Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Yuriy Badzyo: 'the right

Socialist Organiser no. 337, 26 November 1987 · scan p. 10 · about 1,019 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

But we have a problem. We can comment on unfair sentences, but short of becoming judges, we can't actually lengthen them. The question therefore is: what do we campaign for as an answer to rape? And a campaign for longer sentences' would pose a lot of difficulties.

We could campaign for a higher minimum sentence. But that might not solve the question, and might lead to more rapists getting off, as juries could be more reluctant to convict. And sexist judges would probably stick to the minimum. -A more vaguely defined campaign for longer sentences would not help. We might want it to be part of a broader policy, but it would be unlikely to be. For in reality, most of those who argue for heavier sentences do so in isolation and don't understand the wider social issues. Gutter press tabloids that bay for the blood of 'sex fiends' and other 'beasts' are hardly campaigners for women's liberation. The call for heavier sentences in fact forms part of right-wing calls for "law and order' and so on.

We do have a responsibility to explain that rape is rooted in women's oppression and isn't just a crime of sex-crazed individuals and that therefore individual punishments won't make r pe go away.

That doesn't mean that we are oblivious to the real suffering rape causes or should stand in self-satisfaction on the sidelines with the "need to change society" as a handy cop-out. We should campaign for real changes, including changes in the law (so that rape in marriage is legally recognised, ete).

But we shoald neither lose sight of our general view of things, nor allow ourselves to aid the law and order' backlash fuelled by the popular press.

GERRY BATES, South London Yuriy Badzyo was arrested in 1979 and sentenced to seven years in a hard-labour camp and five years internal exile on charges of "anti-Soviet agitation and propaganda".

The basis for this charge was treatise entitled "The Right to Live" which examined Soviet nationality policy towards the Ukraine, the falsification of Ukrainian history and the russification of the Ukrainian language and culture.

At the beginning of this year the Soviet authorities requested him to write a petition for a pardon. He refused and instead wrote to M. Gorbachev in June arguing that all the problems he posed in his study still remained unsolved.

In August he received permission to visit his sick elderly mother in the Ukraine from his place of exile. But this permission was revoked when he arrived in Kiev. Badzyo complained to various Soviet authorities about his treatment, which is the subject of this appeal written on 31 August. Badzyo argues that "at the heart of the social and political ideology of my treatise, "The Right to Live" ', lies the concept of democratic socialism" and "the ideas of democracy, freedom and cooperation are the keynote of all my public statements"

Badzyo criticises the indifferent West:

*And we Ukrainians have learned once again that politicians and the public in the West, and in particular the Western media, treat us as no more than material to be used for propaganda purposes. They forget" that we are a nation, a separate and self-contained subject of history, with our own legitimate listorical needs and interests"

Badzyo believes that:

- My world outlook, political conduct, and emotional responses to situations are far from extremist, and I am not prone to immoderate responses to situations. I already knew and now have new confirmation of the sad truth that in terms of the historival needs and prospects of An appeal by Ukrainian socialist oppositionist Yuriy Badzyo the Ukrainian people today's world is blind and deaf to our fate. " The attempts by the Kiev authorities, "citing an order from Moscow" , to prevent him visiting his mother he described as "almost certainly her last chance to see her son and bid him good-bye forever.

Badzyo wrote to various Soviet departments but he did not receive a single response and he feels "as if we were in a torture chamber" . Badzyo states that "even if there were no high-sounding declarations by the government about the revolutionary restructuring and democratisation of Soviet society" he would find it all the more contemptible the way he has been treated because he refused to write a petition for a pardon. Badzyo is not completely surprised as he has *spent a considerable portion of my life amidst a thick fog of official lies, demagoguery, oppression, and abuse"

The way the authorities have treated him is in revenge for his refusal to yield and it seriously questions the "very essence of the government's proclamations about reforms". • Badzyo goes on to state:

"I interpret what the government has done as serious proof of its true ideological and moral nature, of the real intentions of the initiators ofi restructuring, and of the possibility and prospects of revolution trom above"] Such a disregard for the law, Badzyo believes, "is possible only when public opinion does not exist, or when the authorities know that there will be no reaction from world public opinion" - During the 1960s and 1970s, the Ukraine, 'has suffered perhaps the harshest repressions and the largest human losses. Ine reaction of the world to our situation has been and remains outrageously indifterent and sell-seeking. Great-power and ethnic egoism reigns in the attitude towards us where one might expect simple human sympathy and to have produced active solidarity with our plight.

Disregard of the Ukrainian problem and Ukrainophobia cannot but have its historical consequences.."

Badzyo appeals to the United Nations, Western delegations to the national and goes on to say that "the lasting and sound betterment of international life on the principles of stable peaceful coexistence and cooperation cannot occur without a complete and genuinely revolutionary democratisation of the Soviet Union, and the democratisation of the USSR is impossible without democracy for the Ukraine, without a democratic resolution of the Ukrainian question, that is, in practical terms, without the attainment by the Ukrainian people of national independence, of real and complete control over its historical existence"

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 337

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →