Injustice has been done
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-02-04Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
outrage 14 years ago may make most understandable = the local ings of the Brummie on the Outer good copy but in truth we all know press has reflected far more disquiet Circle bus. We don't know for sure, that they are no better placed to and unhappiness about the out- but we're not happy about it. judge the guilt or innocence of the come at the Appeal Court, than the Meanwhile, six men who most of us, six than the rest of us. What is of nationals. And as a denizen of the ateyond reasonable doubt look significance is that in Birmingham Second City myself, I can tell you - where demands for vengeance that on this issue the local rags are like spending the rest of their lives and feelings of bitterness would be an accurate barometer of the feel- in jail. Jim Denham looks the press coverage the case of the "Birmingham Six' JUSTICE HAS BEEN DONE! proclaimed the banner headline on the front page of Friday's Express. It referred, of course, to ine oucome or te ingham Six" appeal.
According to the Express, *victims of the Birmingham pub bombings were united in one chorus last night after the longest appeal case in British history. Justice has been done, they said."
Like most of the national press, the Express had tracked down various survivors of the bombings and families of those who were killed that night in November 1974. As might be expected they all supported the Appeal Court's decision.
Maureen Lord, who was given the last rites on the night of the bombings said: "nothing will ever convince me these men did not do it. The whole appeal case was just a terrible waste of money."1 Ivy Roberts, whose daughter was killed, said: "People seem to have forgotten the victims and their families. For us the grief is never ending. After something like that you lose all interest in life. By now I would have expected Maureen to be married and I would have had grandchildren. Now I can sleep easy in my bed tonight. Justice has been done."
I'm sure that the Express accurately reported the words and feelings of Maureen Lord and Ivy Roberts. And it may well be that their reactions do represent the majority view of those whose lives were shattered by the bombs. But it was not simply one united chorus."
The Birmingham Daily News' told a rather different story: *Relatives of the dead and other victims of the night of horror have spoken of their feelings, often mixed, as they heard the news that the appeal had been lost. For some, doubts still exist as to the guilt of the six men.
Steve Pool, who was injured in the Mulberry Bush explosion, told the Daily News, "if they're guilty, the right men, then it was the right decision. But I'm surprised they disallowed a retrial - the World in Action programme and the new evidence has certainly put doubts in my mind...I did wonder because of the amount of anti-Irish feeling, whether they just got the first people they could."
Marie McArdle, who suffered head and neck injuries and who saw several of her friends killed that night, also expressed doubts: "I would like to think justice has been nocent." Douglas Smith-Blain whose daughter, then 16, suffered terrible injuries, probably summed up the feelings of most Birmingham people when he told the Daily News, "We wouldn't know what to think about it - I just hope they got the right people, that's all!"
Drives
The Birmingham Post and its sister paper the Evening Mail also gave much prominence to those who doubt the guilt of the six (the Post's headline on Friday was "Outrage as pub bombers' appeal turned down") although both papers gave editorial support to the judges.
None of this, of course, proves anything one way or the other. The emotions of the victims of that
----- pull-quotes -----
done, but it is strange that a lot of people keep saying they are in-