Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

1917 How the workers made a revolution

Socialist Organiser no. 339, 10 December 1987 · scan pp. 9–10 · about 410 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

fluenced directly or indirectly by Deutscher rather than Trotsky Ralph Miliband is one. So Deutscher's work is important in its own right.

The Trotsky trilogy shows both the best and the worst of Deutscher. It is beautifully written - the more so when one remembers that English was not his first language - and as fascinating and compelling to read as first-rate fiction. A whole historical period comes alive in Deutscher's writing.

For Deutscher Trotsky was a tragic historical figure, almost in the classical sense that his undoing was caused by a fatal flaw in his own personality. Thus Trotsky's rise to power created conditions that were to lead to his fall: there was an aspect of 'Defeat in Victory, that was to undermine not just Trotsky personalto power — the bureaucratic counterrevolution - as following from the same inevitable historical process that forced the Bolsheviks to make their difficult choices in the early period after the revolution.

Deutscher's trilogy can be read as an indictment of Stalin and a vindication of Trotsky. That is certainly how it was perceived when it was first written. And up to a point, it is. But only up to a point. Beyond that, it is a depiction of Trotsky's struggle against Stalin as a futile endeavour — sad, even poignant but pointless.

And so Deutscher's account becomes more detached the further it goes. Trotsky was defeated in Russia, expelled from the party, and then exiled from the country. The Trotskyists were defeated internationally. And then the triumph of Stalinism brought with it the triumph of worse, completely falsify the ideas for which Marxists have fought. Even where Deutscher's own politics led his assessments off the rails, his presentation of Trotsky's view is clear and honest.

And so as a result, despite its defects, Deutscher's trilogy is a work every Marxist should read. It is particularly useful for younger or newer comrades — it covers a huge subject matter in an extremely entertaining manner, and introduces not only the historical context, but various relevant theoretical issues (like the role of the individual in history).

Other books could supplement Deutscher's - in particular Trotsky's own 'My Life' (which is also as exciting as the raciest of novels). But Deutscher's three-volume epic deserves to be considered a master[piece.

60 pence A Socialist Organiser special special issue on the Russian Revolution. Available from SO, PO Box 823, London SE15 60p plus 20p postage.

Scan page 10

ight Manchester

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 339

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →