Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Fight the Alton. ight

Socialist Organiser nos. 341–342: No Turning Back!, 21 January 1988 · scan pp. 4–6 · about 1,080 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 4

notorious.

What the women's sections need is a new approach. Women's sections should turn outwards to campaigns in the community. They should go on to the estates and into the shopping precincts, talk to working-class women, help them get organised, help them get involved.

Some women's sections have done this around the Alton Bill - leafletting estates, petitioning, campaigning door to door. We have to see our women's sections as not just another meeting every month, but as organising centres for campaign activity.

Women are suffering attacks, but when women are organised they have bags of energy. We only have to look back at Women Against Pit Closures to see that.

Let's get out of the meeting room and on to the streets! Let's get back to basics! That is the way to beat the Alton Bill; and it is the way to go on after the Alton Bill campaign to build a mass working-class-based women's movement. On 27 October last year, Liberal MP David Alton introduced a Bill into the House of Commons which will attempt to restrict women's abortion rights. At the moment, under the 1967 Abortion Act, a woman car be up to 28 weeks pregnant and get an abortion. Alton's Bill seeks to reduce this to 18 weeks.

The vast majority of abortions done in the first 12 weeks of pregnancy. But every year 6,000 women have an abortion after 18 more weeks of pregnancy.

These include: • teenagers who do not realise the) are pregnant until late, or who are scared to go to their doctors; • older women who misread the signs of pregnancy for the menopause; • woren who find they are carry ing an abnormal foetus through tes which work only after 18 weeks of

Scan page 5

LIMIT THE AND Y LIMIT THE WOMEN'S FIGHTBACK PAGE 3

Scan page 6

elimination of the clause in the Act aliowing abortion if on balance the risk to the mother of continuation was greater than that of termination. Since the risk from abortions carried out in proper conditions is very small, this clause allows abortion in a wide range of cases. White, like Corrie in 1979, wanted to specify that the risk to the mother from continuing the pregnancy must be 'grave' or "serious"

later attem amendments It seems every time there is an attack on abortion rights some "shock horror" story hits the headlines. Usually it's of the "babies left to die on draining boards" sort. This time it is something subtler, a story about women (mainly Asian) having abortions because the foetus is female.

The original report was on Radio 4's morning programme 'Today'. By teatime it was one of the main news items, and the point was stressed: abortion on grounds of gender are illegal. This point is dubious. Currently, two doctors must agree abortion is advisable on health or social grounds. This is far from abortion on demand, and what one doctor considers grounds, another will not. However, two doctors could, presumably, agree gender constitutes social grounds for abortion.

Even without the question of legality, the story's ingredients - abortion, race, gender - had something to shock everyone, including women on the Left. It's natural that women who have fought for women's rights, including for choice on abortion, will be shocked by that right being used solely on the grounds that the foetus is female.

In the pro-choice movement we have tended to argue that women do not have abortions for trivial reasons, but because they feel they need them. Some people see gender as a trivial reason, and further, others will see it as a downright reactionary anti-woman. Where does this leave 'a woman's right to choose"?

For a start, to the women involved, gender is not a trivial issue. There are strong cultural reasons for some women going to lengths to have a boy instead of a girl. Sometimes having a son will seem so important that a woman will undergo pregnancy after pregnancy. A researcher into sex determination wrote to the Guardian saying she received "frequent letters from desperate women contemplating divorce, or even suicide, because they are so frightened of having another daughter." It is therefore not : urprising such women should seek abortions as an alternative.

Of course it is disgusting that any were by William Benyon (1977) and Bernard Braine (1978). But it was John Corrie in 1979 who mounted the most serious and radical challenge to abortion rights.

Corrie wanted to limit abortions to 20 weeks in most cases, and to require that the risk to the life of the pregnant woman' from continuing the pregnancy must be 'grave' • The aim was to limit abortions to cases where the woman had special and unusual medical problems.

A huge campaign was mounted to T ALTON'T BILL!

culture should place such a low value on females. However it is that aspect of the culture which must be condemned, not the women who live within it and seek abortions as a way of dealing with its prejudice.

The women's movement must stand by its slogan of 'a woman's right to choose' and each woman must decide for herself what constitutes grounds. It could be argued these women are not making a free choice, but are forced into it by husbands and a culture in which they have little say. There may be truth in this. However, the same applies to defeat the Bill. On 28 October 1979 the Trades Union Congress called an anti-Corrie demonstration joined by about 50,000 people. It was the first time a demonstration of such size had been organised by the labour movement on a "women's" issue.

In no small part thanks to such action - and to independent lobbying and campaigning by the women's movement and the National Abortion Campaign -the Corrie Bill was defeated.

C OFCERONT ALTON S other women. Besides simply nor wanting a child at that time, women alsor have abortions through feeling they can't cope, because of lack of help, money and facilities, or because the foetus is disabled and this society undervalues the disabled, providing little: support or facilities for them. In each case it is society that should be condemned, for making abortion less than a totally free choice. Our aim must. be to change society, meanwhile fighting for abortion to be availabie to all women who want it, whatever their reasons for making that choice

----- pull-quotes -----

WEET NO A TA LANTS Party. MEN Al

← Contents of Socialist Organiser nos. 341–342: No Turning Back!

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →