The view from the whites' farm
Socialist Organiser1987 1987-12-10Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Belinda Weaver reviews The Kitchen Toto. Transcribed from the scan (5 Nov 2026); the machine reading had run it into The Union of Jewish Students motion.
Proofed text: read against the scan word by word; spelling, punctuation and wording are as printed.
Scan page 8
'The Kitchen Toto' could be better, but it's not bad. It is also a start. We aren't deluged with films about the black struggle for independence in Kenya in the 1950s, so this one is welcome as breaking the silence.
It doesn't tackle the issues in any depth, and some of the most important information is in throwaway lines, but it packs an emotional punch and gets you thinking.
The film is set in 1950. The Kikuyu tribe are attacking the British as and when they can. They see the British as usurpers who have the pick of the land, and who hold on to their privileges through force of arms. It's a little too sympathetic to the British. Director Harry Hook presumably sympathises with the Kikuyu, since he allows the Kikuyus' claims about the land and their reasons for struggle to stand. However, he doesn't convey any real sense of the Mau Mau movement. What we see is a rather nasty gang going round terrorising blacks who don't sympathise with their cause or don't like their methods, rather than a legitimate struggle for freedom and independence from colonial rule.
As they're portrayed here, the Mau Mau wouldn't be out of place as the baddies in 'The Untouchables'!
The whites don't get it all their way, of course. The Memsahib, into whose kitchen poor Mwangi, a young Kikuyu boy, is sent to work, is joyless and stiff; her son is a comic book horror. Both bullying and cowardly, he exudes a sort of matter-of-fact brutality. Hook claims the sketch is part-biographical — at least he's learned to laugh at himself.
His father, though, the police chief, is just the kind of pillar of the Empire Brit we've been seeing on the screen for years. To bring him up to date though, he's portrayed as kindly and sympathetic — the finest type of Englishman. It's his job to deal with the marauding Kikuyu.
Middle
The story really deals with young Mwangi, who's caught in the middle. With good reason to fear the Mau Mau, Mwangi still has no real pull towards the whites. The police chief treats him kindly, but Mwangi is a very lowly servant in his home indeed.
Mwangi's youth is no protection against fear, brutality, violence and the consequences of political struggle. He must make decisions about his actions that will have life or death repercussions.
Perhaps the most eloquent line in the film is one that flashes on at the end. The Mau Mau struggle claimed 14,080 lives — 80 European, 14,000 African. It would be good to see a film that told the side of those 14,000.