Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The left and Zionism

Socialist Organiser no. 343, 28 January 1988 · scan pp. 3–4 · about 2,213 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

What should the socialist attitude be towards Zionism? For much of the left the answer to that question is simple: relentless hostility.

'Anti-Zionism' is a central principle for many socialists, equal (and equivalent) to 'anti-racism' Zionists have been banned in some college student unions. In one college, students had to pledge commitment to 'anti-Zionism' to be entitled to union membership. That Zionism is a form of racism is the official policy of the United Nations.

Many people see Israel as not only racist, but also a major bulwark — for some, the bulwark - of imperialism in the Third World. Zionism is an extension of, or the sharp end of, imperialism. Israel is like South Africa or even Nazi Germany. 'Zionism = Nazism' read one placard last Saturday.

Racist

Anyone, like Socialist Organiser, who disputes this interpretation of things is denounced as a Zionist, and therefore a racist...And so it goes on.

Recent issues of both Socialist Worker and Socialist Action have carried articles on the history of Zionism in much this vein. For Socialist Action reporters Rashid Ashraf and Pam Coles, "Zionism represented a historic accommodation to anti-semitism...Its offspring, the Zionist state, today concretises the reactionary origins of Zionism in its racist laws (etc).-. Mike Simons in Socialist Worker writes: "Rather than fight antisemitism, the Zionists accepted it as inevitable"

Thedor Herzl, the founder of modern political Zionism, is quoted (by SW): "In Paris I achieved a freer attitude towards anti-semitism which I began to understand and parera" and caned anti-semites from Count Von Plehve, organiser of the pogroms in Russia to the Ottoman Sultan offering to rid their lands of the Jews in return for support for the Zionist project."

It is easy to read history backwards, and even easier to get carried away by your own propaganda. Marxısm is an attempt to analyse the world without the distorting lens of propaganda; to understand things in all their complexity and in their totality. Such an approach leads to conclusions different from the one-sidedness of SW and SA.

The story, as told by SW and SA, can be summarised thus. There was anti-semitism in Europe. Some Jews capitulated to it and resolved to build a Jewish state in Palestine. These evil men shared the attitudes of the imperialist anti-semites and conspired with them. Likewise they were racist against the Arabs. Israel today is the fruit of their work.

There are some facts which seem to back up this storv. Most of the ocialist Organis 0 Box 823, London SE 1 4NA Published by Socialist Organiser PO Box 823, Printed by East West Graphics (TU). Registered as a newspaper at the Post Office. Signed articles do no necessarily reflect the view of Socialist Organiser. leaders of the Zionist movement were cynical wheeler-dealer bourgeois politicians, no better than any others of their sort. Especially in the early years of their movement, they shared the racism common in Europe towards Third World peoples. The Arabs in Palestine scarcely merited any consideration; if they were considered, most Zionists assumed that the Arabs could only gain from Jewish colonisation.

And Israel today is brutal towards the Palestinian Arabs.

There is one thing drastically wrong with the SA/SW story. It presents the whole history of the working-out of a bad idea, as a conspiracy by evil people.

But Marxists understand history differently. We ask: why did the "bad' idea of Zionism gain mass support among Jews? What material factors brought this about? Why did 'evil' people like Herzl succeed in their "conspiracies'? Who are the Israeli Jews today? They are not just extrapolations of the 'bad' ideas of their forefathers.

And we look at the whole reality of Zionism. Some Zionist leaders were evil people. One (minority) strand of Zionism was even fascistinspired. But similar elements of chauvinism and racism can be found in all nationalist movements. If Zionism stood out among nationalist movements, it was in fact for the larger-than-usual minority within it that opposed the chauvinist and racist excesses.

SA and SW just take particular incidents and elements from Zionist history to fit their own story.

A good example is Herzl's visit to the Tsarist Minister of the Interior, Von Plehve. It did happen, and it was the first of many disreputable Zionist negotiations with antisemites. But the readers of SA and SW would never know that Herzl's talks provoked outrage amongst Russian Zionists and that the Zionist movement nearly split over it!

Again, SW and SA tell us about the plight of the Arab peasants driven off their land and made destitute as, up to 1948, the Zionists bought up 6% of Palestine's land. They do not mention the plight of the peasants made destitute by the profit-grabbing efforts of Arab landlords on the other 94%. They tell us about the atrocity at Deir Yassin, where Zionists murdered some 250 peaceful Arab villagers, but not about the pogroms just a couple of years before in Poland where many Jews had been killed.

Plight

They tell us about the terrible sufferings of the Palestinian Arab refugees, but not about the plight of the European Jewish survivors of the Holocaust. Those survivors faced pogroms in countries like Poland, but the British and US government told them to stay in those, their home' countries. Noone in the world would welcome them except the Zionist community in Palestine.

SA and SW tell us about how over half a million Arabs were driven out of what became Israel during the 1948 war. They do not tell us about the almost equal number of Jews driven out of the Arab countries by anti-semitic persecution in the following years. They do not tell us that the 1948 war was started by the Arab League — with British-officered armies and intentions that had little to do with helping the Palestinian peasants.

They tell us about the alleged collaboration of Zionists with the Nazis during World War 2, but not about the actual collaboration of Palestinian Arab leaders with the Nazis.

Evil Zionists arrive in Haifa None of the facts omitted by SA and SW justify the crimes of the Israeli state. But those facts do tell us that the history of Zionism is one of oppressed people trying to hold their own corner in the dog-eat-dog world of capitalism and imperialism, not one of a demon let loose on an otherwise tranquil universe.

The socialist movement has historically opposed Zionism -and similar nationalisms. Marxists argued against the Zionist project of an independent Jewish state as the solution to anti-semitism; they argued for working-class unity and the fight for socialism instead. Against the notion that antisemitism - or any other prejudice - is unchangeable or natural, Marxists have argued that it is possible to build workers' unity to fight all oppression and discrimination.

Socialists also pointed out that Zionism was forced by the logic of its own enterprise into an alliance with the British colonial authorities who ran Palestine, and into conflict with the indigenous Arabs.

Many Zionists did argue that Gentile anti-semitism was more or less impossible to change - in the same way that radical feminists consider male sexism to be permanent.

Socialists rejected this view. But in the propaganda of SW and SA, this traditional critique of Zionist nationalism is given an extra twist. The 'acceptance' of anti-semitism is treated as an explanation for Israel's treatment of the Palestinians, and for its alliance with imperialism. This is a 'conspiracy' or 'evil men' view of history — like the school textbook versions which describe the past as an affair of 'good kings' and 'bad kings'.

SA comments on the 1930s: *Zionism, by counterposing the fight against Nazism to the colonisation of Palestine, sabotaged the united front that was needed to defeat Nazism" . But where, exactly, was this united front? What sense does it make to blame the bourgeois Zionist leaders for not forming a workers' united front against Hitler? It was Stalinism on the one hand and Social Democracy on the other, that sabotaged that united front. Wasn't it? Or will SA give us their critique of Trotsky's writings on the rise of fascism? No doubt they think that rather than denounce the Stalinist Communist Party, Trotsky should have denounced the Zionists instead.

Zionism's responsibility for the rise of Nazism was utterly marginal; and Zionism's growth can only be understood in terms of the failure of the labour movement. In the late 1920s Zionism looked like a fiasco, a hopeless fantasy. As the '30s marched on, the claims of Zionism appeared more and more to be vindicated; by 1945 they seemed, in the wake of the Holocaust, to be entirely vindicated from the point of view of many of Nazism's victims.

Deutscher

Isaac Deutscher was later to comment that if he had spent less time opposing Zionism and more time trying to get Jews out of Europe, more lives would have been saved. It isn't necessary to accept his argument to see the force of it, or to see why so many others have shared it.

Yet the likes of SW and SA are not prepared to understand Zionism. Still less are they prepared to recognise the diversity of the Zionist movement. Herzl, a bourgeois Zionist, was convinced of the necessity of negotiations with whichever 'great power' might aid the Zionist cause. Ber Borochov, who called himself a Marxist Zionist' , supported the Russian revolution (and indeed died in Russia in 1918). Some Zionists in Palestine were utterly opposed to any deals with the British authorities there.

Zionists 'collaborated' with Nazis? Many Zionists not only did not 'collaborate' - they lost their lives fighting Nazism. The Zionists who helped lead the uprising in the Warsaw ghetto in 1943 are calmly ignored by modern 'anti-Zionists' SA evokes the memory of the Trotskyist, Abram Leon, who died in Auschwitz, whose book "The Jewish Question" they describe (not very accurately) as "the first systematic Marxist critique of Zionism." Yet Leon's basic argument was that it was impossible to create an independent Jewish state under capitalism - hardly the same argument as today's 'anti-Zionists' The point to providing a historically balanced picture is not retrospectively to endorse the Zionist project, and still less to justify the actions of the Israeli state today. Zionism was a nationalist response to the murderous (and eventually genocidal) growth of European anti-semitism in the later nineteenth and early twentieth centuries.

Impulses

It was no more a "correct" response than any other such nationalism (the "back to Africa' movement among American blacks, for example. Zionism did not save the Jews; the establishment of Israel has not abolished anti-semitism or rendered it harmless. But it was not an evil conspiracy. It was a movement given mass support and momentum by terrible oppression and by the failures of the labour movement. Socialists must be sympathetic if not to Zionism, at least to the impulses which drove the mass of the world's oppressed Jews towards Zionism!

SA write: "There is an unbroken continuity from the earliest Zionist writings, through Zionism's criminal response to the threat of Nazism, to its present day policies towards the Palestine people". But this is demonology, rather than serious analysis.

Israel did not come about just because a handful of wicked Zionists managed to get their way — either by convincing some imperialist power or other that Israel could be an "outpost of civilisation against barbarism" or by any other devious trickery. Above all, Zionism achieved its objective because of what happened to the Jews in Europe, and because of the utter failure of the labour movement to prevent it.

The traditional Marxist critique was not wrong. The nationalist answer to the Jewish problem did lead to conflict with Arabs; as an answer it was foredoomed by the 'colonial' character the Zionist enterprise had to take. Deutscher likened what happened in Palestine to someone jumping out of a burning house who lands on a person walking past and injures them. They might pick each other up and live peacefully afterwards, or they might fight each other. In fact, the one who is to blame for it all is the person who set the house on fire.

The Israel/Palestine conflict is a bit like that. The Zionist settlers, fleeing from the fires of European anti-semitism, from the beginning behaved like settlers — mistreating their Arab neighbours. Israel was eventually founded via a war of conquest and the driving out of 500,000 or more Arabs; later more wars of conquest followed. But without even attempting to understand the rise of Zionism as more than an evil pro-imperialist plot, the realities of the conflict today can only be blurred.

What Israel has done to the Palestinians is to be condemned by socialists (though SA and SW might at least mention the brutalities committed by Arab regimes). The Palestinians must be supported. But we must also understand. It is not a question, as SA idiotically alleges, of Socialist Organiser "striving) to find a progressive content within Zionism". It is a question of rejecting one-sided and unscrupulous propaganda (which is also a propaganda of hypocrisy and double standards) and trying instead to develop serious socialist politics.

Page

Scan page 4

RAI

----- pull-quotes -----

atest date for porn int itor John Pimphony

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 343

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →