Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

[many in 1861. It was bought for £700…]

Socialist Organiser no. 340, 14 January 1988 · scan p. 10 · about 690 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

many in 1861. It was bought for £700 a beaten and shot through the head, deposits in the cracks are crystals of year old boy treated her as an equal Socialist Organiser no. 340. 14 January 1988 Page 10 To most people Archaeoptery, the fossil bird with teeth and a long bony tail, is a fascinating relic, a link between reptiles and birds, proof that evolution has taken place.

However, to astronomer and promoter peculiar theories Fred Hoyle, it is nothing more or less than monstrous fraud, perpetrated to dispreve evolution in avour of "creationism"

Hoyle's claim has come under critical scrutiny in many quarters, most effectively by Steven Jay Gould writing in the US journal Natural History, last year.

The first example of a fossil Archaeoptery was found when a block of lithographic limestone was split in Germany in 1861. It was bought for £700 a year later by Richard Owen for the BM(NH) British Museum (Natural History).

Lithographic limestone is a very fine sedimentary rock in which details as intricate as the membranes of jellyfish and the hairy legs of anthropods can be preserved. It is certainly capable of preserving feathers, should they be on a dead animal.

But according to Hoyle, Archaecpteryx was originally without feathers an ordinary, millions of years old reptile. Someone had painted a thin layer of limestone cement over the two halves of the block and them pressed in some modern feathers.

Alan Charig, head fossil-keeper at the BM(NH), and colleagues spent some considerable time and effort disproving this "theory" Gould describes their findings, adding his "2 cents' worth for good measure. His exposition is a masterpiece of clear thinking.

First, with layers of cement on the surfaces of the split block, it would be impossible for them to fit exactly. Yet Charig has proved an "exquisite" fit. There are hairline cracks filled with deposits. Hoyle claimed this was cracking in the artificial cement. Charig showed the cracks went right into the block, extending with a perfect match through both halves. Further, deposits in the cracks are crystals of calcite that take far longer to form than the 125 years since the fossil was discovered.

Second, dendrites, delicate tree-like deposits of manganese dioxide cover both halves, overlaying the feathers in some places. A photograph of dendrites on one half printed backwards exactly matches the pattern on the other half. The dendrites must have been there before the slab was split - and so must the feathers.

Third, feathers are not the only birdlike features of Archaeoptery. There ате aLSO one perching 1oot and "wishbone" typical not of reptiles but of birds. How could a forger have faked these?

Fourth, how did the forger manufaccure the ligaments holding the feathers to the tail vertebrae?

Fifth, was the same forger working in 1877, when the next fossil Archaecpteryx was found? Were his descendants doing the same trick in the 1950s when the next fossils were found?

When trying to show a motive for deliberate conspiracy by the Superintendant of the BM(NH) Owen, Hoyle fares no better. According to Hoyle, Owen was so vehemently opposed to Darwin and evolution, he bought an obvious fake, hoping its unmasking would discredit evolutionary theory.| Gould sees several objections here. Owen was hardly likely to delteratel endanger the reputation of the BM(NH) when he had just dedicated much effort in getting support for the building of its South Kensington premises. Darwin's theory did not stand or fall with Archaeepteryx.

Most damning of Hoyle's scholarship, Owen was not opposed to theories of evolution, just to Darwin's. He saw Archaeoptery as support for his own theory of evolution.

Gould is most scathing on Hoyle's apparent ignorance of Owen's true ideas.

if Hovle had spent as little as an hour reading Owen's writings, he could not have made such a blunder.

Gould is particularly annoyed at the waste of a scientist's time in disproving Hoyle's irresponsible allegations and also at the "on the one hand, on the other hand" approach of the press. This has the effect of misleading their readers into seeing the argument as one between two valid Viewpoints. ed

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 340

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →