the document's rosy view of market economics. It should be thrown out, and replaced through a discussion in which Labour will really "listen' to the working class. tips from the Independent is probably no bad thing (it is, after all, a very well-produced paper). But will the influence go deeper than that?
The Independent has quickly carved out a niche for itself as the standard-issue organ of Yuppiedom. Its news coverage is good, and the editorial line is by no means as leyally Thatcherite as most of the national press. But what really counts in the Indy is the 'lifestyle" content - the stuff about houses, holidays, cars...
And money. The Guardian, whatever its faults, always eschewed such consumerism and gave a high priority to the Great Issues of our time - the nuclear threat, unemployment, the plight of the Third World. It tended to cover such matters in a somewhat woolly, do-gooding sort of way, but at least it recognised that there are more important things in life than equity bonds and the acceleration figures