Nice, Ufferen Equally
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-01-21Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 11
da about having a GLC Women's Committee and supposedly take notice of the interests of women in London, while at the same time it draws back from the fight for adequate resources for such facilities?
This is to miseducate people about the nature of women's oppression, which is seen on the level of ideas in people's heads rather than the economic way in which women are discriminated against".
Now decentralisation, women's committees, and access to local government resources for new groups, can be good. But they are not inherently socialist. And, as Hilda Kean pointed out, they do not tackle the real roots of women's oppression, and they do not touch the lives of most working-class women. The women in the GLC typing pool still had to raise their hands to ask permission to go to the toilet!
In her new book, Labour, a tale of /wo parties, Hilary Wainwright, who worked for the GLC, is fairly explicit about her views. "Looking back, the Labour Party manifesto for the 1981-85 GLC was nothing like as radical as the policies for which it later became known". What Wainwright sees as radical is the extension of pressuregroup politics, not a fight against the Government.
To put it in perspective - what the GLC did was to introduce into British politics some methods from US politics - methods going back to the early 19th century, when Tammany Hall became the vehicle for the disadvantaged Irish of New York to seize control of the local government machine from the establishrms itics nce ided ed gentry. It introduced pressure-group politics of a broader and more extensive sort than traditional in Britain.
In terms of women's politics, the GLC experience and the model it provided for other Labour left administrations was crucial. Equal-opportunities pressuregroup politics, combined with a variant of cultural feminism, has become the dominant form of women's politics. It has replaced real campaigns and real atte of wo men Pol th iLC erie anc I th e mr it provided. was crucial' ›rov ras cruc tempts to organise women to and now for their liberation.
The GLC did act positively in providing money for women's projects, groups and centres. It had a huge budget which enabled it to do so. But feminist publications such as Outwrite and Troubie and Strife have expressed ambivalence about the whole funding experience. Many groups found that it limited what they were able to do politically. Some found that it militated against real involvement.
"You get paid workers in, and, in a sense, what you're doing is removing the need for the inyolvement of dozens of women who used to put in the effort to produce newsletters, organise conferences, contact the press, keep the whole thing going. I think across London there are very few campaigns left, just offices and workers"
Now, of course, the party is over. The cuts which local authorities are making this year seriously affect women both as workers and as consumers of services. They have also blown apart the whole project of achieving equal opportunities by positive-discrimination measures decreed from above. What use is positive discrimination in hiring when you are cutting jobs?
We need to regroup and reorganise. We need to start building a new women's movement, a working-classbased women's movement which can fight for the interests of women now. It should be a movement like Women Against Pit Closures, but one which fights on a multiplicity of issues, and seeks to involve the mass of working-class women.
All women are oppressed under capitalism. But only working-class women have the power to lead the fight for women's emancipation.
Middle-class women and women in management may be oppressed as women, and experience sexist prejudice and male violence. But they have a definite class interest, ultimately, in maintaining the status quo - after all, they're doing very nicely thank you out of it. It is working-class women who have a real interest in fundamental change in society, the sort of fundamental change which is essential if all womer are to achieve their liberation