Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Marxism and women's oppression

Socialist Organiser nos. 341–342: No Turning Back!, 21 January 1988 · scan pp. 14–17 · about 3,556 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 14

Lynn Ferguson traces the development of the idea women's liberation from the pioneers, through the early socialists, Marx and Engels, the German worki class women's movement led by Clara Zetkin, the Rnlshevik Revolution. and the betrayals of Stalinism On the face of it, there is no necessary relation between women's liberation and socialism. Many socialists are sexist, and many feminists are anti-socialist. Logically, why should not common ownership of the means of production be combined with sexual discrimination, or private ownership with equality? The issue cannot be handled by abstract logic, but only by starting off from facts and history.

Women have been oppressed for thousands of years. Possibly they resisted the beginnings of this oppression with violence. For sure individual women have always kicked back and stood up for themselves. But the programme of women's liberation dates from capitalist society.

Mary Astell put it like this in 1706, finking women's liberation to the democratic manifesto of the bourgeois revolution. "Is it not partial in men in the last degree to contend for and practise that arbitrary dominion in their families which they abhor and exclaim against in the state?...If all men are born free, how is it that all women are born slaves?"

Capitalism continued the oppression of women but changed it. In the old patriarchal household, women were domestic slaves. But the division of labour and the relations of power were all worked out within the household, which existed for the outside world only through the head of the household, the man. Capitalism brought women into the labour force as independent individuals. However underpaid and overworked the woman factory or office worker, in the workplace she is not part of any man's household, but an independent person. In line with this, capitalist laws have een at least a measure or a promise of •ormal equality to women.

The underpinning of women's oppression in most societies has been the family property or plot of land, handed down from father to son. The woman is an indispensable partner in the family -for children are economically necessary - but a secondary one.

Jewish, Hindu, Islamic, and Christian ideologies all defined women as subordinate. Traditional Chinese usage bound women's feet. Ancient Greece was particularly ruthless in imprisoning women in the home. Roman law recognised women only as dependents of fathers or husbands. Ancient codes of law punished female adultery severely while not touching male adultery.

Probably feudal Western Europe was, of all major pre-capitalist civilisations, the least harsh in its oppression of and concludes that women' revolution must go hand in women. The sexual division of labour was not rigid. Women workers were frequently paid the same as men for the same work. Women, though their economic activity was much more centred on the home than men's, played a large role in social life. They dominated important trades, as for example the ale wives dominated brewing in medieval England. A widow could engage in trade as more or less the equal of men. Women at the head of convents were important people.

Still women were clearly subordinate. They could not hold any public offices. Even guilds of tradeswomen were headed by men. Generally they could not appear as independent persons in court. Rape, for example, was defined by law not as an attack on a woman's body, but as a crime against a man's property; and lords could rape peasant women with impunity.

Women inherited property only exceptionally, and in such cases the property was likey to be seen as dowry for a future husband rather than as a basis for the woman's independence. The household headed by the father was the norm on which society was based; and for each individual woman the best available course was to find a 'good' husband.

Oppression does not always, by any means, produce rebellion; and the oppression of women in feudal times produced no women's rebellion. There was no arena where women could gather collectively, as independent persons. Oppression produced not rebellion, but a search for consolations, as in the medieval Catholic cult of the Mother of God.

Industrial capitalism did not abolish women's old household drudgery, far from it. But the nature of housework was changed. It became a sphere sharply separated off from social labour, rather than closely intermingled with it. In the old order, the household was the basic economic unit. Most production was done in or around the home. Under the new industrial capitalist order, the centre of production was the factory, outside the home, bringing together people from thousands of different liberation and workers' land.

households.

But the new factory system was not self-contained. The job of transforming the exhausted, dirty and hungry worker at the end of one day's work into a fresh, clean and fit person, ready for labour the following morning, was left outside it. So was the upbringing of children.

Seizing upon the subordination of women which it inherited from older societies, capitalism imposed this 'housework' on women. The natural role of women in childbirth solidified the allocation.

The state has taken on a few parts of the work (schools, nurseries). Some labour-saving devices have been introduced for the home. Yet average hours of housework are still reckoned today at about 70 a week - though in fact housework merges into (and blights) life, while wage-labour is sharply separated from it. Despite the fact that more and more housewives are also wage-workers, there is no sure evidence that hours of housework are decreasing. Unlike wage-labour, housework structurally cut off from the laboursaving benefits of cooperation and (above a certain point) of mechanisation.

This burden of housework has become the basis for the whole elaborate structure of women's disadvantage in capitalist society, including the relegation of women to lower-paid wage-jobs modelled on their domestic roles, the organisation of labour without regard for women's special needs and problems (periods, maternity, etc.

It is structurally impossible to remove the burden within capitalism. State provision will always be limited because it is not profitable and because capitalism is inherently an individualistic system (families would not want to socialise all their housework under capitalism even if the capitalist state provided facilities). Enlightenment, feminist protests, and conscience can drive men to take over more of housework; but all evidence suggests that such a process of purely moral reform is and must be very limited in its effects.

Scan page 15

Thus capitalism keeps omen oppressed. In some respects even worsens their situation.

But the replacement of the old order of god-given hierarchies and social stagnation by a new society which is fluid, which preaches the abstract equality of all people, and which changes itself constantly with the aid of science, contained a huge potential for women to demand and get better conditions. The relegation of the household to a secondary place in the economy likewise opened the way for women to become workers as independent persons.

Capitalism makes the promise of equality, and incites the demand for equality; but beyond a certain poin i its roots in the family household mak e it incapable of satisfying those dema inds and those promises. That is why the movement for women's liberation is a child of capitalism, but potentially a tremendous force for anti-capitalist revolution.

Socialism can socialise housework and thus release the drive to equality generated by capitalism. But if it can, why should it do so? Why showd the working class be expected to be responsive to feminist demands?

For sure the capitalist class will not be. Not even the women of the capitalist class will be. Beyond some formal legal reforms, which have their limits, women's equality is expensive to capitalism. It also threatens capitalism politically, by mobilising 50% of the working class out of passivity. The women of the capitalist class are integrated into and depend on their households. They will not sacrifice their income, and ultimately the whole system of privilege they rest on, to sex solidarity Besides they have the material means to evade the burden of housework, the hard core of the oppression which bears down on the working class woman.

Working class men gain materially from sexism. But their position is different. Whatever the annoyances of women refusing the role of submissive housewife, the overall programme of socialism and women's liberation offers a levelling-up to both working class men and women, whereas for women of the capitalist class it means catastrophe.

Short-term interests divide the working class in many ways - skilled versus unskilled, employed versus unemployed, permanent workers versus temporaries, natives versus immigrants, and so on, as well as men versus women. Yet it is possible in struggle to overcome those divisions and unite round common long-term programme. The experience of working together in the factory or office and in the strike can make working class men come to support the measures needed to give women full equality.

It is not automatic; of course not. But over 50% of the working class are women. They can be expected to respond to demands for wom en's liberation; and then they will put a very powerful pressure on working class men to support those demands.

Classical Marxism and women The early 19th century socialists - the most radical and thorough of the advocates idea of human emancipation or liberation which launched by the American and French Revolutions - were also advocates of women's emancipation. Charles Fourier declared: "The degree of emancipation of women is the natural measure of general emancipation."

Fourier, writing in 1808, also went beyond legal formalities in his programme for equality. "People would be housed in large buildings which would be equipped with various services including creches. Young children would be cared for communally. There would be communal restaurants and public rooms..." (Sheila Rowbotham, 'Hidden from History'). Robert Owen had similar ideas.

There were exceptions in the socialist movement. Until relatively late in the 19th century there was a strong current of 'proletarian anti-feminism' represented by such leaders as Proudhon and Lassalle. They reflected the element in the working class that looked backward — to the old patriarchal household economy - rather than forward. (In early 19th century England, radical workers often defined their aim as a return to the happy state before the 'Norman yoke' was imposed in 1066). Claiming they wished to protect women, they opposed women's employment in industry. Proudhon, in Marx's words, sang "the glories of the petty bourgeoisie and of the miserable

Scan page 16

patriarchal and amorous of domestic hearth.

Marx and Engels added little or nothing to the programme of their more radical predecessors. They integrated that programme into a perspective of class struggle rather than utopiabuilding; they opposed Proudhon's ideas as *both reactionary and Utopian" because they tried to run backwards away from that class struggle.

In 'Origin of the Family' (1884)

Engels endeavoured to use the researches of the US anthropologist Lewis Morgan to map the evolution of women's position. The attempt has been criticised in the light of later research, but for sure the approach was a lasting scientific advance. The position of women was discussed in terms of the changing material conditions that determined it, not just in terms of abstract moral rights and wrongs.

Engels also summarised the socialist programme: : 'The modern individual family is based on the open or disguised domestic enslavement of the woman;

and modern society is a mass composed solely of individual families as its molecules...In the family, (the man) is the bourgeois; the wife represents the proletariat...

"The peculiar character of man's domination over woman in the modern family, and the necessity, as well as the manner, of establishing real social equality between the two will be brought out into full relief only when both are completely equal before the law. It will then become evident that the first premise for the emancipation of women is the reintroduction of the entire female sex into public industry; and that this again demands that the quality possessed by the individual family of being the economic unit of society be abolished...

"With the passage of the means of production into common property, the individual family ceases to be the economic unit of society. Private housekeeping is transformed into a social industry. The care and education of the children becomes a public matter. Society takes care of all children equally, irrespective of whether they are born in wedlock or not" — and, Engels adds, this will underpin a great expansion of sexual freedom.

The German Social Women's Movement In 1879 August Bebel, leader of the German Social Democratic party, the SPD, published a book "Women and Socialism". This explored the historical origins of women's subordination, and presented a picture of what socialism would mean to women, both materially, and in terms of relations befween the sexes.

The impact of the book was enormous. By 1895 it had gone through 25 editions in Germany alone, as well as having been translated into several languages. Ottilie Baader, a working class woman activist, later remembered:

"Although I was not a social-democrat, I had friends who belonged to the party. Through them I got the precious work. I read it right through. It was my own fate, and that of thousands of my sisters. Neither in the family nor in public life had I even heard of all the pain the woman must endure. Her life was ignored. Bebel's book courageously Clara Zetkin The abandonment of serious attempts by the women for socialism was the sharp end of its abandonment of any perspective of organising the working class as a whole for its emancipation' broke with the old secretiveness...I read the book not once, but ten times. Because everything was so new, it took considerable effort to come to grips with Bebel's views. I had to break with so many things I had previously regarded as correct."

In 1885 came the publication of Engels' "Origins of the Family, Private Property and the State". This examined in detail, on the basis of the available anthropological work, the historical origins of women's oppression.

In 1891 the first issue of Die Gleichheit (Equality) appeared, edited by Clara Zetkin. This paper was intended as an educator of women party members, geared towards the development of women party cadre. It was quite heavily theoretical, and Zetkin constantly argued within the party for the maintenance of this bias, as against any watering down in the quest for some mythical "mass appeal'.

Women workers had to be organised into trade unions, and drawn towards the party. For this a network of vertravenspersonen was to be appointed — women comrades who would take on the job of agitation/organisation amongst working class women. Because of the anti-socialist laws existing in Germany at the time, which prohibited women from directly joining political organisations, this seemed the best way to proceed. Women were also prohibited from joining the same trades unions as men, and one way this was got around was by setting up women's trade associations, which developed links with the corresponding 'men's' unions. This enforced separate organisation probably concidentally aided the development of women activists, and forced them into leadership positions within the trades associations.

In 1908 the anti-socialist laws were repealed, and women were legally able to become party members. By 1910 there were 189,442 women in trade unons, 82,642 women party members, and Die Gleickheit had a circulation of 82,000. The circulation of Die Gleickheit peaked in 1913 at 112,000.

But the work amongst women was very much the task of the women comrades themselves. The party as a whole does not seem to have taken this work particularly seriously. During this period the divisions between right and left within the party, between the reformist wing and the revolutionaries was widening. Zetkin and Die Gleichheit were consistently on the left, and the marginalisation of the women's work cannot be separated from the attempts by the right to squash the left.

With the outbreak of war in 1914, and the voting for war credits of the majority of the SPD's representatives in the Reichstag, the split became irreparable. Die Gleichheit attempted to put a proletarian internationalist anti-war line in the face of terrible state harassment and censorship, colluded in by the SPD leadership. The paper appeared with more and more blank columns, to reveal the extent to which it had been silenced. Ultimately Zetkin was removed by the party as editor and Die Gleickheit was politically neutered.

Zetkin, with other Leftists, among them Rosa Luxemburg and Paul Liebknecht went on to form a new communist party and made attempts to continue some sort of communist work among women. As for the SPD organisation, after the war it became a sort of cross between the worst sort of

Scan page 17

Labour Party women's section and the Women's Institute - mainly doing electoral donkey-work, and welfare work among the working class.

We have much to learn from the work pioneered by Zetkin. The development of special methods for work amongst women, which take into account their specia. difficulties of participation, is essential. The smashing of the women's movement by Social Democracy only goes to show how closely tied the fate of women is with that of the working class. The abandonment of serious attempts by the party as a whole to organise and educate women for socialism was the sharp end of its abandonment of any perspective for organising the working class as a whole for its emancipation. Bolshevism and Stalinism The Bolsheviks, under the leadership of Kollontai, Inessa Armand and Samoslova, were pupils of Zetkin and the German movement in relation to organising women.

On taking power the Bolsheviks abolished all reactionary laws relating to women, and established full political and legal equality for women. Freedom of divorce, abortion, etc., were introduced. Special trains were organised to take birth control facilities into remote areas. All laws against homosexuality were scrapped until 1934.

And a great beginning was made towards freeing women from domestic toil. Communal kitchens, laundries and creches were established.

But these facilities were always far from adequate both in terms of quality and quantity. Trotsky wrote:

"Moreover, the existing creches, even in Moscow, Leningrad, and the other centres, are not satisfactory as a general rule to the least fastidious demands. 'A creche in which the child feels worse than he does at home is not a creche but a bad orphan asylum', complains a leading Soviet newspaper. It is no wonder that the better-placed workers' families avoid creches."

The same applied to other facilities. The communal dining halls left much to be desired when compared to 'home cooking". The laundries did virtually everything but return your laundry clean and fit for use. None of this is particularly surprising, if we think about the nature of the Soviet Union at this time — a materially backward country, with a predominantly peasant economy, where the First World War was followed by the revolution and then civil war in defence of the revolution.

Trotsky warned that only our children and grandchildren will realise this aim" of women's full emancipation. Some Bolsheviks, however, went in for doctrinaire fancies.

•The sequence of war, revolution and civil war had produced many of the same unpremeditated and disintegrating effects on family and sex relations as on other aspects of social life. Here too, 'war communism' marked a specific period; and here, too, what in other conditions would have been treated as the unwelcome result of chaos, confusion and licence was now retrospectively justified in terms of socialist doctrine.' (EH Carr, 'Socialism in One Country' Vol 1., p.27).

With the development of a privileged bureaucracy which usurped political power from the working class, all this changed. The Stalinist big lie, that the Soviet Union was "steaming towards socialism" made it impossible to admit that anything was wrong with the position of women. The exodus of the workers from the shoddy communal facilities was answered with the rehabilitation of the family hearth, of motherhood and of the traditional feminine role. Divorce and abortion laws were tightened up. Women were no longer permitted to decline "the joys of motherhood" as "we have need of people". Working class and peasant women, that is. As for the bureaucrats' wives, "they will, as formerly, do what they find necessary under the very nose of an indulgent judiciary" (Trotsky).

The enormous gains made by women were completely lost, to be replaced by the old slavery of domestic toil. The old family units were reinforced as 'forty million points of support for the bureaucracy.

What conclusions do we uraw from this. Was it simply that material conditions made the advancement of women impossible? Or was it that the conservative philistinism of party men about women overcame their revolutionary principles?

Eurocommunists argue that the experience of the USSR shows that socialism will not bring women's liberation without an autonomous women's movement. But the Stalinist USSR was not and is not socialist. The problem was not the workers' movement excessively dominating women's organisation, but the workers' movement and all independent organisation, male or female, being crushed. The history of the USSR does not show women's position declining while the working class forged ahead -but the defeat of women coming, with the defeat of the working class.

----- pull-quotes -----

party as a whole to organisé and educate

← Contents of Socialist Organiser nos. 341–342: No Turning Back!

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →