Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Working-class politics and the Gulf war

Socialist Organiser no. 338, 3 December 1987 · scan p. 3 · about 1,337 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

What attitude should socialists take towards 'anti-imperialist' movements in the world today? 'Anti-imperialism' has come to mean everything and nothing, and the Left needs to be clear about who it supports and why.

The current Gulf War poses many of these issues sharply.

And much of the left has simply fallen behind Khomeini's 'antiimperialism'. A good example is the Socialist Workers' Party.

The SWP is a small organisation which chooses to isolate itself on the fringes of the labour movement. Usually it is more sophisticated and rational in its politics than are the other sectarian "Trotskyist" organisations. Here its views epitomise the worst of the anti-imperialist" confusion you will find on the would-be revolutionary left. Its views are therefore more significant than the SWP and for that reason worth discussing. *The counter-revolution was pushed forward under the guise Fighting importeliem? of Khomeini's phoney 'antiimperialism' and consolidated regime. with the development of the Gull has a fleet in the area and has swung War...The war...provided more fully behind Iraq. The US has perfect cover for the regime's moved in to ensure there is no Iranian wiping out of any remnants of victory. But can such US involvement dictate a socialist attitude to the war? left-wing opposition"

That was the verdict of Maryam whose side we are on in any conflict Poya writing in the Socialist purely by inverse reaction, we lose all Workers' Party's book *Revolu- ability to make independent tionary Rehearsals" about the Ira- judgements. We write ourselves out nian experience (pp.162-3). Yet now, of the script. the SWP argue, things have changed quite drastically. Today the SWP is and whomsoever it supports seems a four-square behind Iran in the Gulf good rough guide. But it isn't in War. Afghanistan, or Poland - and nor *In these circumstances a victory would automatic support for for Iraq is a victory for imperialism" whoever opposes the USSR be a good says Alex Callinicos (Socialist rough guide. We need clearer criteria. Worker, November 28). "It would be a major set-back for anti-imperialists every bourgeois and Stalinist in every part of the world." demagogue across the "Third World'.

Or as Tony Cliff argues, backing him up at the SWP Conference it provided a cover for COLLECL debate on the issue: "We are for revolution. Yet according to military victory. The key question is Callinicos, the Khomeini whether SHOE you fight im- perialism. or not you This aspect or slamic rundamchSo what has changed to so in- talism has made it an validate the SWP's previous force. judgement? Only months ago, the Gulf War was a reactionary war they opposed on both sides. Now, Iran's war is an anti-imperialist struggle to as so). which they give "military" support without "politically" supporting the going. It is possible to oppose imperialism from a reactionary standpoint. And Khomeini does so. 2til The Communist 4NA. 01-639 7965 Latest date for reports: first Ponderi and similar trends, Monday evening combine the liberation Editor: John O'Mahony.

Typesetting: Upstream (TU) perialism with attempt Ltd. 01-358 1344. landowners and mullahs. "l Published by Socialist Organiser, PO Box 823, approach and the SWP's is striking. London SE15 4NA.

Printed by East End Offset (TU), London E2.

Registered as a newspaper at the Post Office.

igned articles do no ecessarily reflect the view c tionaries, because wel suppor ASIASTY tional liberation. And short of What has changed is that the US socialism, the rational meaning of "anti-imperialism' is precisely national liberation.

But is national liberation an issue in the Gulf War? Iran is a fully independent state (Callinicos even corAbsolutely not. If we determine rectly calls it a 'sub-imperialism'). It is indeed the brutal oppressor of national minorities.

If the US were seeking to invade Iran in order to conquer it, or at least in order to impose a pro-American Often, taking sides against the US government - if the national rights of Iran were really at stake - what the SWP say would make some sense.

"Anti-imperialism' is the war cry of But the national rights of Iran are not at stake; the conflict within the US is As the SWP themselves argue, in Iran restricted to the Gulf waters - there is no threat of US invasion or colonisation of Iran. Nor is such a "presents itself as as anti-imperialist. development very likely.

So despite the US's direct involvement, the issues involved in the Gulf War remain what they were. The war For socialists it is not enough that has not fundamentally changed its people are 'against' imperialism (still character. less that they "present themselves" Yet the SWP seem to think that the change of character is so fundamenare, what they want, where they are tal that Iran is no longer part of the world' • As we have seen, for Callinicos a US victory would be a *set-back for anti-imperialists in every part of the world". But what its Second Congress in 1920 spelt out would an Iranian victory mean for socialist attitude. They specified the workers and oppressed of Iran? "the need to combat Pan-Islamism The war always has been used by the regime to divert internal opposition.

This function of the war is greater against European and American im- now that the US is directly involved.

Even outside Iran, it is by no strengthen the position of the Khans, means clear that the 'antiimperialism' — i.e. right-wing Of course 1987 is not 1920. But the Islamic fundamentalism - that an difference between the Comintern's Iranian victory would strengthen would serve working class interests.

We do not support people because Tony Cliff, continuing Callinicos's of what they oppose; we support peo- grotesque analogy with the Spanish le because we give positive suppor Civil War, puts the issue bluntly: "If to their objectives. We support na you give no support to Iran it means tional liberation struggles, even if that you support every strike. (But) if they are led by bourgeois reac- arms are going to the front, ilwaymen should not go on strike.

Are these guns going to the front to be used against fascists attempting to drown a revolutionary movement in blood? Are they even to be used against US marines?

Of course not. The front for which Tony Cliff feels such new-found enthusiasm is with Iraq. They are to be used against Iraqi workers and peasants.

In the Spanish Civil War socialists could say to the fascist soldiers: join with us; abandon Franco, Join the revolution. Can Iranian socialists on the front call on Iraqis to join the Iranian side? The idea is absurd. They should continue to say what the SWP agrees they should have said in the past: we, the workers of Iran and Iraq, should refuse to fight each other; we should join together and overthrow both our ruling classes. A US flotilla and US support for the Iraqi government could not possibly justify Iranian socialists abandoning that argument in favour of support for the current war, no matter how 'critical' they might be of Khomeini's methods.

The SWP's argument would in reality look like this: We, Iranian workers, don't politically support our government. But, because of the presence of the US fleet, in our view we are justified in killing our brothers and sisters in Irag. Like it or not, that is the argument.

As a group of Iranian Marxists has expressed it:

*The fact that the best way to oppose imperialism is to oppose both the Iranian regime and the imperialist intervention seems to be beyond comprehension. According to (groups like the SWP) the oppressed in Iran must...forget...their exploitation and suppression is being organised by this capitalist regime and hope for the situation in which these very same oppressors have given a "bloody nose" to the "Americans" . And this is, presumably, supposed to soften the mullahs' heart against the Iranian masses." politics in favour of a fake anti- The SWP have abandoned imperialism' which, if Iranian socialists were to heed their advice, would pave the way for more defeats.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 338

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →