Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

[It the health cuts! chester area. Local groups…]

Socialist Organiser nos. 341–342: No Turning Back!, 21 January 1988 · scan pp. 7–9 · about 1,368 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 7

It the health cuts!

chester area. Local groups have held tatives and banners from left political had until recently been organised in the behaviolr came fom Altons supmain by various left groupings. Monday porters, Wittiranther such as Nazi saines at which David Alton was speaking, at January, with coaches being booked the Free Trade Hall. The meeting itself mainly by the larger college student was more or less a Catholic church rally, unions but also by a couple of Further with supporters of Alton shipped in by Education colleges.

Criminalising abortion after 18 weeks won't prevent women from having them, but it will force them onto the backstreets and increase the risk of death, infection and sterility.

In Britain, maternal morality associated with abortion has disappeared: legal abortions are safe. however, in 1933 463 deaths were directly attributable to abortion and 97 more were "associated with abortions but not classed to it" • But the social stigma attached to abortion - and its criminality - means that these figures are likely to be hugely underrepresentative.

As the Chief Medical Officer at the time admitted: the figures so provided are far from complete, as from the nature of the case no mention is made of the condition in a certain number of death certifications in which abortion has, or may have, played a part."

Nor do we have figures of how many women suffered sterility through infection, or other disabilities. Some of the abortifacients available carried enorFigh THE CAMPAIGN against the Alton Bill has brought out a number of other issues which restrict women's access to abortion.

One question which often springs to mind is: if David Alton were really so concerned to reduce the number of late abortions, wouldn't he be campaigning against health cuts which force women to wait for weeks on end for their terminations?

Many women at present will borrow money to have private abortions, to ensure they get the whole thing over with The anti-Alton picket had represengroups, the Labour Party, Labour Party women's sections, student unions, the posterage The ever on caine Manchester FAB is now building for demonstration on

Scan page 8

Now do abortion rights in Britain compare w do abortion rights n Britain compai of the world? Michele Carlisle, student National Abortion Campaign, surveys e so-called 'socialist' countries of the mental health — or that of her existing of European countries the woman is family - is endangered by the continua- treated as capable of being able to make tion of the pregnancy; or that there is a her own decisions, control her own David Alton claims that Britain has the most liberal abortion laws in Europe and that his Bill to reduce the upper time limit from 28 to 18 weeks is merely to bring us into line with the rest of Europe, where the average time limit is 14 weeks.

This is only partly true however. What Alton and his supporters omit to poin: out is that in the majority of European countries abortion is available on request up to 14 weeks (on average). Norway, Denmark and Austria give abortions on request up to 12 weeks: in France 10 weeks, Sweden 18 weeks, and in the Netherlands there is no legal upper time limit: in practice women can have abortion on demand up :0 24 weeks.

This is not the case ir Britain, and when Alton and his "pro-life" supporters claim that the 196 Abortion Act provides for abortior on demand they are lying.

In fact abortion in Britain is still a criminal offence unless two doctors agree that the operation is necessary because the mother's life, her physical or The Russian revolution in 1917 provided safe, state-provided abortion for women. Abortion was seen as a woman's right, control over her own fertility as vital if women were to play a fuli part in social and political life.

The Bolsheviks were committed to the fight for the full liberation of women -an uphill struggle in the backward, predominantly peasant economy of Russia at the time.

But as the state degenerated into a Stalinist police state, women's rights were lost. The family again became enshrined as a lynchpin of society. Abortion was made illegal in 1933.

In 1955, after Stalin's death, the Soviet state adopted the policy of 'conscious motherhood' — abortion legalised.

But have Russian women really got 'the right to choose'? What are the abortion facilities like?

Contraception is difficult to come by in the Soviet Union, and unpleasant or downright dangerous to use. Primitive and uncomfortable IUDs, high-dosage pills, poor-quality condoms. This is the sort of contraception available to Soviet As a result, on average a Soviet woman will have 7 or 8 abortions throughout her life. These abortions 25t C the th substantial risk of the baby beine body. seriously handicapped.

So, in this country a woman, far from being able to demand an abortion, has to prove to two doctors that she satisfies these stringent conditions. The decision is theirs not hers. In fact, if a woman's doctor is an anti-abortionist the 1967 Act allows him/her to exercise his/her own "moral" principles over the woman's wishes, whereas in the majority take place in the most appalling conditions. In a Russian feminist Samizdat publication, a woman describes an abortion clinic, known locally as the "slaughterhouse' "Each ward contains ten to fifteen curtained-off beds piled with flannelette blankets. There are never enough sheets.

'The crucial moment comes. The women line up outside the operating theatre.

"Abortions are carried out on two, even on six women simultaneously in the same theatre. The tables are placed so that a women can see everything that goes on opposite her. The face distorted in pain, the blood mass extracted from the womb...

"As she isn't anaesthetised, the woman suffers terrible pain. Some lose consciousness."

After the operation the woman has to walk back to the ward unaided, and is discharged after only a cursory examination the following day. 300 women a day apparently pass through this particular clinic.

Women may formally have the right to choose in Russia. But Russia's production line medical techniques treat women completely inhumanely.

Women not only want the right to choose, but also the right to decent facilities.

organiser c Europe and USSR and The other fact that Alton ignores when referring to the situation in other countries is that extensions are available beyond the 12, 14 or 18 week limits for a variety of reasons: medical and socioeconomic. In Sweden, for example, abortions are legal up to viability if there is a risk to a woman's health. In Greece, weeks, as is incest. In the vast majonity of European countries foetal abnormality is a legitimate reason for "late abortions".

David Alton, however, if he has his way, would force a woman to continue with a pregnancy with no regard as to whether she wants or can cope with a disabled child. For David Alton, looking after handicapped children for 8 hours a day, five days a week, knowing he can (and did) walk away whenever he chose may be 'ennobling': for women whe have to care for such a child 24 hours a day, and not being able to walk away, it can be a nightmare..

Alton has said that "killing people because they are handicapped is neofascist" . What is humane about forcing women to carry on with unwanted pregnancies?

Britain is indeed more liberal on abortion than some European countries: Ireland, for example outlaws abortion altogether. Yet in 1985 as many Southern Irish women had abortions, mainly in Britain, as Danish women who have abortion on request up to 12 weeks. So outlawing abortions doesn't mean women stop having, or needing, them.

If Alton seriously wants Britain's abortion laws to match the rest of Europe's he would be fighting for abortion on demand. He isn't because he wants to ban abortions altogether. We must expose his hypocrisy and fight for free, safe, legal abortions on demand and the right to make our own choices, to control our own lives.

In a personal capacity

Scan page 9

Gaut

----- pull-quotes -----

unlike Britain, rape is recognised as a valid reason for an abortion up to 20

← Contents of Socialist Organiser nos. 341–342: No Turning Back!

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →