Thinking about films
Socialist Organiser1987 1987-12-10Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Belinda Weaver reviews Pauline Kael's State of the Art. Transcribed from the scan (5 Nov 2026); the machine reading had run it into The Union of Jewish Students motion.
Proofed text: read against the scan word by word; spelling, punctuation and wording are as printed.
Scan page 8
You don't have to know a lot about movies to enjoy Pauline Kael's film reviews. She isn't one for the casual namedrop of some obscure film-maker, and you don't have to have seen every film ever made just to get started on her latest review.
Her latest book, 'State of the Art', is the seventh of her collections. Like the rest, it's very readable. Her style is easy; she uses no big words where simple ones would do. She's out to inform, not impress. She can even be slangy.
It's like talk rather than writing, though it's talk with all the boring bits cut out. Her reviews are often complex, full of ideas, but it's all so clearly put that the ideas can be easily understood.
All of Kael's earlier collections had titles with a slight sexual tinge — 'I Lost it at the Movies', 'When the Lights Go Down', 'Reeling', and so on. But in her latest book she breaks with that. "It seemed time for a change; this has not been a period for anything like "Grand Passions".
"I hope that 'State of the Art' will sound ominous and sweeping and just slightly clinical. In the last few years, the term has been applied to movies as the highest praise for their up-to-the-minute special effects or their sound or animation; it has been used to celebrate just about all the technological skills that go into a production. But what I try to get at...is the state of the art of moviemaking."
Kael has been reviewing films for the 'New Yorker' for almost thirty years. She is respected and feared in the film world.
What makes her readable and welcome is her readiness to puncture pretension of any kind, her championing of film-makers trying to make good films in a market obsessed with commercialism, and her ruthless attacks on the overblown mediocrity of many Hollywood movies today.
She is sharp but she isn't spiteful. There's usually plenty of evidence to back up her more unwelcome (to the film producers) comments.
Kael takes pains over her work. So many reviewers dash off their columns with little thought. Reading them, one often wonders whether they sat through the films at all. Kael is passionately interested in the movies.
She pounces on any ray of hope, and enthusiastically promotes promising actors and directors. Even when you don't agree, her reviews are worthwhile. They're stimulating because they are considered; they take a point of view. And they're funny too.
After Sylvester Stallone had built up John Travolta's physique for the abysmal 'Stayin' Alive', Kael queried the need for change. "Dancers don't need big body builders' muscles. What would they do with them — lift ten-ton ballerinas?"