Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

A modest cost-benefit analysis

Socialist Organiser no. 339, 10 December 1987 · scan p. 8 · Jim Denham · about 681 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Parliamentary report. Transcribed from the scan (5 Nov 2026); the machine reading had run it into The Union of Jewish Students motion.

Proofed text: read against the scan word by word; spelling, punctuation and wording are as printed.

Scan page 8

Parliamentary Debate (Hansard). Prime Minister's Question Time. 2.45pm.

Sir Reginald Eyreslicker (Slithy-Tove, Con): Will the Prime Minister please be good enough to give the House, if she would be so gracious, full details of the latest wondrous expansion of National Health Service facilities, for instance the opening of the new Portakabin at Upper Tove General Hospital?

Mrs Thatcher (Compleat, Con): I concur entirely with the points raised by the Hon. Gentleman (Tory cheers).

Mr Neil Windbag (Flanelli, Lab): On a point of order, Mr Speaker, I would like to say that we on this side of the House strongly and resolutely and with all the strength and resolution at our command bitterly object to, and indeed, find utterly sickening and repugnant, the effrontery of the Prime Minister in coming before this House today to boast of the opening of one so-called Portakabin facility, when, up and down the breadth of Britain every man, woman and child, regardless of age, race or creed, knows that our National Health Service is being deliberately and systematically dismantled, and that people, regardless of creed, age or race, are literally dying as the direct result of the utterly repugnant and sickening policies of her Government with regard to this matter.

And furthermore, I would like to state categorically that... (Tory cries of 'Sit down, Pillock!')

Mrs Thatcher (Con): The Hon. Gentleman is obviously unaware of the fact that under this Government expenditure on the Health Service, measured in per capita terms, has risen by over 5p per head of the population since 1979, representing a 131% increase in real terms over the record of the last Labour administration. (Ecstatic Tory cheers).

But even our largesse is necessarily constrained. Allowing everyone, irrespective of their status, unlimited access to services which cost nothing at the point of delivery, is inevitably impossible. Thus there will always be excess demand for health care.

And, remember, these services have to be paid for by the taxpayer. Thus, further improvements in the quality of health care depend on the further strengthening of the nation's economic position. Unfortunately, most of the users of the Health Service are unproductive and often unworthy and feckless individuals who contribute nothing to the well-being of the nation and are a constant burden on the taxpayer (Labour cries of 'Shame! Disgraceful!' etc).

The party opposite may protest, but the facts speak for themselves: what contribution do babies with defective hearts make to the economic recovery of our nation? Of what productive value are kidney patients lying in bed all day with their expensive machines? How can we justify subsidising, from the public purse, the maintenance of unlimited numbers of disgusting incontinent old geriatrics?

If my Chancellor is to fulfil his commitment to reducing the basic rate of income tax by 2p in the pound next year, then economies will have to be made, and, to be frank, passengers cannot be carried in this great journey of national regeneration.

A long-term solution must await not so much the injection of more cash, but reform of the nation's health care system and a realistic setting of priorities for hospitals. To this end we have produced an expensively researched set of guidelines, 'How To Avoid Wasting Money on Sickly Kids and Old Coffin-Dodgers', to be issued to all Regional Health Authorities in the New Year. (Uproar in House, Labour cries of 'Shame! Disgraceful', etc.)

Mr Speaker: Order! I will not tolerate this unruly behaviour and continual interruption. Will Honourable Members please have regard to the procedures of the House? I call the Hon. Member for Flanelli, so long as he is brief (Tory laughter).

Mr Neil Windbag (for it is he): The Hon. Lady's statement will, and we on this side of this House have absolutely no doubt on this one, send shock waves of utter repulsion and repugnance resounding through the four corners of the land as the people of Britain recoil in utter revulsion from the repugnant implications of her utterances on this one. Let me say categorically that... (Windbag drones on ad nauseam; House drifts into slumber).

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 339

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →