Unite for Palestinian rights!
Socialist Organiser1987 1987-12-10Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →
Open letter to the General Union of Palestinian Students, signed Jane Ashworth and Dave Brennan. Transcribed from the scan (5 Nov 2026); the machine reading had run it into The SSiN motion and Manoeuvres foul debate. "millon" and "epiphetmongering" as printed.
Proofed text: read against the scan word by word; spelling, punctuation and wording are as printed.
Scan page 6
Dear comrades,
As you know better than we, the recent history of the Arab people of Palestine is one of unrelieved tragedy and suffering.
Your people were defeated in the 1948 war along with the armies of Syria, Egypt, Jordan and Iraq which invaded the territory allotted to the Jews under the UN partition plan on 15 May, the day after the state of Israel was proclaimed. The Palestinian people were the great losers in that anti-Jewish war.
Between half and three-quarters of a million Palestinian Arabs fled or were driven out of Jewish-held territory. Those people and their descendants — who now number over four millon — have been scattered over the Middle East or left to languish in refugee camps. Another 300,000 were made refugees by Israel's advances in 1967, and many were made refugees a second time in 1982.
The Palestinian Arabs in the refugee camps have been subjected to frequent, savage and indiscriminate reprisals against the PLO by the Israeli air force. They are used as a political football by the Arab bourgeois regimes, which pursue their own interests. They have been betrayed and massacred by those regimes.
It was Jordan which joined Israel in 1949 to divide up what remained of the territory allotted to the Palestinian Arabs in the 1947 UN partition plan. It was Jordan which massacred your people, up to 30,000 of them, in September 1970. Syria massacred your people in Lebanon in the mid '70s. Lebanese groups, both Muslim and Christian, have massacred them in the '80s.
It is a terrible and heartbreaking story. There is no end to it in sight.
What can socialists and activists in the labour and union movement do to help the Palestinians? Organise for medical and similar practical help; but what else? This question seems to us to translate into another question: what political solutions are possible?
For it is no longer a question only of the Palestinian Arabs. There is also a Palestinian Jewish nation, the Israelis. Right now the Israelis oppress the Palestinian Arabs, both inside pre-'67 Israel and in the Israeli-occupied West Bank and Gaza Strip, which have been ruled by a repressive colonial regime for 20 years. But Israel is surrounded by numerous hostile Arab states, of which only Egypt even has diplomatic relations with Israel. Any solution has to take account of both the nations in Palestine.
For ourselves, we think that the only solution will be one which allows each Palestinian nation to have its own nation-state. Two nations, two states, as our slogan at the recent NUS conference put it.
In practice the PLO, the organisation which has the support of the majority of Palestinians and to which you are attached, also advocates two states. To win this solution means, immediately, winning the right of the Palestinian Arabs to set up their own nation-state in Palestine side-by-side with Israel, on a basis of mutual recognition of Israel and the PLO. The Israelis have a state already — and, for now, more than their fair share of self-determination.
As you know, we support the setting up of a Palestinian state, and we advocate the recognition of the PLO by Israel and everyone else concerned. We support the struggles against discrimination and oppression of the Arabs in the occupied territories and in Israel itself.
It was painful for us, therefore, to find ourselves in sharp conflict with you at the NUS conference. You allied yourselves with the incumbent leadership of the NUS. You allowed yourselves to get drawn in to NUS faction-fighting to the extent that, if we may say so, you forget where your best interests lie.
The NUS leaders are a crowd of Stalinoid reformists, who are not very interested in Palestine. They put the subject on the agenda, not because it would help the Palestinian Arab people but because they wanted to punish the Union of Jewish Students for opposing their control of NUS.
Discussion
They did not organise a serious discussion on the issue. That would have required a drive to educate students so that they could make up their own minds on the issue. Instead they imposed the debate on a conference that was not ready for it. The inevitable consequence was a debate dominated by emotion instead of reason, and by slogans instead of coherent ideas. Even so, they didn't have things all their own way.
You allowed yourselves to get drawn into conflict with people — Socialist Students in NOLS — who support your demands while at the same time opposing and campaigning against the vicious Zionophobia which is a large part of the stock-in-trade of some 'pro-Palestinian' activists in the NUS.
More than that, you proved unable to see what was going on at conference. You were not just in conflict with the sympathisers and supporters of Palestinian Arab rights in SSiN. More importantly, you continued to be in sharp conflict with the Union of Jewish Students, despite the fact that the UJS had a resolution advocating the right of Palestinian Arabs to have their own state.
This and other parts of the UJS resolution (amendment 2) far outweighed those parts of their resolution which we would not agree with and you naturally find intensely objectionable, for example, the definition of Zionism as a 'national liberation movement'. Comrades, if you had not been following the lead of the irresponsible and unprincipled factionalists who lead the NUS, you would have recognised that a new situation had taken shape at the NUS conference.
For 11 years the NUS has been 'pro-Palestinian'. For 11 years the Jews in NUS have been ghettoised. For 11 years the ultra-left phrasemongers have held sway at NUS conferences, calling for the destruction of Israel. And what has it got the oppressed Palestinian Arab people? Nothing!
The pseudo-left have repelled reasonable people and substituted mindless slogans for effective politics. At this year's conference a possibility existed for you to join in forging an alliance ranging from the hard left — Socialist Organiser — to the UJS which would champion the right of your people to have their own state as part of a general settlement and recognition of both Palestinian Arab and Israeli Jewish national rights.
Instead of seizing the chance, you preferred to dwell among those who have shown themselves unable — even at the head of an organisation 1,200,000 strong — to build anything in support of either the Palestinian Arabs or in support of a settlement that will do justice to both Palestinian Arabs and Jews.
In a sense you were caught in the cross-fire. But there were political reasons why you let that happen. We suggest that one of those reasons is a deep ambivalence about what your own politics are.
The PLO now wants two states, but it still says its long-term objective is a secular democratic state. It defines it as a single bi-national state in Palestine. All your traditional definitions of the secular democratic state have defined it in effect as an Arab state with rights for 'Muslims, Christians, and Jews'.
You were politically disoriented at conference because you are not clear yourselves which version you want. Saying you supported the right of the Jewish Israeli nation to have its own nation state, you talked at the same time of the right of 'return' of the descendants of those who left or were driven out in 1948. You can't have both two states and the right of the Palestinian Arabs to possess all of Palestine.
We, like you, would choose a single bi-national state. But we have to take it as a fact that we cannot change that there are two antagonistic nations in Palestine, and that they cannot be simply merged.
You allowed yourselves to see the secondary things — like, for example, whether or not Zionism is racism
Scan page 7
— as being of equal or greater importance than the political fundamentals in the situation: the right of the Palestinian Arabs to have their own state.
We found the conflict with you regrettable and painful. We found the leaflet you put out about us on the last day of conference in which, among other things, you called us fascists, simply farcical!
You say you were responding to a leaflet we put out. But we find it difficult to believe you really think we said — or meant to say — that because the Jewish majority in Israel has a right to its own nation state, it is therefore right for the Jewish majority to treat the Arabs within Israel as 'aliens' or anything less than fully equal citizens. No, we don't think that, and we said nothing that could reasonably be construed as meaning it, either!
Nor is it reasonable of you to accuse us — because we support the right of the Palestinian Jews as well as the Palestinian Arabs to have their own nation state — of advocating an exclusivist Jewish state. No, we don't advocate that!
What we advocate is the right of the small Jewish minority in the Middle East not to be forcibly incorporated into an Arab state. Once that is agreed, then the struggle for individual rights for Arabs and Jews in each others' states takes its proper place in the picture. It is something that can be taken for granted among socialists and democrats.
Your casual allegation that we are racists is itself a typical example of the wild and often senseless epiphetmongering that does service for serious and honest discussion of the issues among those on the left with whom you choose to ally yourselves.
Comrades, people writing polemics sometimes get carried away with themselves, and maybe that is what your leaflet-writer did. We suggest that you should now take stock of where things are in the NUS.
There is no NUS policy on the Middle East now. Presumably the matter will come to conference again a year from now. Between now and then, you should help us forge the broadest possible alliance, an alliance that could include both the Union of Jewish Students and the General Union of Palestinian Students, to advocate two states and recognition of each other by Israel and the PLO.