A working class heroine
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-01-21Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 12
THE STORY of Marvell Scholl is the story of a working-class woman and a revolutionary.
She led the Women's Auxiliary which organised women to support the great truck-drivers' strike in Minneapolis, USA, in 1934.
The road by which Marvell Scholl became a socialist was one taken by many socialists before and since. She took that road with her husband Farrell Dobbs, who later led the 1934 strike and wrote a history of it.
Scholl and Dobbs married in 1927. Their hearts were full of hope and yearning for the 'American Dream'. Dobbs had left high school in 1925 to get a job. But capitalism could only offer "the school of hard knocks', and when Marvell had children they found it impossible to make ends meet.
Farrell Dobbs scraped a living as a telephone engineer. Then he was marked out for management responsibilities — but he rebelled against big business. Scholl and Dobbs decided instead to go for their dream. He would use his termination pay to set up a small business, earn enough money to finance college education, and after that become a judge and 'use that position to deliver justice'.
As Dobbs recalls, "Before long, though, we discovered the whole thing was a pipe-dream. Our venture into the dog-eat-dog business world soon bankrupted us, and I wound up in 1933 working long hours in a Minneapolis coalyard... able to provide Maryell and our children [by then there were three of them] with no more than a hand-tomouth existence".
The class struggle was about to take hold of the lives of Marvell Scholl and Farrell Dobbs and turn them upside down. Minneapolis was a non-union town, a scabs' paradise, ruled over by the Citizens' Alliance. This association of Minneapolis employers had full-time staff, a spy in every union, and the police at its beck and call. It had held the line against unionism for more than a generation.
Truck-drivers in Minneapolis faced poverty-level wages of as little as $10 for up to 60 hours a week, with the threat of the sack at any time.
Dobbs joined the Teamsters' (truckdrivers') union in 1934. It was a union oranch in which Trotskyists were already organised. In that same year the Trotskyists developed a plan to unionise Minneapolis in a series of courageous strikes and organising drives. The way they ran those strikes is still a model for trade unionists today.
Marvell SchoH became active organising working-class women to support the Teamsters' strikes. The Women's Auxiliary she helped to form was inspired by the example of the women's auxiliary of the Progressive Miners of Illinois of two years previous.
Dobbs recalls that when Carl Skoglund proposed the Auxilary, most men voted for it without enthusiasm. But once the strikes got under way the Women's Auxiliary proved its worth. It organised field hospitals for strikers injured in the street battles with police, it distributed The Organiser, the first daily strike bulletin in America, and it fought on the picket lines.
The Trotskyists, who had pushed for the Women's Auxiliary to be established and treasured its existence, did so for a clear political reason. As one of their leaders, James P Cannon, wrote: "Local 574 did not take any stock in the theory that capital and labour are brothers, and that the way for little brother labour to get a few crumbs is to be a good boy and appeal to the good nature of big brother capital. We see the issue between capital and labour as an unceasing struggle between the class of exploited workers and the class of exploiting parasites.
Marvell Scholl It is a war. What decides in this war, as in all others, is power. The exploiters have organised to grind us down into the dust. We must organise our class to fight back. And the women are half of the working class. Their interests are the same as ours and they are ready to fight for them. Therefore: organise them to take part in the class battie".
Victory in Minneapolis — along with victories in other strikes around the same time in San Francisco and Toledo of unionisation campaigns across the USA, which saw millions of unskilled workers enter the labour movement. Many of them were women and blacks, previously excluded by a trade union movement which concerned itself mostly with the skilled white male workers.
The Minneapolis Teamsters' union also organised the unemployed to refuse to scab. It repaid its debt. The Works Progress Administration set up by President Roosevelt in 1935 involved 'make-work' schemes like the Tories' present YTS and CP schemes. Then, as now, the wages paid were hardly enough to keep body and soul together, and the work was not productive.
1935
Scan page 13
Teamster defence guard battles with cops. an auxiliary unit for the unemployed -the Federal Workers' Section. Dobbs recalls: "A close affinity grew up between the truck drivers and the unemployed. The average Local 574 member thought it only fit and proper to form the Federal Workers' Section so as to help those who had so loyally backed the union in its time of need. Affiliation with a strong trade union gave their movement unprecedented elan, stability, a new measure of dynamism, and an enhanced growth rate".
The most positive developments in today's Transport and General Workers' Union, such as in Merseyside, stand in the tradition of this movement.
Although the Federal functioned supervision of the union's Executive Board, it had full democratic rights in forming an internal structure shaping its own policies. The section had its own Executive Committee, and due unemployed movement the Committee was viewed as an open-ended body to which personnel could be added as required. There was a steward formation which consisted mainly of representatives elected on WPA projects".
Marvell Scholl played a key role in nighting for aid for dependent children and organising women on a large WPA sewing scheme. Centred on this scheme was a special women's division of the Federal Workers' Section.
The FWS organised a series of battles with the city authorities over pay levels and conditions. With each victory the size and strength of the FWS grew.
1937 saw a six-week campaign, including strikes, which forced the Public Welfare Board to grant increased payments. As one activist recalls, "We stormed every session of the Welfare Board, picketed City Hall, organised mass meetings, and mobillised big demonstrations. We beld all-night vigils at the homes of Farmer-Labor Party representatives on the Board. In the end we won a year-round supplement for WPA workers".
Later in 1937, the Roosevelt government and the Minneapolis bosses launched a legal attack on this moyement, with a Federal Grand Jury "investigation' into the strikes. Over 150 strikers were convicted, most of 'conspiracy to deprive the WPA of workers' services', others on framed-up charman Arrested in their homes, they were marched, manacled together, to jail and a series of show trials.
Marvell Scholl produced one of her most powerful pieces of writing about the first of these show trials. The strikers on trial were mainly women. The article was called 'From one woman to another'.
"Next week, when the court reconvenes, a group of our sex is coming to trial on the WPA thing. I would like to talk about these women today, to tell you something about them as persons and unionists.
Knowing them, working with them, taught many of us that women can be as good 'union men' as any member of the male sex. A little less than three years ago, the women o n the WPA began to realise that unless they did something about their own status they would be left far behind the men. Most women on the WPA are mothers, left alone to take care of their children.
Unlike the men, they had not only to work on the WPA, but they had also to maintain their homes, keep their children clean and in school, keep them fed and well.
In other words, they had a double job. It may have been easier, from a purely physical point of view, had most of them stayed on direct relief or mothers' aid — but women are no more ready or willing to take something for nothing than are the opposite sex. They clamoured for, and got, jobs, sewing, cleaning, assisting in hospitals, clerical work — anything at which they could work to earn money.
Working on huge projects, under supervisors who were prone to give favours to favourites, made a group of these WPA women workers realise that unless they organised they were lost. So they organised. They won new and better conditions for all the workers. They took care of their members, called on them when they were ill, helped them get relief when they could not work, helped them get back to a job when laid off, assisted them to do better work when they were in danger of losing good jobs because maybe sewing wasn't something they had been born to do -got parents of workers on Old Age Assistance — aided mothers to get Aid to Dependent Children when it was no longer possible for them to go on with the double job.
In other words, these women took upon their own shoulders the cares and tribulations of many bundreds of families. Took those burdens willingly, their only compensation the knowledge that somebody else's life was a little less burdensome than it had been. They worked tirelessly, completely forgetting themselves in their efforts to help others.
Next week several of these women come to trial. They are charged with "conspiracy'. They face almost certain conviction. If these women — if any of the WPA workers who stands convicted or is in danger of being convicted - if they are guilty, then so is every man and woman in the United States who has ever dared to stand up for his or her own ideals; who has ever struck back against oppression; who has ever believed that this is a free country.
They are charged with 'conspiracy' because they believe in the Golden Rule which tells us to 'do unto others as you will be done by'. If 'conspiracy' is helping your fellow man to a better life; if 'conspiracy' is putting bread into the mouths of hungry chlidren and old people; if "conspiracy' is giving your all with never & thought for yourself, then they stand convicted.
They are real women. proud to be a woman!"
WOMEN'S FIGHTBACK PAGE