Childish posturing
Socialist Organiser1987 1987-12-03Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 3
the We've seen a lot on the TV and in the press over the past months about child sex abuse.
The Cleveland case, where around 100 children were taken into care after medical diagnosis by Drs Marietta Higgs and Geoffrey Wyatt, opened up a wide-ranging debate about the causes, extent, and ways of dealing with child sex abuse.
But what of the left press? How has it responded?
The Militant position was set out in a centre-spread by Margaret Creear perhaps not unexpectedly titled 'Child Abuse sign of a sick society', In an article which slips and slides. confusingly between child abuse in general and child sex abuse, the issues raised by the Cleveland affair itself are left untouched. As you might expect, socialism is the answer, and there is virtually no attempt to answer the admittedly horrifyingly difficult question of what can be done in the here and now.
Creear does, however, in places, show a tendency, unusual in a Militant writer, to think about the causes of abuse. At one point she rejects the idea of a direct relation between economic deprivation and abuse. Sadly, she falls back on the old bland generalities a few paragraphs later, asserting "Without a struggle against unemployment, to talk about reducing child abuse is wishful thinking", Creear is right when she points to class society, and the distorting effect it has on personal relationships, as the ultimate culprit. But that's an empty platitude when it comes to helping the victims of child abuse now.
Socialist Worker adopts the *socialism is the answer' approach, though to its credit it does attempt some discussion of the immediate issues. It opposes the witch-hunt of Higgs and Wyatt, while questioning the procedures which were used in Cleveland when children were removed from their homes on purely medical evidence, and far from conclusive evidence at that.
The thrust of the article is criticism of the medical and social work professionals as middle-class people who don't understand how the working class lives. But no amount of being Marxist and working-class will magically give you better judgment on medical and social-work problems. Socialist Worker ends up blustering instead of thinking seriously about this immensely complex and serious subject I hesitate to mention Workers' Power, for fear of bolstering their mindbogglingly massive collective However, enough to have to deal with it.
Workers' Power makes a big thing about what they delicately call "intergenerational sex' - that's paedophilia to the rest of us. Child sex abuse, they tell us, must be distinguished from consensual sex between adults and children, which is OK.
I have racked my brains, but I can't conceive of such consensual sex. Many sexually abused children 'consent" - to please adults they love and trust, or because they are too scared, or too bewildered, or too young, to say no.
Children are highly dependent on adults, and especially so in this society. They are conditioned to 'be good and do as you're told'. It is utter nonsense to talk about 'consensual inter-generational sex".
But Workers' Power hysterically accuse those who favour the retention of an age of consent as providing some sort of protection for children of "scabbing on youth".
This sort of loud-mouthed leftier-thanthou'-ism, so typical of Workers' Power, ends up diminishing the reality of child sex abuse in the name of sexual liberalism.
Children do have a sexuality, which they should be free to express and discover without shame. But children's sexuality is fundamentally different from that of adults. Most children play 'doc tors and nurses' and other such rames but that's a long way from penetrative s with an adult.
The real people who "scab on youth" those who rate the physical and emotio well-being of children lower than th own political posturing.
Scan page 4
In this excerpt from 'The Revolution Betrayed', Leon Trotsky traces the transformation of the Bolshevik party from an instrument of working-class revolution to part of the bureaucratic totalitarian apparatus of the Stalinist Lenin addresses Russian workers while Trotsky looks on. The Stalinists later painted Trotsky out of this picture police state.
The Bolshevik party prepared and insured the October victory. It also created the Soviet state, supplying it with a sturdy skeleton. The degeneration of the party became both cause and consequence bureaucratization of the state. It is necessary to show at least briefly how this happened.
The inner regime of the Bolshevik party was characterised by the method of democratic centralism. The combination of these two concepts, democracy and centralism, is not in the least contradictory. The party took watchful care not only that its boundaries should always be strictly defined, but also that all those who entered these boundaries should enjoy the actual right to define the direction of party policy. Freedom of criticism and intellectual struggle was an irrevocable content of the party democracy. The present doctrine that Bolshevism does not tolerate factions is a myth of the epoch of decline.
Factions In reality the history of Bolshevism is a history of the struggle of factions. And, indeed, how could a genuinely revolutionary organisation, setting itself the task of overthrowing the world and uniting under its banner the most audacious iconoclasts, regarded not as a principle, but as an episodic act of self-defence.
The swift growth of the ruling party, with the novelty and immensity of its tasks, inevitably gave rise to inner disagreements. The underground oppositional currents in the country exerted a pressure through various channels upon the sole legal political organisation, increasing the acuteness of the factional struggle. At the moment of completion of the civil war, this struggle took such sharp forms as to threaten to unsettle the state power.
In March, 1921, in the days of the Kronstadt revolt, which attracted into its ranks no small number of Bolsheviks, the tenth congress of the party thought it necessary to resort to a prohibition of factions - that is, to transfer the political regime prevailing in the state to the inner life of the ruling party. This forbidding of factions was again regarded as an exceptional measure to be abandoned at the first serious improvement in the situation. At the same time the Central Committee was extremely cautious in applying the new law, concerning itself most of all lest it lead to a strangling of the inner life of the party.
However, what was in its original design merely a necessary concession to a difficult situation proved perfectly suited to the taste of the bureaucracy, which had then begun to approach the inner life of the party exclusively from the viewpoint of