Dodging the issuers Lynn Ferguson looks at Socialist THE BATTER FRUTS DE
Socialist Organiser1987 1987-11-26Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
of British Rule' — you would think it was BRI SHRULE sionals.
The problem with Sinn Fein and the IRA is that over the years they have settled into fighting a war of attrition as a Catholic, not a working-class socialist or even an all-Irish nationalist organisation. They have given up on any hope of talking to the Protestant workers.
This is understandable. The Protestant workers are often very bigoted. But a struggle based narrowly on the Catholic minority in the North — 10% of all the Irish people - can never achieve a united Ireland. If it is a military struggle, the "most' it can achieve is to trigger an all-out sectarian civil war — which the Catholics would not win.
A socialist movement needs to be built, which unites Catholic and Protestant workers around socialist aims and a consistently democratic programme for Ireland - a federal united Ireland with local autonomy for the mainly Protestant area.
So long as the Northern Ireland state exists, violence will continue. The deep sectarian hostilities arise in part trom the structure of that state. It is possible to build a movement that breaks down the divisions. British socialists can help by distancing ourselves entirely from the actions of successive British governments, Tory and Labour, and helping Irish socialists and Republicans to develop a democratic programme to unite Ireland. KEN Livingstone brought a storm about his head when, immediately after the Enniskillen massacre, he said that Britain should withdraw from Northern The hypocritical press raged, and so did Neil Kinnock. Livingstone condemned the Enniskillen slaughter, but the press didn't want to notice. A number of Labour MPs demanded that Livingstone, a member of Labour's National Executive, should be expelled from the Parliamentary Neil Kinnock laid into Livingstone: *British withdrawal would spread the slaughter not only in Northern Ireland, but in the Republic of Ireland and mainland Britain as well"
Now Livingstone is a capable selfpublicist. He knows the press game. He is a past master at playing it. His history shows that he is a calculating man, and a self-regarding one.
He must have known what would follow his comments at this time, and he must have wanted it to happen. He must have thought the publicity would be good for his standing on the left. He may be right.
In any case Livingstone should have the right to say what he likes. It is not for the hypocritical and bloodthe front-page article nor the editorial, "The Only Way Out', contained that demand. Instead lt argued in mirytale fashion that basic, elementary socialist agitation is the answer — to magically unite the rish workers and sweep away the problems.
-In its issue-dodging verbosity, SW left all the major questions unanswered or glossed over in a few banal phrases.
What is the British state doing in Ireland now? What does the British government want? We got a potted history of the last 65 years, with the evil British state duping the Protestants into acting as their agents in the North.
The evidence of the past few years — where the British state clearly draws no Fi aduatania aduandona luam Nan prom or suage suvamage mom aus thern Ireland, and is trying to get some sort of settlement that the Protestants do not like — was completely ignored. Why did the Anglo-Irish deal lead to an Orange backlash? What does this tell us about British government policy towards Ireland? SW seems neither to know nor to care.
On the Protestant working class SW is particularly incoherent. On the one hand the Protestants are reactionary bigots bought off by the British state. But by magic they can be won over to the struggle for a united Ireland by throwing in a bit of socialist propaganda.
SW's basic argument is that It is British rule that is the source of Northern Ireland's problems". Sinn Fein has got that right. However, their "methods" will not win sufficient mass support. So what has to be done is to use "socialist politics" to persuade the Southern Catholics and Northern Protestants to throw in their lot with the Northern Catholics. "Socialist politics" are defined as bread-and-batter demands on jobs, housing and wages.
This is an odd jumble of nationalism and economism. SW accepts the nationalist view of the issues, and recommends socialism only as a means to the greater nationalist end. Moreover, since when has SW reckoned that *socialist politics" are an instant recipe for mass support? In Britain they argue that the thirsty Sun, which gloated when the British Navy sent a shipful of Argentinians to the bottom of the South Atlantic, or the other Tory rags, to tell a Labour MP what he can or cannot say.
And what is Neil Kinnock's policy for Ireland? He doesn't have one. On paper Labour is committed to a united Ireland - but since the Anglo-Irish Agreement was signed two years ago, Labour's front bench has re-established a common front with the Tories on Ireland. If Labour were to form a government now, Neil Kinnock would do exactly what the Tories are doing.
He has learned nothing from Labour's record in the 1970s. He has not learned that the status quo in Northern Ireland is fundamentally untenable. Under a Kinnock government, Labour's united Ireland policy would be a dead letter.
Nevertheless, much of what Kinnock said against Livingstone is true! That is the measure of the Labour Left's confusion on Ireland.
Troops out without a political settlement would not lead to a united Ireland, but to sectarian civil war and a new partition. Kinnock is right about that, and Livingstone (together with the Campaign Group of MPs, very attempt to win majority support -in ballots and elections - drags you into reformism, and the only true socialists are those who base themselves on the combative minority. Why then in Ireland is it wrong to base yourself on a combative minority, and why then in Ireland is socialism synonymous with winning the majority?
More than that: the history of Northern Ireland has many examples of ProtestantCatholic worker unity around economic questions. That unity has always shattered when the question of the Border was raised. A Protestant worker can very well be convinced about socialism and workers' rights, yet prefer to be part of a socialist Britain rather than a socialist Ireland. You can't dodge the national question by talking about something else economics - instead.
Our job is to work out a programme to unite the Irish working class. The Protestant workers have their own history and culture, and form a distinct national minority. They have a genuine fear of becoming an oppressed minority in a Catholic united Ireland. Any programme to unite the working class has to tackle this problem, not just sweep it under the carpet.
The fundamental problem in Northern Ireland is not 'British rule' , but a deeply divided working class. That has to be the starting point for socialists. We want to see Britain withdraw and Ireland united. and independent - because we think that, if the united Ireland has adequate provision for the Protestants' rights, that is the best framework for developing the working-class struggle. But to get it we need to address the issues. SW dodges them.
whose statement we reprint) is wrong.
The central problem in Ireland is the chronic antagonism and division between the two Irish communities. That predates Partition, and would continue - and express itself murderously — if Britain withdrew without a political settlement.
Partition, and the brutal, uncomprehending, and indifferent policy of successive British governments, have made things worse. Britain's rule in Northern Ireland is a holding operation for the status quo, not a solution.
The only democratic solution is a united Ireland with federal institutions that allow local autonomy to the Protestants. That united Ireland would probably have much closer links with Britain that the 26 Counties have had since their secession from the UK in 1922, but they would be voluntary links, not links secured by British troops on the streets.
Kinnock is right against the dominant view on the left. But Kinnock represents the Labour and trade union Establishment - and he may one day represent the British Establishment as prime minister. Kinnock is incapable of learning The serious left can learn. But it needs to learn to deal with the facts of Irish reality.