An AIDS blind alley?
Socialist Organiser1987 1987-12-10Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
Isaac Deutscher's three-volume biography of Trotsky, recently reissued, remains the classic work on Trotsky's life and thought.
Thirty years after its appearance, Deutscher's trilogy is still an excellent study not only of Trotsky, but of the whole generation of the Russian Revolution.
Deutscher was a Polish communist who supported Trotsky's Left Opposition and was Trotsky's comrade until 1938, when Deutscher rejected the project of a new, 'Fourth' International. Thereafter, Deutscher moved away from revolutionary politics, and in particular from Trotsky's views on Stalinism in Russia. Deutscher shared many of Trotsky's criticisms of Stalinism, but considered it possible that the ruling bureaucracy could reform itself: revolution was not needed. He would no doubt have looked kindly on Gorbachev.
Many contemporary critics of Stalinism on the Left have been inly, but the whole programme of workers' democracy for which he stood. To carry through the revolution, the Bolsheviks were forced to make choices that unwittingly paved the way for Stalin.
Conversely, for Deutscher there was in Trotsky's death an element of 'Victory in Defeat': in a moral sense Trotsky had triumphed over his Stalinist murderers.| Vivid and readable as Deutscher's acount is, it reveals a political approach seriously at odds with Trotsky's, despite its apparent warm sympathy to Trotsky and his ideas. Essentially, Deutscher considered Stalin - and his mass-murdering bureaucratic tyranny - to be historically inevitable. It was unpleasant; and those who fought it were morally laüdable; but historically, they were wasting their time.
He therefore presents Stalin's rise fascism, as the German Communists failed to fight Hitler, then failed to criticise their own passivity and sectarianism. The Trotskyists decided they had no choice but to start afresh - to refound the Marxist movement.
Deutscher opposed the creation of the Fourth International at the time. In his biography he gives a spirited and polemical defence of the stand he took then. But he does more than that: his essential verdict is that Trotsky should have given up the effort of political activity and devoted himself (like Deutscher) to commentary, journalism, literary criticism and so on. It is a perverse and philistine judgement, and undermines the merits of Deutscher's trilogy.
The defects are central to the trilogy as politics. But as literature and as biography, they are still, combined, a classic. There is still for example, no biography of Lenin even vaguely to compare with it in quality.
Deutscher is scrupulously concerned to present and assess Trotsky's ideas. So often biographies ignore (or A recent programme in the Channel 4 documentary series "Dispatches" advanced the notion that the Human Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV) is not the cause of AIDS, and that research into other possible causes is being obstructed by a drug and health care industry with a massive vested interest in the HIV business.
Ever since HIV was identified, there has been controversy over its status. In the early days it was called Human T Leukaemia Virus type 3 (HTLV3) or Lymphademopathy Associated Virus (LAV) depending upon whether you supported Robert Gallo or Luc Montagnier in their claim to ownership of the considerable academic and commerical benefits of its discovery.
The influential gay magazines "New York Native' and 'Christopher Street' gave much space to publicising the theory of microbiologist Jean Teas that the cause of AIDS was African swine fever virus (ASFV). The CIA had used a form of ASFV in the mid-1970s in an attempt to ruin Cuban agriculture, and the virus had spread by 1979 from Cuba to Haiti, one of the countries in which AIDS first became established. The US Deparment of Agriculture and New York State Health Department announced plans to test the connection but the Centre for Disease Contro (CDC) and the National Institute of Health (NIH) dismissed the ASFV hypothesis, and such is their control over AIDS research in the States that nothing has happened.
Many commentators linked such inactivity to the political influence of the farming lobbies; the $10 billion pork industry facing destruction if such a hypothesis entered popular consciousness, let alone if it was proven.
Theories that AIDS has resulted from genetic manipulation of viruses — either for military or commercial purposes have been me s variety of sources, from "scientific Trotskyist group" Communist Cadre to a variety of establishment figures.
There is in reality little support for these theories (and even the New York Native has stopped referring to AIDS as ASFV disease as it did for a while), but the way they are handled reflects upon the control which is maintained over AIDS research.
At a meeting a few months ago in London Gallo made an extraordinarily impassioned plea for "British physicians to join with their US counterparts and dispose once and for all of the myth that the virus was created in a laboratory."] The Channel 4 documentary, and a US book "AIDS and syphilis: the hidden link" by Harris Coulter (which isn't yet available in this country, and I haven't read) suggest that the real cause of AIDS is the spirochaete bacteria treponema pallidum, the miro-organism which causes syphilis, The symptoms of tertiary syphilis can be similar to those of AIDS; this is particularly true of AIDS-related dementia and the dementia of tertiary syphilis. Some people with AIDS are positive on blood tests for treponema, and it is known that the currently used standard tests can often fail to detect that contact with the micro-organism has occured when in fact it has.
Some doctors in the US are treating people with AIDS with the appropriate therapy for syphilis, penicillin.
Clearly there is little profit for drug companies in this: penicillin is no longer a registered, i.e. patented drug. Any company can produce it. It is consequently cheap and a source of little profit when compared to a patented, exclusive drug like AZT.
One vocal protagonist of penicillin treatment, Dr. Stephen Caiazza, claims to have been assaulted by an agent of a West Germany pharmaceutical company. Other, less direct, ways have been used to limit research into putative treatment for AIDS offering low or no profits (e.g.
In truth the evidence for syphilis as the cause of AIDS is not convincing, though untreated syphilis in people who also have HIV may be a serious problem. However important issues are raised about why alternative hypotheses are advanced and the way they are dealt with.
There is great uncertainty about why transmission rates are different noble went to develo AIDS and others don't. It seems certain that factors besides the mere presence of HIV are involved in the development of AIDS - these are referred to as co-factors.
For other infectious diseases, nutritional status, the presence of other infections or co-existing disease and stress have been identified as cofactors. In the case of AIDS the presence of other infections, including venereal diseases, have been implicated in this role.
However compared to virological and pharmaceutical research, vestigations in this area have been scant.
Megaprofits clearly do not lie along this route. Even in universities, research is now often funded by business and industry concerns - a process which the present government is encouraging. Academic departments are to be rated on their ability to attract external funding. Researchers, increasingly on short-term contracts, are finding themselves in the situation of either finding such external funding and engaging in research in areas which are well-sponsored or collecting a UB 40.
The uniformity in the direction of research that this produces - with drug 'cures' for AIDS and recombinant HIV vaccines being the main target of investigation - reduces the chance of exploring other, perhaps more fruitful, approaches.