Whatever happened to the women's movement?
Socialist Organiser1988 1988-01-21Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
From the 1960s a new mass women's movement emerged in the advanced capitalist countries. There were more women workers than ever before, more women were going into higher education, and traditional moral restrictions had been loosened.
The original four demands of the women's liberation movement in Britain, adopted in 1971, were focused on giving women freedom to escape the housewife role and to take part in society as equals with men: • Equal pay • Equal education and tunities • Free contraception and demand • Free 24-hour nurseries munity control.
From its very beginnings the modern women's movement contained different strands of thought. Some women saw "male power' as the root of women's oppression. Some saw women's liberation as a matter of legal reform within existing society. But most saw the oppression of women as tied to class society, as part and parcel of a society based on exploitation of one class by another. They saw the fight for women's rights not purely as a matter of reforms but as tied to a socialist class-struggle perspective.
Initially, despite arguments at the women's liberation conferences, this variety did not harm the movement. But, as time went on, the differences became more and more sharp — and the socialists more and more marginalised.
Partly this was the fault of the socialists themselves, in particular the organised Marxist groups. Most Marxist groups at the time had a particularly sectarian attitude towards the women's liberation movement. They went along and 'intervened' ', but tended to counterpose bread-and-butter demands to the discussions of sexuality and other more ideological manifestations of women's oppression.
No doubt some women were hostile to all socialists, but mostly the Marxist groups gave themselves a bad press.
By the time of the last-ever women's liberation conference in 1978, the emphasis had shifted from demands around social issues to more personal WOMEN'S FIGHTBACK PAGE 8 Fer questions of sexuality. The 'right of every woman to a self-defined sexuality' was made a preamble to all the other demands. The slogan 'the personal is political, which had had at its core the idea that problems which manifested themselves as personal were in fact the result of the sort of society we live in, was transformed into its opposite - the idea that changing our personal lives was the political struggle.
'Cultural feminism' began to dominate - a feminism focused on challenging "male values" and creating a 'women's culture' . The sort of feminism which sees men as inherently aggressive and violent, and women as nurturing and peace-loving, gained ground. Stereotype ideas which the early women's movement had rebelled against were now the ideas of the movement itself.
Something else happened, too. In the late '70s and early '80s a new left emerged in the Labour Party. The 'Benn for Deputy' campaign and the fight for constitutional change in the Labour Party became a focus for a left wing which drew in many activists from campaigns in the '60s and '70s - people for whom feminism in one way or another formed part of their personal history.
Many women who had been active in the women's movement joined the Labour Party at this time. The Labour Party women's sections were transformed.
This influx of feminist women into the Labour Party had enormous potential. Women from outside the traditional sluggish structures and routines of the labour movement could shake up the Labour Party. A fight to force the labour movement to take up "women's" issues could have an immense impact on the party as a whole.
Women's Fightback argued: "H we can mount a strong campaign along these lines - challenging the existing hierarchies, helping to turn bits of the labour movement outwards to join up with struggles of the women's movement, and constructing bridges and signposts to show women ways to get into and organise together inside tbe labour movement — it could open up whole new territories movement'.
Why was this potential never realised? The debacle of the local government left played a big role.
The new left in the Labour Party made a big impact in local government. Between 1978 and 1983 left-wing Labour administrations were elected in local authorities, at first in London, then in other major cities, for instance Manchester. In May 1981 Ken Livingstone was elected leader of the Greater London Council (GLC).
The GLC of May 1981 was very ditferent from the image we now have of it. Its manifesio contained an explicit commitment to confronting the government over cuts.
"A Labour Greater London Council and Inner London Education Authority will resist any cuts and demand that the Tory Government provides the necessary finance to maintain and improve all council services. Understanding that the Tory Government does not listen to pleas but only responds to pressure, a Labour GLC and ILEA will appeal to the trade union and labour movement to take action, including industrial action, to support 'this stand"
Livingstone personally pledged the support of the GLC to any workers in struggle, as part of the fight to "bring down this government ahead of its time". The GLC was geared to and focused on class struggle.
But it began to veer away from that focus very soon. At the beginning of 1982 the GLC decided to obey the courts over the 'Fares Fair' issue. As John Carvel puts it, the GLC "went legit"
From then on, Livingstone's GLC slid away from its commitment to the working class. Socialist politics were abandoned for a variant of radical liberalism. It was after the GLC had capitulated to the Government that the turn towards women, lesbians and gays, and equal opportunities, took place. These causes did not figure largely in the 1981 manifesto.
They were adopted in the search for ways of being radical that did not mean collision with the Tories and the courts.
Hackney councillor Hilda Kean pointed out the problems with this in an interview in 1985. 'How can the GLC on the one hand make all this propagan-