Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Poland after tr

Socialist Organiser no. 345, 11 February 1988 · scan pp. 6–8 · about 3,408 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 6

Polish workers struck last week at the Ursus tractor factory in Warsaw and the Skogar leather goods works in Lodz, demanding wage rises to compenate fully and imThe government has announced a series of price rises which, it says, will bring inflation this year to 45% and cut real wages by 8%. Jaruzelski organised a referendum on price rises last November, and failed to get the majority he wanted, but the IMF insists on the price rises and they are going ahead anyway.

2,000 people marched behind Soldarnosc banners in Gdansk on the day before the price rises came into effect, chanting 'Down with the price rises'. And the next day there was a demonstration in Warsaw protesting at the Rumanian government's repressionof the recent The wave of protest will strengthen a trend within Solidarnosc which has been arguing for the movement to drop its recently-adopted support for market economics and to focus on defending workers' living standards. Andrzej Gwiazda is one of 22 well-known Solidarnosc leaders who wrote a letter to Lech Walesa last September expounding this view. In this interview, reprinted from the magazine 'International Viewpoint", What attitude did referendum?

I thought that regardless of the content of the questions, our answers and our intentions, participating in the referendum had only one meaning. The government was looking for a popular endorsement. It was the same with the 1946 referendum. Instead of asking us the fundamental question whether we wanted a Communist Party government in Poland brought in by the Red Army - they asked us three substitute questions: Did we want social reforms, a single-chamber parliament and borders on the Oder-Neisse line (1). In participating in this referendum, we could say that we relinquished the western territories, but not that we could do without a Communist government.

We could not make the same mistake as before. In the recent referendum, we were asked to give up our right to defend ourselves against exploitation. On December 13, 1981, the regime responded to the demand for reforms to be carried out under the supervision of society by instituting a state of war.

Instead of looking for the cause of the crisis, they accused Solidarnosc of provoking it, and the reform theme was used to justify the continual price increases, inflation and restricting the rights of the workers.

After six years of uninterrupted reforms, young people no longer have any chance of finding a place to live, and most families have been tightening their belts for a long time, despite working harder and taking on second jobs. The most burning question today is the defence of workers' material interests. So, what had to be done was to call for a boycott with the slogan, *By boycotting the referendum, you are protesting against exploitation!

What is your assessment of the referendum results? According to the French press, Professor Geremek (Lech Walesa's main advisor) considers that it was a setback for everybody, because the government compromised the ideas both of the referendum and the economic reform.

If such views have been expressed, they are utter nonsense. The result of the referendum is a spectacular blow against Jaruzelski. It testifies to the fact that Polish society no longer believes in any reform by the Communists. This is the result of 40 years of a Communist regime. Jaruzelski told Moscow that he had everything under control, and that he had achieved total normalisatio.. He could even claim that there was general support for the economic reform, because it was supported by Lech Walesa, the Solidarnosc leadership and its experts. The referendum showed that all that was nothing but propaganda.

People gained confidence after the referendum. They feel more sure of themselves. Only they no longer think, as they did before, that there is a leadership and that it will lead their struggle. After I got out of prison in the summer of 1984, I travelled through the coun try for a year. I discussed with the main leaders of Solidarnosc, as well as with ordinary activists in the plants. I could see then that combativity was flagging, and that the leadership's authority was also on the wane - it was the TK at the time. Today, the evolution of the situation will depend to a large extent on the correlation between these two processes. If the leadermediately for the recent price rises.

workers' rebellion in Brasov.

Gwiazda explains his ideas.

ship's authority contines to decline, but not combativity, then people will begin to organise autonomously. Before, these two processes were parallel. Now, even betore the referendum, the ranks had begun to think independently. The referendum result is the expression of that.What do you think of the position taken on October 25 by the Solidar-nose National Executive Commission (KKW) on the referendum?

It was the worst imaginable. I was in a small provincial city at the time, and I discussed it with a Solidarnosc activist there. He told me, "You don't understand anything, because Walesa says that the reform is a good thing, but that there is no need to vote." The whole Solidarnosc leadership took the same position as Walesa, that society is hoping for an economic reform, that this reform is necessary but that, despite everything, it was better not to go to the polls. Onyszkiewicz, the representative of the Solidarnose leadership, said that it was better to go fishing or gathering mushrooms, because in any case the referendum results would not matter. That was very bad propaganda. On the other more intelligent propaganda than the government conducted ever. But despite this, the people refused to give their support. They are starting to think independently..

In your opinion why was the government so mistaken in its predictions?

Everyone is asking themselves that question today. Why did Jaruzeksli hold this referendum? I think that the team in power today is taken in a lot less by its own propaganda than those that preceded it. But it let its head be turned by the Solidarnosc leadership's propaganda. It thought that this leadership faithfully represented the opinion of society.

1 have heard such an opinion voiced by a representative of party and police circles. All you had to do, according to them, was listen to Walesa, the Solidarnosc leadership and the church and you would know it all. That is what convinced them to hold the referendum.

They did not realise that the views of the Solidarnose leadership had diverged from those of society. That is because society has no way of expressing itself, not even in the underground press.

The Solidarnosc leadership and the groups linked to it have established their monopoly over this press. The existence of the independent press and publishing houses is a marvellous thing. I say that witout any irony. But the distribution of the press and independent publications is weak! * Warsaw, it scems' ptherwise rus trator factory, in the ital because tere is a plant press in une Warszawa steelworks, in the FSO auto factory and in the Polkolor electronics factory! —But there are provincial cities and more generally many regions that this press does not reach. So, despite the existence of this press, the Western radio stations remain the main source of information. But these stations are no less given to censorship than those of the Reds. A document not approved by Walesa, the Solidarnosc leadership or its experts has no chance of getting on the air.

Consequently, the Solidarnosc leadership have made the same error as the PZPR (the Polish CP) -they have imposed their monopoly on the independent press.

Only their views are broadcast by Western radio stations; the others are eliminated. And so these groups are convinced that the whole of society shares their opinions. This news monopoly functioned effectively for a period, as it did for the Communist system.

Every individual thought, *1 have a different view, but all the others think like the press" (the clandestine press in our case). Before the referendum people said, *I will not go, but the others certainly will." It was not like that. What do you think of General Jaruzelski's economic reform programme!

In the first place, the regime is basing this reform on an economic theory of the free market. The West demands that Jaruzelski base himself on this theory, and this is demanded above all by the International Monetary Fund.

But this is absurd, because there is no free market; this theory has no application here. Secondly, our economists, who are trying energetically to convince us of the soundness of their reform, are people who have undoubtedly never Solidarnese demonstrates, 1987 seen a factory, who have no idea of what is going on in industry nor of how the production process unfolds.

They imagine that a big drop in the standard of living will lead to an increase in labour productivity and to an improvement in the quality of products. Since they have nothing o do with productive labour, the!

hink that if you drive the proles to get on with the job under the goad of hunger or the whip, that they will work hard enough to raise the standard of living of the others. In fact, all those who are discussing how to get society to work have living standards several times higher than most.

I am working now as a painter on a heating centre building site in Ciechanow in the centre of the country A welder of scaffolding earns 25,000 zlotys a month (2). A top category welder with dozens of years of seniority earns 30,000 zlotys. This is what the wages of most workers are like. Of course, there are enterprises where wages are better - steelworks Or shipyards. But I am talking about typical enterprises, like mine. Such wages are not enough today to feed a family, so most Poles are looking for supplementary jobs to do after their eight hours, obviously manual jobs.

For example, the boss on my building site clears away rubble after his workday, and the foreman at the end of his eight hours lays paving stones. And they are asking these people to let their real wages be cut in half. And they tell them. "If you want to keep your standard of living, you have to increase productivity." I don't doubt that they will manage it. I don't know how, but through their collective intelligence they will do it. Only at that time, I will refuse to go up with my brush onto the scaffolding built by my fellow workers, because I would be afraid that it would collapse under my weight.

If the Polish economy is sick, this sickness is caused by norms that are too high and therefore lead to a false productivity and in reality endanger immense losses. In 1980-1, I was invited to drink coffee with some ministers, because they wanted to know what I thought should be done to get the economy moving again. I told them that before anything else they had to lower the quantitative production norms by 40 percent without cutting wages and create the conditions for quality production.

It is only after that we can start to increase productivity, while increasing wages proportionally.

But the regime has always done exactly the opposite and this produces nothing, because Polish workers are very imaginative.

I have been working in industry for thirty years, and the workers still surprise me by their imagination. Their norms are increased, and despite that they manage to maintain their wages at the same level. I am a worker with a number of skills. I have worked as a lathe operator, a welder, and now l am a painter. So, I can judge how much time is necessary to make a given product.

The norms are such that it seems totally impossible to do the work in the assigned time, but they manage

Scan page 7

le referendum Simply they do not respect the chnological process. From the tside, the product seems to meet -ecification. It even has, if cessary, the indicated dimen-ns, but this product maintains its e value ten times less time than it ould, because it is produced by -minating 80 per cent of the ecified technical operations. All e workers' inventiveness is ected toward finding means for minating them.

The present economic reform will ice workers to find more tricks of s sort. On paper, productivity Il increase, and they will therefore tintain the level of their wages. t the economy will breakdown I more.

Ju are one of the signatories to the -ter of the 22 Solidarnose leaders Lech Walesa. In this letter you •ticise the Solidarnosc leaderp's lack of interest in defending rkers* living standards and you -nand the convocation of the Naual Commission elected by the an's congress in order to solve eproblem of its leadership. Could ¡ explain this demand?

The only document that defines wat Solidarnosc is and how it suld function is its statutes. Acding to these statutes, the union dership is made up of the NaJal Congress of Delegates, the ional Commission and the ConCommission. The tasks of the ional Commission, the statutes cate, are the tollowing: to reprethe union as a whole in dealings 1 the state, the economic addistration, as well as with the er institutions and organisations, coordinating the activity of the regional union organisations and adopting the budget.

A demand for convoking the union's only statutory leadership should not surprise any member. It is the right and duty of every member to de this, and in particular a member of the National Commission. It anybody were to ask us to justify our demand they would only show their ignorance of the rules that govern our union.

Why did our demand make so many waves - even arouse hostility? The object of every rule is to curb individual and group interests in the name of the general interest. The statutes of Solidarnosc are such rules. They oppose individuals' actions contrary to the interests of the union as a whole. It seems that we have people in Solidarnosc who are opposed to repsecting the statutes. I am with those who demand that the statutes be respected and applied. The present leaderhsip of Solidarnosc is not a statutory body.

But after the establishment of the state of war, it was not possible to act in accordance with the statutes. In the place of the National Commission, replacement bodies were to appear. The Provisional Coordinating Commission (TKK) was I was very happy when the TKK emerged. I was in an internment camp at the time. The need for foreveryone, because then it was im- ming the TKK was clear possible to do otherwise. However, the situation has changed since. When I got out of prison, I realised after a few months that there was absolutely no problem about convoking the National Commission. There were technical difficulties, to be sure, but they were far from being insurmountable. I have taken part in many meetings in which there were more than 200 unionists, and these meetings could be held. The National Commission has less than 100 members. Since then, conditions have become still more favourable.

If it is possible to apply the statutes, that should be done, if you want to stay in the framework of Solidarnosc. In such a situation, those who fail to apply the statutes place themselves outside the union Solidarnosc - not outside the social movement Solidarnosc, but outside the union. That seems clear to me. If a group makes it impossible to call a session of the statutory leadership of the union, then that group is standing in the way of the union functioning.

Why do you think this problem ists?

It is very simple. Monopoly conditions have appeared, and the group that has imposed this is doing everything it can to maintain it. The existence of groups aspiring to monopolise power is a natural thing. But democracy's purpose is precisely to make this impossible by establishing a balance between such groups and guaranteeing that they Will keep a check over each other.

Nonetheless, the leading group in Solidarnosc contains members who have various points of view. For example, some give priority to the fight for a market-type economic reform, while others favour giving priority to the trade union struggle in the plants, like the signatories to the letter of the 22, who consider that Solidarnosc is not paying enough attention to this question.

It is not paying any attention at all. Solidarnosc may be a social movement today, but it is certainly not a union. Since the establishment of the state of war, the groups that have taken the leadership have not been carrying out active trade union activity.

Henryk Wujec is an exception, because from time to time, timidly, he reminds people that after all we have to be a union.

I will give only one example: In the autumn of 1984 I met in Warsaw with a group of 40 workers from a plant, rank-and-file members of Solidarnosc. The workers sat quietly through the whole meeting; they said nothing. Only the leaders talked.

Shortly before midnight, the leaders left, and then the workers started talking, until Sam. I learned from them - not from the leaders - that new contracts were in the pipeline. When I came out of prison, none of the regional leaders talked to me about that. Either they did not know anything about it, or else they weren't interested. In that meeting, we discussed how to defend ourselves against this looming threat.

Later, I travelled through the country, and I collected documentation about this question. I drafted Andrzej Gwiazda a statement, and I intended to publish articles on this affair in the underground press. At that time, they were still publishing what I wrote, because I had just got out of prison and had to be reckoned with.

Unfortunately, Father Popieluszko's murder diverted everybody's attention, and the regime then took advantage of that to force through the new contracts, without arousing any protests. This question simply did not interest either the TKK or the regional leaderships, because they did not feel that they were in the shoes of union leadership. That has not changed.

You are very hard on the present leadership of Solidarnose.

Yes, that's so. I have a negative assessment of the work of the comrades who make up the KKW and the preceding leaderships.

I am in complete disagreement with their political line, with their conception of an understanding with the regime and their attempts to orient to it. I should add that I am equally shocked by the attitude they took following the recent arrest of Kornel Morawiecki, the underground leader of the Fighting Solidarnosc Organisation. As you know, the regime accuses Morawiecki of terrorist activity.

The KKW poses the problem in the following way: Solidarnosc has never been implicated in terrorism, but despite that we have to protest. In fact, that means the KKW giving legitimacy to the accusations made by the prosecutor and the propaganda of the government's representative, Jerzy Urban, who say that Fighting Solidarnose is a terrorist organisation.

That is an inadmissible and scandalous attitude. In common with some other independent activists — including Haline Mikolajska — we drew up a statement on this matter (3). If the ditterences that exist in the opposition were to lead us to treat each other the way Walesa and the KKW did Morawiecki, then the government would very soon be able to put us all in prison, including the comrades of the KKW, because no one would want to defend us, and rightly so.

1. This border was far to the west of Poland's pre-war western borders. The settlement granted lands to Poland that had been Polish centuries before in compensation for the eastern lands of inter-war Poland, which were incorporated into the Soviet Union. 2. According to the calculations made by Solidarnosc last October, to live on the "breadline" a person needs an income of 10,660 zlotys; and to live at a minimum social level, a family of four needs an income of 53,400 zlotys a month. 3. Helena Mikolajska is an actress and recipient of two state prizes for her artistic activity. She was formerly a very active member of the Workers' Defence Committee (KOR), which was victimised for the 1976 Radom strike and became the political nucleus of the Polish opposition./

Scan page 8

Letterse

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 345

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →