Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Boom cil

Socialist Organiser no. 340, 14 January 1988 · scan p. 7 · about 938 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 7

WAs this tenement strategy has reach- caste across the no-man's-land of ded los supersaturation point, Pershing Square, Fifth Street families have spilled over into a metamorphoses into the 'Nickel': burgeoning-black market in hous- the notorious half-mile strip of ing. In a city where thousands of blood-and-vomit spewn concrete -luxury condominiums stand unoc- where several thousand homeless cupied, at least two hundred thou people live. sand immigrants from Mexico and Last winter, after a number of Central America are living in illegal people froze to death on the streets. garage conversions, typically the mayor — at the urging of the —in some areas, whole families businessmen — ordered police are less than 30 years ld.

What should be the response of acialists to these attacks? -Much of the theoretical back-up + the Tory propaganda offensive s been gained from the work of matcherite Alice Coleman, who tried out a study which correlated people who live there are inhless. poor, and desperate; but, all other things being equal, design makes a big difterence.

'The reason is the lack of contact between tenants in large blocks, poor security caused by an inability to control access to the blocks, and the existence of large areas - corridors, lifts, entrance halls, walkways, open spaces surrounding flats — which are neither private nor as public as a street.

Coleman suggests that existing flats can be made more like houses by 'top downing' high blocks and restricting the number of flats which share a common entrance, and that new building should be houses rather than flats.

Thus far the evidence is detailed and convincing; but Coleman goes on to claim that it is all a result of central planning and to imply that where housing is publicly owned it will inevitably be bad. She makes the remarkable assertion (unsubstantiated by her research) that houses were better designed in the Victorian era or in the shanty towns of the Third World.

In fact big tenement blocks were a common form of private-landlord housing for workers in early inductrial Rritain and property is houses. Working-class people in Britain seem always to have preferred houses to flats. In recent years, the most vigorous action based on Coleman's research Loverall desian of the estates. the flats, internally, were usually a big improvement.

The modern movement in architecture, whose glass wall skyscrapers were increasingly dominating city centres, had long had a vague preference for big blocks of flats as somehow more socialistic than individual houses. And — this was probably crucial -the big building companies reckoned that they could build big blocks of flats more quickly and more profitably than other forms of housing. They offered local councils deals whereby building would be cheaper if the council put up enough blocks to make industrialised systembuilding worthwhile.

It was a fiasen - Can sed not en much by planning, but by the wrong kind of planning, bureaucratic planning from above.

Since the early part of this century the labour movement has been dominated by reformist ideas. These ideas hold that working class people are basically passive, and are not therefore to be involved in the planning of something as basic as their own homes.

With democratic workers' control over the building, construction and nlannina enharac али Pias WULACES -could plan the houses they want. At present the house price boom and the restricted ownership of land prevent most workers from ever having any hope of adequate hous-ll Los Angeles, the boom city of Reagan's USA, shows us where Thatcherism is going.

Since 1981 federal housing assistance has been slashed by seventy percent without compensatory support from state or city authorities. Los Angeles has not built a unit of public housing since the controversies of the McCarthy period, and the existing stock of older rental property is being systematically depleted by redevelopment and condoninium conversion.

The cheapest family units in the city, in the most dilapidated neighbourhoods, now cost about seventy percent of the income of a minimum-wage worker.

The result has been universal overcrowding as two or three, sometimes even four, immigrant families are forced to pecupy a *single family dy elling or apartment: without plumbing or heat. have to hot-bed' - share beds, sleeping in shifts. I The shortest route between Heaven and Hell in contemporary America is probably Fifth Street in Downtown L.A. West of the refurbished Biltmore Hotel, and spilling across the moat of the Harbor Freeway, a post-1970 glass and steel skyscape advertises the landrush of Pacific Rim capital to the central city. Here, Japanese megadevelopers, transnational bankers and billionaire corporate raiders piot ine restructuring of the California economy. A few blocks onto If the Tories get away with their proposals, they will lead to a vast increase in homelessness and in overcrowding and inadequate housing.

If rents (which are already escalating where not tightly controlled) rise until the market will take no more, that will drive many working class families nut into the vul HAV CAV street and cause much hardship to countless others. (WIch is in any case experiensing one of the worst slumps in its history) will fail dismally to build enough houses to meet the need for them. 'Demand' and 'need' are two quite different things. The prices of new houses will rule out any possibility of most working class people being able to afford them.

Young people leaving home will Lanu even tess nance or unanig secure accommodation. The number of people who come to our cities in search of work and end up homeless and destitute will increase drastically. The qyality of the hous ing stock will deteriorate still fur-

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 340

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →