Privatisation: who benefits?
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-01-28Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 6
There have been three privatisation in health.
NHS ancillary services have been contracted out to the private sector. Private health insurance and private health care have been promoted. And charges for NHS services to patients have been increased.
These three strands have been connected. The deterioration in NHS facilities brought about by contracting out ancillary services encourages those who can attord it to go private, and the public health sector is left as a 'sink service' for the poor.
In Thatcher's first term of office, health authorities were encouraged to solicit tenders from private companies for ancillary — i.e. catering, cleaning and laundry services in the health service. The response was not enthusiastic — so at the beginning of the second term, in August 1983, a circular was sent by the government to each District Health Authority instructing them to return a timetable for tendering of these services by April 1984., The government was urged to initiate this form of privatisation by the right-wing pressure group Aims for Industry and the Adam Smith Institute. However, they didn't need much persuading.
At least 30 Tory MPs either had shares in or were directors or consultants for the firms involved. Crothalls, for example, the company with the most ex-NHS contracts, pay two Tory MPs as consultants — Michael Forsyth and Sir Anthony Grant — and are part of
Davey-Smith
the Pritchard Services Group who gave £10,000 to the Conservative Party in 1982-83.
The effects on the pay and conditions of hospital ancillary workers, and on services provided for patients, have been devastating. The government abolished the 1946 Fair Wages Resolution, so private contractors did not have to offer their employees the Whitley Council rates of pay and conditions guaranteed under the NHS.
-Wages Eyen prior to privatisation wages for ancillary workers were very low. A survey in London published in 1980 revealed that nearly four out of five ancillary workers were born overseas.
The degree of unionisation is often low. Full-time workers on NHS pay grades 1-3 earned £72-75 per week in 1985-6, and four-fifths of female ancillary workers earn less then the supplementary benefit level — the 'official' poverty level.
Even before contracting out the situation was bad. However, to make contracts attractive to private firms, health authorities were told not to include minimum wages and conditions clauses in the contracts. Private contractors could only undercut the current costs to the health service by forcing down wages or by increasing the labour carried out by each worker.
As one commentator in the Health Service Manpower Review noted: "The margin of cost reduction is the contractor's ability to increase the intensity of labour and cut real wages"
In the civil service, where three-quarters of cleaners' jobs have been contracted out, the result has been 10p-35p per hour wage cuts on the already low 1986 rate of £1.89 per hour. Pay is also effectively cut by loss of bonus payments and overtime, and by an increase in the workload.
Private firms prefer to employ part-time workers since they are not entitled to sick pay or holiday pay, pensions or maternity allowances. Up to three-quarters of contract cleaners are currently women employed part-time.
The firms were helped in their quest to cut pay and conditions by the 1979, 1980 and 1985 Employment Acts, which have progressively reduced rights against unfair dısmissal, so that now full-time workers have to be employed for two years betore they gain such rights.
Turnover Many part-time workers fail to qualify for any rights at all. A rapid turn-over of workers ensures that few will ever get employment protection - for example in Croydon 87 people passed through the 25 jobs in a Crothall's cleaning contract in the first five months it was tunning® Contractors claim they can do the job of the NHS units with less staff. recognition was won only after trike; at many places there is nov simply no union recognition.
In the most notorious case, at Barking Hospital, Crothall's refused to negotiate with the unions, then cut total working hours by 40%, cut holidays by 1-1½ weeks per year and abolished sick pay entitlement totally.
It is not surprising that the level of services to the patients has declined dramatically. There are reports from all over the country of dirty and unhygienic hospitals -dangerous to patients and staff alike - of dreadful catering and unclean linen. In some places operations have been cancelled because of filthy operating theatres.
In addition to these obvious effects, the social contract between ancillary staff and patients is removed. At some hospitals, ancillary staff work with medical staff in rehabilitation and therapy programmes for patients which involve domestic tasks.
For many patients, simply being able to talk to someone is important, but as one former ancillary worker wrote to the Guardian "we were explicitly instructed by the tients in the firms time soe patients in the firm's time. So cheering up sick and depressed people even for a couple of minutes was disapprovingly categorised as wasting time"
Ironically the official objective of contracting out - the saving of money for the NHS - has hardly occurred. The House of Commons Social Services Committee reported that in 1985 savings of €9.4 million had been made, and since there was a VAT refund of £27 million to the private firms "the savings were hardly a startling success' . Since then savings have apparently been greater, calculated by the NS' bills. I the other costs are added - redundancy pay, unemployment benefit, rate rebates, and the hidden costs of increased unemployment, it is unlikely that any savings have ever been made.
A survey of approximately half of the country's District Health Authorities in 1985 found that nearly 3,000 workers had been made redundant. "The estimated saving for each employee made redundant was £3,400; the net cost to the public through loss of tax and social security benefits was €7,000", it reported.
This bears out the fact that the prime motivation for privatisation is ideological - an overbearing faith in the market, and a desire to break the unions. Indeed the government ordered Cornwall Health Authority to offer a contract to a private firm even though the in-house service would have been £47,000 cheaper.
So the NHS has not done well out of contracting-out, but some firms - and, of course, the Tory MPs who are directors or whom they pay as consultants and the Conservative Party to which they give money -have done. For health service workers and their patients the results have been a disaster and are one of the reasons why a massive struggle to defend the NHS for its employees and users is now developing. HSE REGY EGION