Women and the socialist movement
Socialist Organiser1987 1987-12-10Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 5
An often-forgotten episode in of the international working-class movement is the mass women's organisation built in pre-First-World-Wa Germany under the leadership of Clara Zetkin. Lynn Ferguson looks at its haga (39f edmod d cecon af... 193943 achievements.
The development of large-scale about organising proletarian women. industry in the 19th century drew. In 1891 the first issue of Die Gleichheit (Equality) appeared, edited more and more women into facby Clara Zetkin. The paper was intory production. The old family tended as an education of women structures were beginning to party members. It was quite heavily break down, as women and theoretical, and Zetkin constantly argued within the SPD that it should children entered the labour force.
retain this bias. Other literature Many socialists at the time should be produced for working responded with horror. Surveying the women modelled on temperance misery and poverty of the urban literature — small, clear, agitational working class, they looked back to an pamphlets, setting out basic socialist imaginary golden age where men ideas. were the toilers and women and In her speech to the party congress children remained at home. in Gotha in 1896, Zetkin summarised In their desire to 'protect' women the existing Marxist analysis of 'the from the rigours of the factory woman question' and suggested ways system, some these utopian in which the SPD should attempt to socialists went so far as to argue for relate to and organise working class male workers to strike against women. women's employment. Women workers had to be organisThe attitude of the Marxists was ed into trade unions, and drawn different. Marx and Engels argued towards the party. For this a network that the precondition, not only for of 'vertrauenspersonen' was to be apthe liberation of women but of the pointed - women comrades who working class as a whole, was would take on the job of agitation women's participation in factory pro- and organisation amongst working duction. Isolation in the individual class women. home was not the answer - women should be able to develop as part of Prohibited the class, to be organised in trade unions and political parties. time was the German SPD. It was a The biggest Marxist party at the Anti-socialist laws in action in Germany at the time prohibited women mass party, with a whole plethora of from directly joining political cultural organisations and publica- organisations, so this form of tions. It was this party which provid- organisation was particularly impored the socialist movement with tant. Women were also prohibited model for organising women workers from joining the same trade unions as In 1879 August Bebel, leader of the men - one way they got around this SPD, published a book, •Woman was by the setting up of women's Under Socialism'. This explored the trade associations' which developed historical origins of women's subor- links with the corresponding 'men's" dination and presented a picture of what socialism would mean to The daily party press was to prowomen. duce special supplements for women.
The impact of the book was enor- Some were doing this already, but mous. By 1895 it had gone through Zetkin considered them far from ade25 editions in Germany alone, and quate. had been translated into several ...the daily press has regarded the languages. Ottilie Baader, a working proletarian woman as a subscriber, class woman activist, later Flattering her ignorance, rather than remembered: trying to enlighten her.
*I read it right through. It was my The women's organisation, as well own fate, and that of thousands of as unionising women, organised my sisters...I read the book not once discussion groups and produced but ten times." masses of pamphlets. In 1908 the *Woman Under Socialism' presented anti-socialist laws were repealed and a powerful indictment of capitalist women were legally able to become society, contrasted with a vision of party members. By 1910 there were the socialist future. It covered every over 189,000 women in trade unions, aspect of women's subordination, 82,000 women party members, and ranging from her economic position, Die Gleichheit had a circulation of through to sexual relations. 82,000. The circulation of Die Socialism will remove the Gleichheit peaked in 1913 at 112,000. economic pressures which force But the work amongst women was women into dependence on men. very much the task of the women parDomestic labour is socialised; society ty members themselves, and not the is organised on the basis of real, party as a whole. This was partly due direct democracy. Sexuality is able to to sexism, but there is a deeper develop undisturbed. reason. For, during this period the *The individual shall himself gulf between the right and left of the oversee the satisfaction of his own in- party was widening. stincts. The satisfaction of the sexual The party leadership concentrated instinct is as much a private concern more and more on purely parliamenas the satisfaction of any other tary politics, and was suspicious of natural instinct. the active agitational and organising In its day the book was a bomb- work being carried on by the shell, and a milestone in the develop- women's organisation. ment of a Marxist theory of women's Politically Zetkin and Die Gleichheit oppression. The task was now to set were consistently on the left, and atClara Zetkin tempts to marginalise Zetkin's work cannot be separated from the attempts by the right to squash the left.
At the outbreak of the First World War in 1914, the majority of the SPD representatives in the Reichstag voted for war credits, that is in support of the war, and the split became irreperable.
Die Gleichheit attempted to put a proletarian internationalist anti-war line. The SPD censored the paper. The women, in protest, produced it with white spaces revealing the extent to which they had been silenced. Ultimately Zetkin was removed as editor, and Die Gleichheit politically neutered.
Zetkin with other leftists, among them Rosa Luxemburg and Karl Liebknecht went on to form a new Communist Party and made attempts to continue some sort of communist work amongst women.
As for the SPD — its remaining women became leading cheerleaders for the war. And later, disgracefully, colluded with the state in the brutal murders of Luxemburg and Liebknecht.
The history of Zetkin's women's movement is frequently forgotten, but socialists have much to learn from it. The pioneering use of special methods to reach working women → the willingness to be completely flexible in the forms of organisation used - these offer vital lessons to the philistines of the Militant and SWP who hysterically denounce "autonomous' organisation as one-sidedly feminist and anti-working class.
The way the reformist leaders ultimately smashed the women's work only goes to show how closely tied the fate of women is with that of st chev -Socialist the working class.
The abandonment of serious attempts by the party to organise and educate women for socialism was the sharp end of its abandonment of any perspective of organising and leading the working class to fight for its own emancipation from wage slavery and state tyranny.
Workers Liberty with Zbigniew Kowalewski on Solidarnosc in Lodz, special feature on South Africa, survey, features, reviews. Se for your copy to SO, PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA. 90p plus 30p postage.
Organiser no.339 10 December 1987 Page
Scan page 6
The left scored a narrow victory at NUS conference — a very narrow victory.
In the debate on education, the amendment moved by Socialist Students in NOLS (SSiN) was carried by 8 votes. As a result, NUS is now committed to a more militant campaign - to make the government's Education Reform Bill (known in NUS as one 'GERBill') unworkable. There are to be mass lobbies of Parliament and a national shut-down of colleges together with a national demonstration.
NUS is to try to develop an education alliance' together with the trade union movement.
The campaign against YTS and JTS is to be intensified, and the right of Further Education students to be on their boards of governors will be defended.
In an important step, NUS decided to integrate the education campaign into the rest of its campaigns the Tories.
In the poll tax debate, the left also won a narrow victory. NUS is to support rent strikes by tenants and students whose rent is increased to pay for the poll tax. In addition, conference decided to oppose all councils, which make cuts, and voted for a campaign of non-compliance with the poll tax by students, colleges and councils. -The whole of NUS Executive was censured for failing to get campaign materials sent out to colleges by the start of term.
Activists in the colleges have had enough of the current Executive -enough of their inactivity, and enough of their bureaucratic factionalism towards the opposition.
What we need to do now is to pull together all those who want to fight to make sure that in the second term we can have campaigns that are so good that the disasters of the first term will be forgotten. Dear comrades, As you know better than we, Open letter resolution (amendment 2) far outweighed those parts of their
----- pull-quotes -----
ENORKERS' FABERTY