[recently with the release of some of the…]
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-01-28Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
recently with the release of some of the cabinet papers of the time. These revealed that facts about the fire had not been made public because Prime Minister MacMillan hadn't wished the Americans to think the British nuclear industry incompetent.
Coincidentally, an article* in New Scientist discussed the evidence that radiation might be many times more dangerous at causing cancer than assumed when the likely death toll from Windscale was calculated.
That radiation causes cancer is agreed. That more radiation causes more cancer is also agreed but how much more is less certain. Such uncertainties have led recently to a hundredfold discrepancy in predictions of the extra cancers expected from the Chernobyl fire - from 500 to 500,000!
With high doses (over 1 Gray or 100 Rads) there are so many more cancers that it is obvious they have been caused by the radiation. But with low doses, it difficult to pinpoint the effect radiation. After all, there are many other causes of cancer. To demonstrate the effect of just 1 Rad of extra radiation, it would be necessary to study 10,000 times more people than for 100 Rads.
The only example of mast expose US radiation we have is that the US bombs on Hiroshima and Nagasaki in 1945. Hundreds of thousands of people were irradiated and survived, an ideal population to study for long-term effects. Indeed, some say this was one reason for dropping the bombs when Japan may have been about to surrender anyway. John Huston made before he died. "The Dead' is like an exquisite miniature; what is striking is the fitness of the detail. The film is John Huston's dramatisation of "Dubliners'.
It's a small film, but not a negligible one. After the primary actioncentred plots of Hollywood films, it's a pleasant change to see a film primarily concerned with character and atmosphere.
This doesn't mean that there's no plot. The story is well constructed. It builds from small hints and allusions to the climax of Gretta's revelation in a logical and satisfactory way. What people say, the music we hear, the look in Gretta's eyes, all mean something for the development of the story; they aren't just there as filler. The story is, however, just the skeleton which Joyce fleshes out with the themes he wants to tackle.
And the film is concerned with large themes - love, loss, death, memory, and the haunting pull of the past.
The story begins at the home of the Misses Morkan, two elderly Dublin spinsters who are holding a dance followed by supper for family and friends. It is before World War I. Snow is falling outside as Gretta and Gabriel Conroy arrive for the evening. Gabriel is the Misses Morkan's favourite nephew, Anjelica Huston as Gretta to whom they defer.
The film only slowly comes to focus on Gretta and Gabriel. At first we meet a variety of characters, all of whom we'd be happy to + 71r1 follow. After a time, the camera rests increasingly on both Gabriel and Gretta, and it is they whom we follow out from the party to their hotel room.
Though the gathering is a cheertul-social one, there are minor strains. The aunts fret about Freddy who drinks too much. Another guest is of a different religion. One of the younger female guests, a nationalist, chides Gabriel for writing for an English newspaper and for looking to Europe before looking to his own country. Half in fun, half in disappointment, she calls him a 'West Briton' . In reply, Gabriel uses his speech to congratulate the older generation with their hospitable traditions as a way of pointing up the impatience of the up-and-coming generation.
Throughout the evening, Gabriel notices the increasing abstraction of his wife. In the carriage later, he will try to pull her back to him and their shared reality. What Gabriel learns is how little he really knows of Gretta.
Music and the power of music to conjure up the past are central to the film. The background music in the film is pleasant but unobstrusive. The foreground music - piano playing, dance music and singing — is central to the characters' lives. Over dinner, people discuss singers they have heard, and look longingly and sometimes tearfully back on moments that have moved them. It is overhearing the plaintive song *The lass of Aughrim' that brings the past so sharply back to Gretta.
Joyce's story is largely descriptive. Apart from the long talk between Gretta and Gabriel, what happens in the story occurs largely inside people's heads. But Huston's film manages to convey much of the feeling and atmosphere of the story. What we see on the screen evokes the time and the place in a strangely touching and moving way. tain in the 1950s being born, a 'working man's paradise'.
But the 1890s depression changed that. Workers who struck were locked out and starved by their employers. In the 1930s many workers learned that the 'working man's paradise' was a myth.
And the lesson is still relevant today. When the first convict ships sailed into Botany Bay they carried the seeds of capitalism in their holds. It took root in Australia and trampled the Aborigines and their claims to their land. It has ruined small farmers and it has tried to crush the workers. What has grown up is a paradise for spivs.
----- pull-quotes -----
Les Hearn's More risky than they say The Windscale fire of 1957 was brought into the news again
Belinda Weaver. reviews 'The Dead', the last film
the story "The Dead' from James Joyce's collection,
TURE your nancs e him to Malia