[Asian revolution, what kind of society the USSR…]
Socialist Organiser1987 1987-12-03Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 5
Asian revolution, what kind of society the USSR is today and we have focussed attention on Gorbachev's so-called 'reforms.
These are important issues and we Cathy Nugent examines the response are still far from understanding what goes on in the Soviet economy and the left to Gorbachev and his reforms society.
However, Socialist Organiser has been very clear about who we side with: we stand with the workers against the Russian bosses, the class and enjoys a sense of security killing of the German revolutio naries bureaucracy. Other socialists, par- and even a "greater influence on Karl Liebknecht and Rosa Li Ixemticularly those who claim to stand in public policy" than the working class burg and some of their compa nions the tradition of Trotsky' have not in the advanced capitalist countries is are qualitatively different in scope been so clear. At best there has been complete nonsense. Lower from Stalin's annihilation f the confusion, and at worst there has bureaucrats are not highly paid, but Bolshevik party and his suppre ession been the grossest kind of illusions. they do enjoy better education and of the Russian labour move: ment.
The 'best' is probably represented better housing. Those higher up in Stalin suppressed the la bour the hierarchy enjoy not just "perks" movements in Eastern Europe too, the newly formed International e.g. chauffeured cars and special after World War 2.
Socialist Group. The November- waiting rooms in stations, but in- The equivalent of what Stal linism December issue contains an article comes and lifestyles that stand out does to the working class is not *Gorbachev and the Left' by Oliver starkly when compared to the frugal Social Democracy has some times MacDonald. It is a discussion piece. reality of the lives of most Soviet done, but what fascism and re gimes MacDonald poses the question workers. like Pinochet's in Chile do. 1 s this thus: "Should socialists support Gor- In addition an important part of view 'revisionist'? Trotsky wa is the vachevism against Brezhnevism?" Gorbachev's 'reforms' is a drive for revisionist, then. In the pro gramThis strikes me as odd. Why should matic document he wrote fo r the we? Gorbachev represents only the Trotskyist movement in 1931 8, he interests of a privileged caste. declared that Stalin's political s ystem Although any lessening of political differed from fascism "only in more repression should be welcomed, it It's time the left unbridled savagery" does not follow that the bureaucracy will tolerate any kind of independent stopped living in century ago. But the straitjack Stalin's terror ended a third cet of a working : class activity. MacDonald fantasy world, the social, economic, politica F indoes not take up this point anywhere tellectual and moral straitjack iet — in his article. believing that the that Stalin imposed on the work ers of the USSR by way of that terrc or still minimise the fundamental conflict of Furthermore he attempts to USSR is 'nearly exists. Gorbachev is determin ed to interest between bureaucrats and socialist' and a maintain it. His liberal bureauc cratic' workers in the Soviet Union. He says reforms are designed to secure : that Leonard Shapiro and other reac- progressive force system and ensure that it can si arvive tionaries were right when they wrote in the modern world. *that the working class is the most world politics'. Socialist Action's editorial privileged class in the USSR and that. worse. "Gorbachev is the most rightthe reason for so few strikes has been wing leader the Soviet Union ha s ever less to do with the police than with had, " they say. Why? Becau se he the sense of security and well-being does deals with imperialism! among key groups of industrial The political framework tha it lies workers." behind these and most othe r inworking class 'economic discipline'.
MacDonald uses the example of coherent outpourings of Sociali: st Acthe relatively low wages of plant In practice it will mean speed-ups and tion is this. The world is divide d into more intense exploitation. The or- two camps: the goodies are the ! managers to back up his point: the economic privileges of the Soviet dinary Soviet workers will find their Union and other 'progressive' -DUO bureaucracy are marginal. It is their political power that is fundamental. Hence Gorbachev's moves towards jobs less secure. MacDonald fails to mentions this also — his political position is confused and, ultimately, imperialist' nations like East many, Poland, Cuba, Nicaragu: The baddies are the imperialist a, etc. West. Gerpolitical liberalisation are of immense he fails to take account of the real Gorbachev does deals witl 1 imsignificance, and MacDonald con- plight of the Russian working class perialism, so he is thus objec stively cludes by saying socialists should and defend their interests. right-wing. Indeed, Stalin, wh o put seriously consider taking a critical but The editorial in the last issue of tens of millions in slave-l abour supportive stance towards Gor- Socialist Action is a depressing exam- camps, was "left-wing' by combachev. -But to say that the working class in ple of Stalinist tainted dross. Entitled 1'70 years on" it is an attempt to parison! So presumably are, or Kim Il Sung in North Korea, Enver were, the Soviet Union is a 'privileged' draw up a balance sheet of the legacy Hoxha in Albania, and Pol F Pot in with it had disappeared the of the Russian Revolution: what the Cambodia! democracy of the Soviets, the trade Soviet Union stands for today. It also follows that "the USS R was unions, the co-operatives, the Socialist Action's "balanced" ac- the force that crushed fasc ism" cultural and athletic organisations. about count starts thus: "It is unnecessary True, millions of Russian wo orkers Above each and every one of them to recount here the crimes committed were killed on the Eastern front. there reigns an unlimited hierarchy of in the name of that revolution since it then was Stalin not interesti ed in party secretaries. The regime had occurred." To suggest that it is un- fighting fascism in 1939 whe en he become "totalitarian" in character necessary to recall Stalin's police made a pact with Hitler to join tly inseveral years before this word arrived State terror, to say that this does not vade, crush and partition Polar nd? from Germany. Rakovsky wrote in affect a socialist attitude to what the It really isn't necessary to o on. 1928: "By means of demoralising Soviet Union is today is sickening. Stalin's extreme terror is a thing of Stalinist rubbish you read, the The more of this confused more neomethods, which convert thinking the past — but the totalitarian police you realise that these people d o not communists into machines, destroy- state is very much a thing of the pre- live in the real world at all. The sy live ing will, character and human digni- sent. in a fantasy world of their own makty, the ruling circles have succeeded Why is it necessary to remember ing. They do not know whicl 1 side converting themselves into an Stalin? According to Socialist Action they are on between workers and unremovable and inviolate oligarchy special issue on the Stalin was no different in nature bureaucrats. which replaces the class and the par- from the Social Democrats who 'in It is time the left stopped livin g'in a ty." Russian Revolution. 1918 in Germany connived with the fantasy world, believing as So cialist Since those indignant lines were fascists to crush the revolution" Action evidently does, that the USSR This is goobledegook. Fascists were
----- pull-quotes -----
Available from SO, a revolution