The spread of private medicine
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-01-28Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 7
Socialist Organiser no.343 28 January 1988 Page 7 FOLLOW THE --HE- HILL RULE:JUST. SAT 1980-1 to 1985-6. The minimum necessary increase to keep pace with an ageing population and new medical techniques which mean that patients live longer (expensively) rather than dying quickly (and cheaply) is 1.5 or 2% a year.
The Conservative Party and allied organisations are £1 million better off as a result of donations from NHS contractors.
According to a report prepared by the Joint NHS Privatisation Research Unit, 10 companies which have won NHS contracts since the privatisation drive in 1983, have been 'generous contributors.
One of the largest contributions came from the cleaning and catering firm, Spinneys, which contributed almost £370,000. The company has a reported 46 per cent of private NHS catering.
Last year, a leading surgeon estimated that 5,000 people a year were dying needlessly because of cuts, especially in ambulance and casualty services. Since the Tories took office in 1979, prescription charges have risen from 20p to £2.40. Now the Tories talk about charging patients for stays in hospital, and they will make us pay for eye and teeth check-ups.
161 NHS hospitals have closed since 1979, and 78 new private hospitals have opened. Over 90% of the population is totally reliant on the NHS.., The Tories claim that waiting lists have fallen. But they have fiddled the figures. Since 1979 day cases have been removed from the total, and there has been a drive to weed out names on the waiting list of people who have died, gone private in desperation or moved.
Support staff in the NHS are badly paid, too. Secretaries get between £4,900 and £6,500 a year, and in London hospitals over half the secretaries are agency staff. In the laboratories, graduates start at E5,300 and go up to less than £9,000. Pharmacists get £5,000 to É/,000 less in the Fichtin Photo Stefano Cagnoni NHS than in high street pharmacies. Qualified accountants get €5,000 to £10,000 less in the NHS than in the private sector.
in a recent survey, 38% of lowincome men, and 33% of lowincome women, said they were in poor health - as against 17% of high-income men and 13% of high-income women.
Up until 1965, the US had almost no governmentprovided health insurance. You got health care if you could pay, you didn't if you couldn't, and that was that.
Since then, the Medicare programme has improved things a bit. But this is how it was in 1965:
*The US spent far health care than any tion.
*The average expectation of life for US men was lower than in Bulgaria.
*Infant mortality for black children was 42 per 1000 -around the same as Thailand or Paraguay today.
That's what the means in health.
Davey-Smith The Tories' enthusiastic championing of private health care reflects their perception of the NHS as the last bastion of the welfarism they so despise. In 1986 the Conservative Research Department stated that "the government believes that a thriving private sector strengthens the NHS by relieving some of the pressure on it and by providing an alternative way of developing good practice and improved forms of treatment."
It is not surprising that the number of private hospitals increased from 150 in 1979 to 199 in 1985, with the number of private beds increasing from 6½ thousand to over en thousand. This increase disguises the fact that the big increase has been in private health ¡are provided by 'for-profit' organisations. In 1979 three-quarters of private beds in the UK vere in private hospitals run by harities or religious groups, but now over half of the private beds ure in hospitals run by groups such is American Medical International, Humana and BUPA These hospitals are concentrated n the affluent South of England. Most of the work they do is funded ›y private medical insurance, which low covers nearly 10% of the population — a doubling since 979. Much of the increase occured secause of company schemes, organised by employers, sometimes n collaboration with trade unions. Company schemes often end at etirement when health care secomes most needed and used. Like private hospitals, private nedical insurance is concentrated in he South, and private insurance is argely the domain of the rich -ınly 1% of semi-skilled and unskillid workers are covered.
Private medicine is a parasite on he NHS. Equipment and supplies re often "borrowed" from te HS. Patients who have been seen it private clinics often mysteriously et admitted under NHS care ahead if people on waiting lists. Furthernore, even when the NHS attempts o collect fees from the private secor the bills are left unpaid: just one District Health Authority, WONDER HoW MUCH THEY PAY THE RCN FOR NOT STRIKING? £20 IN Bloomsbury, had uncollected debts of over £1 million in 1986. Most importantly, the private sector is run trained in the NHS. The private sector caters mainly for profitable, non-urgent work - with one in four hip replacements being done privately, and a considerable proportion of non-urgent hysterectomies and varicose vein operations. This gives an incentive for consultants to keep waiting lists long - more people will then come privately - and there are cases when this has definitely happened.
Naturally, insurance schemes exclude expensive conditions: renal failure (requiring dialysis or transplant) is an example and it is likely that AIDS will be too. There is clearly little money to be made here, and the insured people with these conditions - and others, such as psychiatric illness, pregnancy or any chronic disease requiring more than 180 days care in a year are shipped off to the NHS.
The government has suggested that the spare capacity in the private sector should be used to reduce waiting lists for non-urgent operations. However, when Bath Health Authority did just this the cost was greater than treatment under the NHS.
Clearly, contrary to the Conservative Research Department views, private medicine weakens rather than strengthens the NHS. It offers additional care to those who need it least — the wealthy, who experience less ill-health than the poor, and are in a better position to get optimum NHS treatment if they want it. The government will continue to encourage the spread of private medicine.
The 1986 Green Paper on primary care has suggested ways in which general practice could be partally privatised. More ominously, recently 'respectable' groups such as the Institute of Health Service Management and even the usually progressive Kings Fund for Hospital Research have produced reports on the commercial funding of the health service - previously the domain of loony right wing groups like the Adam Smith Institute and the Institute for Policy Studies.
John Moore has recently suggested extending the tax relief on private health insurance. One effect of the worsening conditions within the NHS may be to scare more people into taking out private health insurance. However, as shown above the private sector is dependent upon the NHS: ultimately private medical insurance just gives an illusion of independence from the health service. Private health care takes away from the NHS whilst giving nothing. It adds further to the inequalities between the rich and poor, and the only people who really benefit from it are those who get a. share of the profits.
One way in which the TUC could show its commitment to the NHS would be by opposing any deals between unions and medical insurance agencies. Labour should be committed to abolishing private medicare altogether, not merely to withdrawing active support from it.
Scan page 8
150 years ago there were no nurses as we know them today.
There were no properly organised hospitals.
Nursing as a job was carried out in workhouses by the inmates. The rich were always nursed at home, and the few hospitals around were largely the resort of poor people.
As doctors began to rationalise treatments, hospitals expanded. Florence Nightingale started nurse training schools. Nursing came to be seen as a suitable occupation for young ladies from wealthy backgrounds. In 1916 the newly tormed Koyal College of Nursing (KCN) finally won a register of trained nurses.
The RCN's articles of association specifically prevented the college from imposing on its members or supporting with its funds 'any regulation which, if an object of the College, would make it a Trade Union' The real object of the RCN at this time was to become the controlling body of nursing. It was never meant to be a body that would campaign for higher pay and better conditions at work.
But instead the General Nursing Council (GNC) was set up (and this body still exists today to keep the register of trained nurses.
The RCN went on to develop as an independant professional organisation. More middle class nurses were being recruited. Unlike the ladies of the previous generation of nurses they wanted proper pay.
In 1919 the RCN published "The Nurses' Charter" , calling for a 48 hour week and better pay.
In 1926 however, the Labour Party declared that the only way that nuses could advance their pay and conditions was to be orgainised into Trades Unions. So started the battle for nurses to be organised.
Some joined the RCN, and others Trade Unions. Even today about a third don't join anything at all.
The RCN maintained its elitist, protectionist, non-militant stand. In 1939, the Athlone Committee met to discuss nursing conditions and the RCN recommended AGAINST high salaries to student nurses on the grounds that this. would attract unsuitable applicants.
Although that was 40 years ago, and things have moved on among the hierarchy of the RCN this attitude still lingers on.
They still refuse to recognise the necessity for industrial action, despite the groundswell of opinion that way amongst rank and file RCN members.
John Smith Photo: (Protile), Management, Nursing officers and the like, are usually the shop stewards of the RCN.
The RCN stewards (although some are very good) are usually hand in glove with senior management - being 'professionals" themselves, they often provide very ineffectual stewarding and representation.
The 'No Strike' clause is seen as almost a type of religious commitment - frequently it is called a no strike vow in RCN circulars.
There are many reasons for the reluctance of RCN members to strike. Popular myth is that it would harm patients. However, all nurses must recognise the fact that low wages and poor conditions of work harm patients more, and the RCN is guilty, not only of depressing wages, but of allowing nurses to be exploited in hospitals with appalling conditions.
In particular the RCN has never conducted a real campaign against the enforcement of night duty rotas on student nurses. Although training only stipulates 3 months of night duty to be necessary for registration, all British hospitals force student nurses to work 9 months, using them as cheap labour.
The role of the RCN in the present disputes has been appalling. The Daily Mirror has stated the nurses' case more boldly than the RCN. Indeed RCN officials often seem to be doing the Tories job for them, arguing that striking will only serve to harm patients.
Many nurses are voting with their feet and leaving the RCN to join COHSE and NUPE. Nurses know they cannot carry on being selfless "Angels' on starvation pay and working in ever more stressful conditions. Whatever the RCN leadership would like us to believe, nurses want to fight back nurses and members of COHSE at Maudsley Hospital in South London, spoke to Cathy Nugent about their plan to strike on 2 February.
IAN: Here the issue is very much staffing levels. There has been a deterioration over the past 18 months in the numbers of nurses on the wards because of an increasing inability to recruit. Since the autumn people have been doing masses of overtime, wards haven't been properly covered, students haven't been supervised.
Christmas was diabolical. The whole hospital was terribly unsafe. People were very angry, wanting to know what the union was going to do.
And then the Manchester strike happened. After that we called an emergency executive meeting. We decided to have a 24 hour strike on 2 February, with emergency cover. At that point we weren't sure of anybody else doing it.
By the time we knew that other hospitals would strike on 3 February, we had already agreed on 2 February here. What I think is important now is to organise something London wide or nationwide, but things have happened so fast that I don't think it was feasible anyway.
I've been to one London coordinating meeting. At that meeting it was agreed that one of the issues we ought to be pushing on was London weighting. We get the lowest London weighting of virtually any group going, half of what local authority workers get and less than a third of what the police get. There are masses of nurses leaving the capital simply because they can't afford to live here.
MANDY: London Health Emergancy and "Radical Nurse' held a big joint meeting where they formed a sub-committee which a few of us go along to. They were talking of having a national march and rally on 19 April for all health workers CLAIRE: We are going to write to COHSE and some nurses in NUPE were going to write to NUPE, hoping to get the General Secretaries of both unions down to the rally on the 3rd and to start trying to coUntil other industries back us, l don't think health workers going on strike for a day will make Thatcher change her mind. But hopefully this. is a percursor for further action. We need a national strike with support trom other workers and hopefully this sort of action will start people thinking along those lines. MICHAEL: The major issue is the future shape of the NHS, how it. should be funded, and the fact that nurses and health service workers have been exploited in order to maintain what has been a very economic service. Nurses are forcing the issue of funding, forcing the government to fund the NHS adaquately, and they are forcing them by taking strike action.
The RCN say that striking will damage the NHS. But nurses in other unions, NUPE, COHSE are saying that this isn't true. Nurses should become more radical and take control - not only through strike action but if necessary when there are hospital closures, through occupation and other forms of action.
IAN: At this hospital we have got fairly strong links with other groups apart from COHSE, especially the junior doctors. We had lots of active co-operation with them during the cuts campaign of 1986. We work with other unions through the staff side of the Consultative Committee, but you're talking about handfuls of people.
In 1986 the doctors claimed an awful lot of credit. Because they were good at gaining access to the press they put themselves down as being a major cause of the fight against the cuts. In fact the bulk of the work was done mainly by nurses. and porters. This time round it's going to be hard for the doctors to assume their traditional dominant position, or maintain the illusion of It.
I heard on the radio that NALGO are considering taking action on the 3rd. Whether NALGO here will consider taking action with us, I don't know. I'll have to see them next week.
What we're asking doctors to do is to work as nurses for the day and to maintain the emergency cover. It will be a learning experience for them, anyway! And it will free more nurses to be out on the picket lines.
Doctors have started joining COHSE. We've got about half a dozen, who we hope will be out with us.
CLAIRE: We'ld like people to come on the day from different unions and workplaces and bring
----- pull-quotes -----
NO CUTS Fighting for the MMS or the NAS.
UC Fightin Fighting for the N.HS. -T1 =
TEBBIT / PAID NURSE
MOONLIGHT SCANDAL
lan Morton, Claire Newby, Mandy Sharp and Michael Ridge,