Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Manoeuvres foul debate

Socialist Organiser no. 339, 10 December 1987 · scan p. 7 · Jane Ashworth · about 1,239 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →

Reader request 5 Nov 2026 (the Sunderland Poly and UJS articles): transcribed from the scan; the machine reading had run in other pieces on the page (the p. 7 end of the open letter to GUPS). "In the same leaflet" as printed, though no leaflet is named before it.

Proofed text: read against the scan word by word; spelling, punctuation and wording are as printed.

Scan page 7

The conference of the National Union of Students was dominated by the Middle East debate.

Unfortunately there was no clear discussion. The entire three days of debate were marked by the opportunism and unprincipled ganging-up of the 'anti-Zionists'. In the end, all the positions fell.

Socialist Students in NOLS (SSiN) was accused of both opportunism and racism. But in fact it is the National Organisation of Labour Students, the Socialist Workers' Party, Campaign Student and 'Students for Palestine' who displayed the most pathetic opportunism, fired by factional hatred of the twin devils — SSiN and the Union of Jewish Students.

In fact all the motions called for two states in pre-1947 Palestine — a Palestinian Arab state alongside Israel. But the oh-so-principled Campaign Student and SWP — who don't support this position at all, and who favour one democratic secular (or 'socialist') state in Palestine — managed to support one of the two-states motions as if they agreed with it. All the motions explicitly recognised Israel's right to exist — a point lost on the oh-so-principled Campaign Student and SWP who denounced SSiN precisely for that!

SSiN's position (Amendment One) was unique in one respect: it alone wanted to work both with the PLO and with progressive Israelis. SSiN's position specified clearly both Palestinian and Jewish rights. It was SSiN's opponents who used the issue as a political football — NOLS, the Communist Party, Students for Palestine, and Campaign Student.

The fact is they couldn't stand Amendment 1 purely because it was supported by SSiN and UJS. They couldn't stand Amendment 1 because it recognised the need for work with progressive Israelis.

In the same leaflet they made that clear. The "one force in the Middle East that can really take on imperialism and the Israeli state is the Arab working class". So for the SWP the entire Israeli Jewish proletariat has been written off as a class potentially capable of bringing about social change. For the SWP the Israeli Jewish working class are inherently reactionary. They are part of a "bad nation".

That is either downright stupid or anti-semitic. In any case, the SWP cannot claim any credit for their part in the debate. Despite their denunciations, it is they who are the opportunists.

Students for Palestine argued in an initial version of a leaflet later altered: "A group of Jews had the idea of setting up a Jewish nation towards the end of the last century. They were convinced that Jews were so different from other Europeans that they could not live together in peace. This is just what the Nazis believed and they tried to make it come true."

Whether the authors of this passage understood or intended its implications, this direct equation of Zionism and Nazism is grotesque and reinforces popular anti-semitic stereotypes (Jews as conspirators, underhand, etc).

As with the SWP, Students for Palestine sometimes supported Israel's right to exist and sometimes didn't, depending on who was proposing it — SSiN/UJS or NOLS.

NUS shouldn't work with Students for Palestine. For one thing there is nobody in it. And its politics stink.

NOLS supported the main motion — Israel's right to exist. They opposed the SSiN position because it had "some nice phrases but no action". Yet the 'action' in the SSiN motion — the 'instructs' section — was substantially the same as that in the main motion.

NOLS's 'hidden agenda' was simply to 'do over' SSiN and UJS. Politics were secondary, or even irrelevant.

NOLS could not stand the idea of the SSiN position being passed; they couldn't stand the idea of working with progressive Israelis, and more than that, they needed to write UJS out of the political equation.

So much so that when the UJS-backed Amendment 2 (which was indeed unbalanced) was passed, they proposed to extend the debate only long enough to take the amendment about academic freedom and not long enough for that on the PLO. The latter would have corrected the UJS motion's imbalance.

NOLS preferred NUS to come out with no policy rather than have Amendment Two passed with additions on academic freedom, women and support for the PLO.

Instead they wanted to move on to censure SSiN supporter Simon Pottinger.

This brings into doubt the actual content of the main motion. Although it acknowledged the right of the Israeli Jewish people to a state, much of it was attuned to the 'destroy Israel' school of thought. And there was no mandate to work with Jews either in the diaspora or in Israel. But it is not possible to have a genuine two-states position, without seeing a role for progressive Israelis.

It was not an adequate two-state position: perhaps that was why Campaign Student, Socialist Workers Party and NOLS could vote for it.

Two incidents illustrate the underlying sentiments of some delegates. During the discussion on Amendment 2, a delegate who had been called a 'fucking yid' tried to protest about it to the conference. President Vicky Phillips spoke against the Jewish delegate making a statement to the conference, in case it 'influenced' the debate.

Perhaps it would have influenced the debate — it would have shown that some opponents of the Israelis are purely and simply anti-semitic and perhaps it would have made other people think carefully about their own attitudes.

In refusing to allow the Jewish delegate to speak, Vicky Phillips was absolutely out of order; it is not surprising that she was called anti-semitic by another delegate.

What was an absolute disgrace was that Vicky Phillips, in her capacity as president, has announced her intention to sue the delegate who declared her comment to be anti-semitic!

Another example from NOLS was Pauline McNeil's speech on the composite motion on Soviet Jewry. Defending a Communist student for failing to do anything, Pauline alleged that criticism of him came from people who had a vendetta against him because of his position on the Middle East.

So who were the real opportunists?

SSiN voted for the UJS-backed motion. In doing so, SSiN made two real concessions. First, there was a clause describing Zionism as the Jewish national liberation movement, a view SSiN does not hold to. Second, the motion called for the PLO to recognise Israel as a precondition for participation in the peace process. SSiN believes Israel should recognise the PLO as the chosen representatives of the Palestinians immediately. (In fact in practice the PLO does recognise Israel's right to exist anyway).

SSiN had hoped to clarify this through the incorporation of an amendment calling for support for the PLO. But this was never discussed. The real opportunists were the SWP and Campaign Student, calling for one thing and voting for another.

Nor will being seen to have 'lined up with Zionists' be much of a vote-winner for SSiN, as the accusations have it. Possibly the reverse. Where NOLS, for example, were voting for purely factional considerations (revenge on the UJS, who voted for SSiN in the Executive elections last year, hatred of SSiN), SSiN stood by its principles. SSiN also did its best to explain its principles, which is more than can be said for most of its detractors.

The SSiN motion lost by ten votes. This represents a big step forward. The shift of the UJS from publicly uncritical support for Israel is equally significant. Next time the debate comes up — at next year's Christmas conference, perhaps — SSiN will win it.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 339

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →