More violence on W.Bank PALESTINE FISKAEL Z NAHONS 2 STATE
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-02-04Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 2
Protesters picketed the Israeli Embassy in London last Thursday, 28th, to condemn the repressien in WOMAN'S Clare Short has decided to have another go at introducing a Bill in Parliament to ban page 3 pictures. The debate has been had out before in Socialist Organiser around banning pornography/page 3.
I'm against it for two reasons. Firstly, however silly and demeaning page 3 pin-ups are, I don't think banning them would make any difference at all to the position of women. What's the point of dealing with symptoms rather than tackling the root cause?
More importantly, though, I'm against the state having the power to tell anyone what they can and can't look at.
I'm not sure that it isn't worth some sort of serious discussion taking place about pornography. One thing that everyone, be they radical feminist or socialist, seems to have in common is the idea that pornography is a 'bad thing' - the difference lies in the priority it is made in terms of political action or how you deal with it.
But there are enormous pro-l More people have died in renewed violence in the Israeliing of February 1, two Palestinian youths, aged 17 and 20, were killed, probably by ultra-right Jewish settlers. A 25-yearold Palestinian woman was rushed to hospital after being shot in the head.
The army continued to impose curfews on various West Bank towns, notably at the largest, Nablus, Calls to action, and advice on methods of fighting, are put out daily by the Voice of Jerusalem radio — believed to be run, albeit on a non-partisan basis, by a proSyrian PLO faction. A 'Unified Na-tional Leadership' is believed to have been formed, uniting Yasser Arafat's Fatah, the Democratic Front for the Liberation of Palestine, the Popular Front, the Palestinian Communist Party and the religious-fundamentalist Islamic Jihad.
So there does seem to be some link between the violent protests of the youth and actual political organisation, although how close the link it is hard to say.
Comparisons with South Africa have leapt to many people's minds, and it is not necessary to hold an analysis of Israel as a replica of apartheid to see the similarities. The • current revolt bears a gover resemblance to the nability' strategy employed in South African black townships at the peak of the unrest there. A comthe West Bank and Gaza. Photo: lan Swindale. mercial strike has remained in force since early December, probably involving a higher degree of mobilisation than South African boycott But does the current uprising suffer from the same weaknesses as the 'ungovernability strategy in South Africa? There it proved impossible to topple apartheid through boycotts alone; a more immediate focus for demands was necessary than simply the maximum 'down with apartheid'. Moreover, "ungovernability' was linked to the external diplomatic strategy of the African National Congress: it was seen as a radical form of pressure from below to push P.W. Botha to the negotiating table. For the PLO, too, the uprising provides above all diplomatic opportunity. And Twhilst there is nothing wrong in principle with diplomacy, there letermina Return is not in itself racist" is the height of absurdity. It is like saying that Britain's immigration laws (which I'm sure you oppose) are not racist because they are not explicitly so. However, anybody with some sense knows that this is certainly not the case because the implications of the laws are to discriminate against black people.
Similarly, with Israel one has to examine the political context of laws. In 1948, up to 700,000 Palestitandards VO GAZALA CLUB could be dangers if the uprising is subordinated to diplomatic efforts.
There are big differences between Palestine and South Africa. Israel out of the West Bank and Gaza' is a slogan with no South African equivalent. The call for Israel to get out of the occupied territories is more or less like any call for national independence.
But there are big obstacles to Israeli withdrawal. The official Israeli army (the so-called Defence Force) is immensely powerful. As recent events have shown, paramilitary far-right settler groups pose an extra problem. There are 70,000 such settlers in the West Bank in 118 settlements (plus 2,500 at 18 settlements in Gaza). And these are all fanatics.
Successive Israeli governments have fiven backing to the settlements projects as a form of tion for nians were driven from their homes and forced to flee to neighbouring countries. However, with the formation of Israel, only Jews were allowed to immigrate. Arabs within the Jewish state are treated as second-class citizens in many spheres of life.
The second point is your call for the self-determination of all the peoples in the region, includine the This is a ridiculous position because socialists support the self-determination of oppressed nationalities. The Jews are not in this position. (Read Lenin's writings on the national question).
I am afraid that SO seems to share the Zionist obsession about being engulfed by the surrounding Arab states. For example, the SSiN motion (a real hodge-podge of ideas) says in Paragraph 11 ("The Israeli Jews are a nation and therefore have national rights, i.e. the right not to be incorporated into an Arab state against their will").
Apart from being such a vague motion, it seems to imply that the Last week's Labour Party National Executive Committee agreed to investigate Militant 'infiltration' of Bermondsey North Party, and one of Leeds West. Only four NEC members voted against these measures.
The NEC decision is the latest stage in Neil Kinnock's 'get tough' policy. 50 Militant supporter or alleged apporter have now been expelled from the Labour Party.
Not copal=g Bermondey, 51 Party SRAEL OUFIF THE NEST BALI AND GAZA creeping annexation'. Even if this: or any future government decides to get out, the settlers will fight to stay - and they are well-armed and determined.
The general drift of Israeli public: opinion is to the right, particularly among the most dispossessed sections of Israeli Jewish societv.
The stronger the Palestinian movement is now, the better any results from an international conference will be. But international negotiations are no substitute for building Arab-Jewish unity at grassroots level. That is a difficult task — but probably an essential one if a Palestinian state is to be achieved.
The other lesson from South Africa is the necessity for a working class movement to lead the revolt. So far, the Palestinian trade arion movement has yet to put its own mark on the uprising.
lews!
Arabs will impose their state on the Jews.
Finally, another flaw in your argument is the proposal to have an independent Palestinian state on the West Bank and Gaza Strip. Apart from being economically nonviable, it evades the central issue. Who would control it politically? Just like South Africa dominates the region with its military might, so does Israel. The reactionary Arab states also would do everything in their power to prevent a progressive Palestinian movement coming to power as it would threaten their interests.
In the long term (and this is where SO is correct) only a socialist federation in the Middle East could bring an end to the region's intractable problems. However, in the short term full support must be given to the Palestinians and an appeal must be made to Jewish workers to support their Arab brothers and sisters. Surely this is not utopian.
TONY TRAUB Leigh-on-Sea members are under investigation due to be.
So Kinnock is tightening the screws, and the left is in a bad shape to resist it. But resistance is possible. The Kinnockites must not be allowed to trample on all opposition in the Party. Look at their pathetic showing over the health workers' action: a Kinnockite Labour Party that can't unambiguously support the health workers would be unlikely ever to support anybody.
We need a united campaign against the witch-hunt. The Labour Party must be an open, democratic forum for discusion and political action. No to expulsiera!
----- pull-quotes -----
My erotica your porn?
occupied West Bank and Gaza Strip. At Anabta, on the morn-
Labour Party, and voted for charges to be drawn up against eight members of Bradford